Verified Document

Sexual Harassment Legal Case Study Research Paper

Legal Brief McCurdy v. Arkansas State Police, 375 F. 3 762 (8th Cir. 2004)

Type of Action

The case covered in this legal brief was the case of an employee of the Arkansas State Police, that being McCurdy, filing an action against the State of Arkansas in the form of the Arkansas State Police, that being her employer. Ms. McCurdy was trying to hold the Arkansas State Police liable for the sexual harassment of her supervisor. The case in this legal brief was argued before the United States Eight Circuit Court of Appeals (Leagle, 2014).

Facts of the Case

Jamie McCurdy, while being an employee of the Arkansas State Police, was subjected to about an hour of sexual harassment. The harassment in question was explicitly banned and disallowed as a matter of policy with the Arkansas State Police. On the Friday in which the harassment occurred, Sergeant Hall (McCurdy's supervisor) asked her where her uniform was and also stated that if it was up to him, her uniform would be a "bra and panties." He then touched and twirled McCurdy's hair and asked her if she had any "black" in her. She rejected the advances from Hill and then found a way to leave the room and report the conduct to another office. Upon elevating the details of the event to Sergeant Garner (the highest ranking person on duty) it was decided that the McCurdy and Hill should remain separated...

The matter was eventually referred to Internal Affairs rather than being handled internally by that particular group of people. Hall was eventually put on probation, demoted and assigned to a position in which he would have no conduct with McCurdy. However, he was also required to get a psychological evaluation to determine if he was even fit for duty given what he had done. They tried to terminate Hall but it was later overturned. It also came to light that McCurdy had prior harassment that she did not report and thus the police department could not react to it properly and timely given the absence of a complaining witness (IntroLaw, 2014).
Contentions of the Parties

McCurdy asserted that she was subject to a hostile work environment and constant sexual harassment and thus the Arkansas State Policy should be held liable for not controlling and properly punishing the employee. However, the police department argued that they were not able to react as quickly as they would have liked because McCurdy did not diligently report and detail the harassment until it was well under way. As such, the police department asserted that they could not deal with something that they were not aware of and thus should not be held legally liable since they reacted quickly…

Sources used in this document:
References

IntroLaw. (2014, May 30). Summary: McCurdy v. Arkansas State Police, 375 F.3d 762 (8th Cir. July 23, 2004). Summary: McCurdy v. Arkansas State Police, 375 F.3d 762 (8th Cir. July 23, 2004). Retrieved May 30, 2014, from http://www.introlaw.com/ed/cs/8th/04/080704mc.html

LawMemo. (2014, May 30). Employment Law Memo sample. Employment Law Memo sample. Retrieved May 30, 2014, from http://www.lawmemo.com/sample/e20040726.htm

Leagle. (2014, May 30). McCURDY v. ARKANSAS STATE POLICE | Leagle.com. McCURDY v. ARKANSAS STATE POLICE | Leagle.com. Retrieved May 30, 2014, from http://www.leagle.com/decision/20031257275FSupp2d982_11161
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Sexual Harassment It Is Important to Note
Words: 2133 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Sexual Harassment It is important to note that apart from serving as a centre for economic gains, the workplace also serves as a second home as well as a critical social network. Just like any other social network, the workplace also tends to have a distinctive culture which in some cases could be a field of gender-biased traditional beliefs. It is these gender-biased traditional beliefs that at times expose individuals (typically

Sexual Harassment and Discrimination Anna
Words: 1016 Length: 3 Document Type: Case Study

Given the context and the fact that being a convicted criminal and a sex offender could conceivably make the risk of any type of abuse (whether or not of a sexual nature) foreseeable, that defense is unlikely to succeed. However, generally, the knowledge of one Board member who does not disclose that knowledge to the Board will not be imputed to the rest of the Board. In any case,

Sexual Harassment Case Studies Mitsubishi Motors Manufacturing
Words: 546 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Sexual Harassment Case Studies Mitsubishi Motors Manufacturing A class action lawsuit was filed in a federal court in Illinois by the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunities Commission against Mitsubishi Motor Manufacturing of America Inc., a subsidiary of Mitsubishi Motors Corp., in April of 1996 (BHRRC 2009). The suit listed an extensive list of sexual harassment incidents affecting more than 300 women working at a manufacturing facility in Normal, Illinois, including subjection to fondling,

Sexual Harassment in the Workplace
Words: 3076 Length: 11 Document Type: Research Paper

At all times, a compliant organization will provide the following to all/each staff/employee: A non-hostile work environment An anonymous and secure system for staff to report sexual harassment/ethical concerns Quick and responsive, unbiased, comprehensive & objective investigation into all claims A safe and courteous atmosphere for our patient population and for our staff An environment void of preferential treatment or discrimination based on gender An environment void of preferential treatment Interim & annual training sessions conducted

Sexual Harassment in the Workplace: Training Is Vital
Words: 1419 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

2010). That said, Perry notes that "we know surprisingly little" about whether the training actually creates "positive change"; and given that lack of specific knowledge, the authors present what they call the "best training practices" that are available for HR departments and managers (187). The "best practices" factors that have proven successful in preparing HR professionals in matters of sexual harassment include: a) "Pre-training factors" (an assessment of who needs

Sexual Harassment Within the Hospital
Words: 1810 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

Sexual Harassment in Hospitals Existence of sexual harassment in the hospital setup in its varied forms has been clearly confirmed by exhaustive studies. It is unfortunate that such insidious practices have invaded the serene hospital environment. Sexual harassment, in whatever form it exists, must be rooted out and this demands immediate attention and positive intervention from the human resource professionals. Sexual harassment has of late become a matter of serious concern for

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now