Verified Document

Show The Similarities Term Paper

¶ … Thomas Szasz's the Myth of Psychotherapy and Bilingual Education in Richard Rodriguez's Hunger for Memory How can psychotherapy be a myth? How can the internal speculation in regards to the soul be wrong? However, both Richard Rodriguez's Hunger for Memory and Thomas Szasz's The Myth of Psychotherapy say that the current cultural obsession with self-reflection and the idea that reconstituting, reliving, and recapturing memory, at least in an idealized and primal 'perfect' form is impossible, a lie, and would be dangerous to the psyche and soul's self-development and sense of efficacy in the world, if this were possible. Szasz critiques modern psychotherapy as an attempt to make morality a mental and medical issue. Rodriguez critiques modern moral educators within the educational establishment whom would excuse poor performance by minority students, and students from non-English speaking homes. Both suggest objective, external standards to live up to, rather than internal reflection is the answer to the sense of depression and disenfranchisement so endemic to modern life.

Hunger for Memory chronicles the autobiography of a young, once-Spanish speaking, now primarily English-speaking young man, of the journey of a Mexican-American named Richard Rodriguez who 'made good' and lived the American dream. Yet although Rodriguez states that he has reaped the benefits of material and academic success, he feels alienated from his culture and of the political emphasis of reconstituting one's roots in modern America. This is particularly in terms of language, the author states. Rodriguez, after all, began his schooling in a primarily English-speaking school in Sacramento, California. He knew only a few words of English but Spanish was the primary language of his home.

Likewise, The Myth of Psychotherapy discusses the modern alienation of truth from language. Rather than truly articulating one's desires, however,...

This is not simply true of theoretical constructs however. Even from a personal perspective, to become the man of the later part of his autobiographical text, Richard Rodriguez's early life and language had to be shorn, the author states that he feels in no uncertain terms. To succeed he had to become the embodiment "of the scholarship boy who returns home one summer to discover the bewildering silence, facing his parents. This is my story. An American story," Rodriguez writes.
Morality and the need to meet societal and linguistic standards are thus viewed as crucial to education by Richard Rodriguez, and crucial to his current success. Rodriquez measures his success by external terms, the fact that today he can be found in the reading room of the British Library, rather than in the barrio or worse, in jail. Szasz does not argue from a personal perspective, but he reminds the reader that until recently, with the popularization of psychoanalytic lingo in the media and in the court system, "bad" and "immoral" were terms used to describe people who are now referred to as "sick" and "in need of treatment."

The moral and religious perspective of the past has been clearly replaced by medical and therapeutic rhetoric of the present, encouraging excuses rather than the hard work embodied by the scholastic efforts of individuals such as Rodriguez, says Szasz. Thus, it is of little wonder that the world is plagued by those who use the langue of excuses and addictions and mental sickness, rather than attempt to ameliorate their own morality, because there is no incentive in society for them to do so, and every incentive provided to make excuses for their lack of success through modern psychotherapeutic claims that these moral deficits are in fact cognitive deficits…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Rodriguez, Richard. Hunger Of Memory. New York: Bantam Books, 1983

Szasz, Thomas. The Myth of Psychotherapy: Mental Healing As Religion, Rhetoric, and Repression. Syracuse: Syracuse University Press, 1988.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Similarities and Differences in the Characters Beowulf and Grendel...
Words: 844 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

character similarities and differences between Grendel and Beowulf based on the classic poem, Beowulf. I would like some specific quotations (at least 5) to support the paragraphs in which the two characters are compared. Beowulf and Grendel are two of the key protagonists of the poem. Both are similar in that they fight for what they believe and are courageous. Both are dissimilar in that whilst Beowulf is popular and

Similarities and Differences Between African Americans and Hispanics...
Words: 4693 Length: 15 Document Type: Research Paper

Hispanics and 40,375,000 African-Americans live in the United States and the respective percentages of these population groups are projected to continue to increase well into the foreseeable future. The purpose of this study was to provide descriptions of these two cultures and why they are of interest as well as a comparison of similarities and differences related to time orientation, communication, physical and mental health, group relationships, and perceptions

Similarities and the Differences Between the Shi Tes and the Sunnis...
Words: 1546 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Shi'a and Sunna Islam The early origins and history of Islam as a religious organization is unified under the teachings and leadership of Muhammad, who was considered the Prophet of Allah, the God of the Muslims. When Muhammad died, the problem of handing over the leadership of Muhammad became a problem, since there are many Muslims who had claimed leadership of the Muslim religion, many factions were created. Upon Muhammad's

Similarities Between World War I And Modern Warfare
Words: 1178 Length: 4 Document Type:

World War I is fundamentally similar to warfare as it is practiced today. This paper reviews the relevant literature to provide evidence in support of the argument that World War I is fundamentally similar to warfare as it is practiced today. Major and Supporting Points of Evidence There were numerous innovations in military ordnance and munitions that took place during and following the U.S. Civil War, but the purpose of the warfare

Similarities and Differences Between Christianity and Islam
Words: 1003 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Christianity and Islam: A Clash of Civilizations Ever since the beginning of the 7th century CE, the relationship between Christianity and Islam has been characterized by wariness and suspicions, feelings that became especially pronounced following the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001 in the United States. Today, the billions of Christian and Muslim adherents have squared off in their respective ideological corners and scarcely a day goes by without the headlines

Similarities and Differences Between Virtual and Traditional Teams...
Words: 1031 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Identifying Best Practices for Supporting Virtual Teams About half of all multinational corporations already use virtual teams in some capacity, and current trends indicate that they will become increasingly commonplace in the future (Minton-Eversole, 2012). Although definitions vary, virtual teams are typically regarded as being comprised of a group of individuals that are located in different geographic locations who communicate primarily through collaborative electronic communications platforms (Minton-Eversole, 2012). Given their growing

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now