Verified Document

Shawnee A Counterpoint To The Essay

" (Atkinson, 1) This is an important divergence of approaches, not simply because it dispenses with the ordinary telling of this story but also because it recasts the way we might understand the death of the Shawnee tribes. Where the caricature of the heroic and generally lionized Tecumseh is concerned, there is a tendency to vest too much stock in the role played by a single charismatic leader in defining the suffering and ambition of the Shawnee people. Edmunds' work is an accomplishment particularly for undoing the myth that a single people can be defined thusly. By shifting his focus to Tecumseh's counterpoint, a religiously inclined brother who prioritized conflict over unity, and especially by framing the conclusion of this story according to the placement of the Shawnee on a reservation, Edmunds succeeds in demonstrating the scale of this atrocity in a way that histories centering on a single man cannot.

Instead of making the narrative suggestion that the death of a hero in battle caused the end of the Shawnee people, Edmunds makes it clear that this was in fact a systematic dismantling of a culture millennia in the making which was culminated by the displacement of those who might have otherwise carried on a Shawnee legacy. This helps to promote a more realistic understanding of the cultural imposition and practical impediments to native survival.

If the text may be said to have any weakness, it is perhaps the underwhelming focus on Tecumseh. Though the emphasis on his brother is a welcome point of divergence and is also justified by the purpose of the text, this same purpose might have been more effectively served by a comparative analysis of the two. Many readers will have entered into this text with a familiar grounding in Tecumseh's...

These readers would benefit from a comprehensive separating of myth and fact, particularly as these may be illuminating in the story of Tenskwatawa. With respect to the relative lack of probing consideration of Tecumseh, we lose the opportunity to understand Tenskwatawa as a counterpoint.
This is even further magnified when the reader in question does not possess a great deal of background in Shawnee studies. Though there is a value in diminishing the singularity of a focus on Tecumseh, for the novice reader there is also something lost in the degree to which he is overshadowed. In the assessment conducted here, we can see that there is a distinct value in using the two brothers as reference points for understanding one another. Indeed, the greatest service performed by this text is in the way that it trains our focus toward the balance between native acquiescence and native resistance. A more critical discussion on both brothers might serve this interest with more acuity.

Ultimately, this is less a criticism of the work in question than a suggestion that its impulses could be served through yet a more probing evaluation of the chosen subject matter. But as a historical text, Edmunds' work is a compelling one, told in a linear and highly readable style that brings its subject very much to life. Thus, as a point of entry on the Shawnee people, it is not highly recommended. Instead, as a strand in a body of research on the Shawnee people, Edmunds has contributed a volume rife with insights and points of interest.

Works Cited:

Atkinson, D.D. (2007). Review: The Shawnee Prophet by R. David Edmunds. Blogtide Rising.

Edmunds, R.D. (1985). The Shawnee Prophet. University of Nebraska Press.

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited:

Atkinson, D.D. (2007). Review: The Shawnee Prophet by R. David Edmunds. Blogtide Rising.

Edmunds, R.D. (1985). The Shawnee Prophet. University of Nebraska Press.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Cultural Assimilation According to the Mosby Medical
Words: 875 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Cultural Assimilation According to The Mosby Medical Encyclopedia, cultural assimilation is a process by which members of an ethnic minority group lose cultural characteristics that separate them from the main cultural group (Cultural pp). In the September 22, 2000 issue of Daedalus, Dorothy Steele writes that the assimilation of millions of immigrants into one society is what defines America, however in the shadows, millions of nonimmigrant minorities, such as African-Americans, Native American

Assimilation in the American Culture
Words: 382 Length: 1 Document Type: Term Paper

Stronger connections with family and other persons from the same country are also formed (Lee). Another gain for immigrants can be experienced from partly assimilating with the mainstream of American culture, even while retaining what is best of the original culture. What results is then a combination of the original and the new culture in order to form something new. This new culture then becomes part of the "melting pot"

Cultural Differences Human Relations and
Words: 1642 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

Cultural belief can shape and integrate "the expectations that pattern the relationships among a social structures constituent and statuses and roles" (Schooler, 1996:323). Conclusions Culture includes the attitudes, values and beliefs an individual or group adopt and consider normal in everyday society. Within and given society, differences in culture exist, and these differences impact human relations. Also within a society of different cultures, assimilation occurs, where ethnic groups adopt what are

Cultural Evaluation Japan Describe Identify Ways Arguments
Words: 824 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Cultural evaluation Japan describe identify ways arguments a presentation arguments changed result cultural differences Rose Cohen. Out of the Shadow: A Russian Jewish Girlhood on the Lower East Side, with an Introduction by Thomas Dublin. (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1995). Pp. vii-313. Paper: $19.95. ISBN: 978-0-8014-8268-7. Rose Cohen was born in Russia at the end of the 19th century and immigrated to the United States of America in the early part

Cultural Identity and Personal Perspective
Words: 1201 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

S. without fluent English language skills. I have always felt that my upbringing allowed me the maximum possible benefit of American society without detracting from my ability to appreciate my culture of origin. In that regard, I have always felt very confident in public and in my interpersonal relationships; I have never felt like an immigrant or a foreign national and part of my personal identity definitely includes "American" components that

Cultural Assimilation and Sociological Perspectives
Words: 1836 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Sociology Applying the Sociological Perspective: An Iraq Soldier's Story This research conducted surrounding this interviewee focuses on the reasons why a soldier's resiliency levels are so high considering the two massive injuries endured. The interviewee above demonstrates a considerable amount of resiliency after his time in combat in Iraq. He suffered a painful physical injury and a psychological injury quickly identified (assumed first due to the events surrounding the burns then diagnosed).

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now