Verified Document

Second Ghetto From The First Term Paper

" With this onslaught of blacks into their communities, there was an "exodus of Jews" (apparently no pun intended vis-a-vis the book Exodus about the Jews seeking a homeland) which created a "vacuum" that was immediately filled by a "housing-starved black population." On page 415-16, Hirsch writes that the "real tragedy surrounding the emergence of the modern ghetto" is not that it has been "inherited" but that it has been "renewed and strengthened... with government sanction and support."

Finally, on page 416, Hirsch gets down to the bare bones, bottom line social dynamic of the problem that has been allowed to fester in Chicago (at least up to 1983 when he published this essay). When, he writes, the racial lines began to "harden" after the post-WWII influx of blacks into the second ghetto, "it was apparent that white hostility was of paramount importance in shaping the pattern of black settlement." Blacks were blackballed, so to speak, from moving into white communities. It was apparent from the first page of his essay, but on page 416 he begins to related to that fact. "White hostility" could have been the title of his essay. But meantime, he describes the federally-mandated "urban renewal" (which many skeptical people including African-American activists called "urban removal") program went into decaying neighborhoods, evicted the people (who, Hirsch writes, were "shunted off to other quarters"), tore down the buildings, and built housing for middle class citizens and institutional structures for bureaucracies.

Where did a lot of the black folks get "shunted off" to? "High-rise public housing projects, created, in large part, to re-house fugitives..." from those "urban removal" areas. Those "projects" (high rises) lined State Street for "miles as a new, vertical ghetto supplemented the old." Soon though, all the positive feelings for the new tall projects went sour as there were segregationist...

The flight of the white population to the suburbs was in fact encouraged by the FHA company; Hirsch writes on 416 that of 374 FHA-guaranteed mortgages in metropolitan Chicago, only 3 of those mortgages were approved for the central city, where blacks lived and sought a better lives for their families.
The pattern of the federal government with regards to encouraging and rewarding segregation was like a Jim Crow law being re-written in different language in the north; for those who thought blatant racial bias only occurred in the south, this may come as a shock but in fact racism and segregated communities (call them "colonies" if you will) were plentiful in the big urban areas of the north.

But because there already had been an original ghetto, the fact of a new one wasn't such a shock, and that is what Hirsch is saying; basically an institutionalized ghetto was the work of a government and power structure in Chicago and elsewhere that, behind the mask of "urban renewal," just wanted to upgrade the ghetto, not really give the black middle class a chance to move out to the suburbs where the air was fresher and the lawns sparkled in the morning dew.

This essay by Hirsch could have been structured a little differently, and could have made a more dramatic impact and immediate impression, if the facts of racially segregated Chicago had been brought out at the outset of the essay. He could have laid it out like this: here is the problem, here is why is so ugly today, and now let's go back and follow the pattern of this problem from its origins. Instead he began by discussing race riots and linking those to the ghetto's proximity to the white community; the heart of the problem lies in institutional racism, not in a race riot every 50 years or so.

Works Cited

Hirsch, Arnold R. (1983). "From the…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Hirsch, Arnold R. (1983). "From the First Ghetto to the Second Ghetto," in Making the Second

Ghetto: Race and Housing in Chicago, 1940-1960, Arnold R. Hirsch, 412-419, Cambridge:
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Second Reconstructions One of the Most Dramatic
Words: 6309 Length: 14 Document Type: Term Paper

Second Reconstructions One of the most dramatic consequences of the Civil War and Reconstruction was that the South was effectively driven from national power for roughly six decades. Southerners no longer claimed the presidency, wielded much power on the Supreme Court, or made their influence strongly felt in Congress But beginning in the 1930s, the South was able to flex more and more political muscle, and by the 1970s some

Warsaw Ghetto Uprising
Words: 3374 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Warsaw Ghetto Uprising (April 19-May 16, 1943) by a handful of Jews against the Nazis, although a futile effort against overwhelming odds that was brutally snuffed out by the SS in less than a month, was the largest Jewish uprising in German-Occupied Europe and was symbolically significant. In fact, the story of Warsaw ghetto uprising is a microcosm of the Holocaust: reflecting Nazism's vicious anti-Semitism, the brutality of a totalitarian

Freakonomics to Some, From First Look, Would
Words: 1501 Length: 4 Document Type: Book Report

Freakonomics to some, from first look, would be considered another boring economics book. But in reality it is far from it. It is an innovative look on how economists view the world.. I learned so much in relation to the way the world works. I enjoyed the readings because they offered insights the "merit pay debate" for public school teachers, an area I was not too familiar with. Regardless of

Bishop of Speyer When First
Words: 1071 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

" In fact, the support of the burghers was critical to the slaughter of the Jews in Mainz, for they unlocked the city gates for the crusaders. Despite the fact that the fortifications around the Jewish population could only protect them so much, no where in Speyer's decree does it say that others would come to their aid in another situation like Mainz. A paper signed by the Bishop can only

Learning a Language: Gaining Fluency in a
Words: 1741 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Learning a language: Gaining fluency in a language to be free The acquisition of language is never a culturally neutral process. When someone learns his or her first or even a second language, that individual also acquires a status in the eyes of the world, based upon how that language is perceived. The race of the speaker, his or her perceived level of education, gender, and race all interact with the

Bioecological Theory and the Family and Community
Words: 3151 Length: 8 Document Type: Case Study

Bioecological Theory and the Family and Community Resource Conceptual Framework) The Case History "Kerry" has twin girls who are now 4 years old. She had been living with her defacto "Dean" for the past 6 years. She is a qualified beautician and has previously run a small business from home before the birth of the twins. She undertook schooling until year 12 (equal to USA high school diploma) at a public

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now