Verified Document

Scout Mortgage The Nature Of Essay

Also contributing is the temporal immediacy -- although the reps had known changes were coming, the firings were immediate. The proximity level was high, since the changes had direct impacts on the sales reps and their staff, with a ripple effect throughout the organization. The concentration of the impact was high as well -- many others in the company had their jobs spared, and may even have benefited. The sales reps themselves were directly targeted. Each of these factors contributes to a high degree of ethical intensity. 4. Walsh and Mangel arrived at their decision in part by trial-and-error and in part by developing a strategy. Their first decision -- to transition with both salaried reps and commissioned ones -- was the trial and error component. While there was forethought, there was no research and no concrete decision-making process that lead to that decision. As a result, the decision was not a success.

The second decision -- to fire all of the commissioned sales reps was in part a response to the failure of the first decision, but it was also a part of an overarching strategy. The company had its mission change, and firing the reps was a necessary step in the fulfillment of that new mission. The decision to make the change, therefore, was simply a reflection of the strategy...

The approach to change illustrated in this case is one that emphasizes the swiftness of the action. The failed first approach was a soft approach that emphasized compassion, as the needs of the sales reps were considered and even given priority over the needs of the company. The second decision was more strategic in nature. The change was deemed to be strategically necessary as a result of changes in the external environment. Therefore, the final decision was made in response to what was essentially a crisis in that the owners were not making money while the sales reps were making excellent money for doing what had become a low-skill job.
Management's approach, then, was to ignore the concerns of the workers and place the emphasis on making the right decisions for the company. Long-range vision was developed first, in order that the changes driven were the ones that needed to be made. The first change that failed was likely a reactionary change driven by the need to cut costs. That the first change provoked crisis served to spur the need for wholesale change at a philosophical level. With strategic management principles in mind, the change was guided by the desired end objective.

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Business Case in the 21st
Words: 922 Length: 3 Document Type: Research Proposal

The rational decision-making model has a logical flow from goal setting to the implementation of the change strategy. That Walsh and Mangel used this model is evident even in the implementation part of the change. They dismissed their commission reps outright, rather than undertake half measures. This was consistent with their vision for their organization going forward. It is that consistency of vision, strategy and implementation that defines the rational

Buying a Home Is a
Words: 932 Length: 3 Document Type: Thesis

There is little information with respect to the fees that the buyer might face. The Fannie Mae site also offers very little advice with respect to when to buy a home. From this, one can interpret that Fannie Mae's constituents do not view home ownership as an investment. The financial ramifications of home ownership, therefore, are less a concern since the home will be owned long-term. The underlying assumption appears

American Disabilities Act American's With
Words: 7288 Length: 27 Document Type: Essay

(Schall, 1998) In addition to a lightened burden of proof and broader definition there were two additional changes resulting from the amendment which served to positively affect the impact and ultimate effectiveness of the legislation. This amendment clarified the fact that judges are not allowed to assess possible mitigating factors such as medication, corrective surgery, or specialized equipment in the determination of whether or not an individual is disabled. This

Management Styles Fool-Proofing a Service Operation. In
Words: 4150 Length: 12 Document Type: Term Paper

Management Styles Fool-proofing a service operation. In the banking industry, a significant service industry in any country, optimized operations are essential to ensure that the public has maximum confidence in the operators of this industry. Bank of America and its operations have been selected for discussion in this study. The bank has grown tremendously in the past few years. CEO, Ken Lewis realized that the bank could gain a wider market share

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now