SEC FASB
Should the FASB be abolished?
Outlining the major arguments for and against the SEC replacing the FASB
Both the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) and the Securities and Exchange Committee (SEC) play critical roles in establishing the standards of GAAP. Only the SEC has the power and authority of United States law to set and enforce accounting standards. The FASB is a private organization that is supposed to show professional leadership in establishing and improving the accounting methods used to prepare financial statements. It functions much as the National Bar Association or American Medical Association might, in establishing professional guidelines.
The argument for subsuming the SEC into the FABC is that the recent accounting scandals such as Enron, demonstrate that legal 'teeth' are needed to enforce accounting procedures in a uniform fashion. Until now, the FASB has shown little proactive action in addressing ethical issues. For example, the SEC had to ask the FASB to add revenue recognition, concerns about the pooling-of-interests method of accounting, and accounting for financial instruments at fair value, and transparency issues related to derivatives, investments and loans to its agenda for review because the number of SEC enforcement actions related to these matters (Herdman 2002). Also, unlike the broad ethical guidelines provided by other professional organizations, the FASB's standards have been rule-based, as opposed to principle-based which may provide extremely detailed guidelines but also can eliminate the ability of the individual accountant to exercise personal judgments (Herdman 2002). The SEC, in contrast, attempts to provide principle-based guidelines and can back up those guidelines with the force of law.
However, there is still an argument for the existence of the FASB. Rule-based standards certainly have their place in a field as technically detailed as accounting. Also, because it is not a legal arm of the government, the FASB can have greater flexibility and sensitivity in setting accounting guidelines, as it is not establishing government policy. Finally, and perhaps most importantly, because it is primarily concerned with accounting, unlike the SEC which has host of other concerns pertaining to the open market and the sale of securities, the FASB can devote itself entirely to the business of examining the implications of GAAP standards.
Works Cited
Herdman, R.K. (14 May 2002). Testimony: Roles of SEC and FASB in establishing
GAAP. U.S. Security and Exchange Commission. Retrieved 5 Jul 2007 at http://sec.gov/news/testimony/051402tsrkh.htm
FASB Impacts The Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) was established with the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 1933 (SOX) to establish accounting standards for protection of investors and other users of financial statements. Standards implemented by FASB have the full effect of law and holds public accounting firms accountable for assurance that financial statements are accurate and fairly presented to the investing public. It is vital to the accounting profession that public accounting
FASB Accounting Rules Did FASB 157 Cause the Financial Crisis? Since the financial crisis began in February 2007, there has been an ongoing debate in the financial community over the causes of the crisis. One target that has come under fire for its role in the financial meltdown is FASB 157, which created new rules for valuing mortgage-related assets. Wall Street analysts and others blame 157 for implementing mark-to-market accounting standards. They
However, the study made by Robert J. Warth-Ethics in the Accounting Profession- concludes the necessity of better planning of the structure of education, improvements in the measure of compliance and a variation in the concentration on ethics training and discussions. The studies made by Curtis C. Verschoor-Accounting involve Ethics, not just technical issues emphasize the significance of ethics to the profession and the accounting involves morality and not just technical
Under GAAP, reversal of an inventory writedown is not permitted. Under IFRS, reversal of an inventory writedown is permitted. If the writedown has been recognized in previous years, the reversal can be conducted through the income statement of the year in which the reversal occurs, not the year in which the initial writedown occurred (Lajara, 2008). There are significant differences between cash accounting and accrual accounting. Cash accounting has transactions
IFRS Transition The SEC Proposal for Transition to IFRS This essay examines the SEC's proposed Work Plan for transitioning IFRS into the U.S. Financial Reporting System. This paper presents arguments in favor of convergence because of the benefits it presents. History of Convergence Efforts The history of convergence efforts for IFRS reporting includes several milestones. In October 2002, the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) and International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) issued a memorandum of
EITF as relates to the FASB The Emerging Issues Task Force, abbreviated as the EITF, was formed in the year 1984. The EITF works to assist the FASB (Financial Accounting Standards Board) to improve financial reporting by providing timely identification, identification, discussion and resolution of issues in accounting which are within the FASB framework known as the Accounting Standards Codification. The framework represents the source of authoritative standards of accounting
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now