¶ … ship called the MV Sun Sea carrying 490 asylum seekers from Sri Lanka, was intercepted off the B.C. coast. The arrival of these Tamil migrants sparked a controversy as to how Canada should receive Tamil and other potential refugees fleeing Southeast Asia. On one side of the controversy, Canadian officials voiced concern that the migrants could be criminals and terrorists, and should not be allowed to enter Canadian borders. On the other hand, these accusations could have been utterly baseless, originally espoused by the Sri Lankan government for the purpose of deflecting international attention from their human rights abuses. Indeed, screenings of 76 Tamil migrants who arrived from Sri Lanka in October 2009 revealed that all were eligible to claim political refugee status, despite rumors that they might have had criminal ties. The recent debate regarding whether to accept the Tamil migrants on the MV Sun Sea was reminiscent of similar controversies that have taken place throughout Canadian history, dating back as early as the 1914 arrival of 376 Indians at Vancouver on the Komagata...
The similarities between Canada's rejection of the migrant Southeast Asian population aboard the Komagata Maru in 1914, and the aversion to the Southeast Asian migrants aboard the MV Sun Sea in 2010, raises questions as to whether Canadian border policies are grounded in racism and xenophobia, or legitimate security interests.Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now