Verified Document

Scientific American By Michael J. Term Paper

Using humans as guinea pigs in a study of what happens to the body when syphilis is left untreated borders on the viciousness of some of Nazi Germany's "human experiments" on innocent Jews. Meanwhile, Satel goes on to point out that notwithstanding the DNA evidence of biological similarities, there are dramatic differences in how medicine views ethnic differences, and there lies the controversy which is one of the main themes of her article.

To wit, Canadian Eskimos have a "variant form of a liver enzyme" that causes the Eskimo to be vulnerable to tuberculosis bacteria; and African-American woman have a higher incidence of breast cancer prior to reaching 35 years of age than Caucasian women do. Yes, we're almost all the same but our bodies react very differently to disease. The other themes that come through Satel's research: worries about categorizing people based on ancestry notwithstanding, identifying a person's ethnicity though DNA (hair samples, blood, semen in crime cases) has social value; two, a tiny DNA difference can invite an enormous biological difference; and three, good science must ignore "groundless accusations of racism" when research devoted to health issues specific to ethnicity and ancestry.

Henry E. Hale of Indiana University ("Explaining Ethnicity") writes in 2004 that nothing "close to a consensus" has emerged among scholars as to how to treat the concept of "ethnicity." Those who put forward theories about "ethnicity" divide it into "primordialism" and "constructivism" - but neither category is helpful and in fact the two "actually obscure some of the most important questions," Hale continues. In short, Hale is saying that ethnicity should be thought of within psychological scholarship, not just biology, sociology, political science and anthropology.

Meanwhile, in his essay "The idiom of ethnicity," Michael Banton writes that in terms of political / social realities, "no group defines itself" in terms of "ethnicity." Banton writes that an attempt was made in 1935 (by Sir Julian Huxley...

Haddon) "to clear up" the confusion between issues of "race, culture and nation"; hence, they wrote that "it is very desirable that the term race as applied to human groups should be dropped from the vocabulary of science." This material was presented by Banton no doubt in the sense of showing that the debate over "race" and "ethnicity" is not a new one.
What Banton explains ("Rational Choice Theories [Theories of Ethnicity]") with reference to approaching the issues of race and ethnicity (Banton, 1995) is that he falls back on "rational choice theory"; and the two main propositions of rational choice theory are: one, groups are created based on "physical and cultural groups" in order to set up inclusion and exclusion in that group; and two, when "groups interact, processes of change affect their boundaries" in ways that are determined by the "form and intensity of competition."

In conclusion, the work of Banton and Hale, and the essays of Bamshad / Olson and Satel give the reader plenty of ideas from which to cull out the meaning of "race" and "ethnicity." The bottom line is, there really is no "race" per se; the world is made up of cultural groups based on their own attraction and relationship to others of like cultures.

Works Cited

Banton, Michael. (1995). Rational Choice Theories (Theories of Ethnicity). American

Behavioral Scientist, 38(3), 478-498.

Banton, Michael. (2000). The Idiom of Ethnicity (Debate). Journal of Ethnic and Migration

Studies, 26(3), 535-543.

Bamshad, Michael J., & Olson, Steve E. (2003). Does Race Exist? Scientific American, Retrieved 14 Jan. 2007 at http://www.sciam.com/print_version.cfm?articleId=00055DC8-3BAA-1FA8-BBAA83414B7FOOOO

Hale, Henry E. (2004). Explaining Ethnicity. Comparative Political Studies. 37(4), 458.

Satel, Sally. (2001). Medicine's Race Problem. Policy Review, Hoover Institution. Retrieved 15 Jan. 2007 at http://www.hoover.org/publications/policyreview/3462856.html.

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Banton, Michael. (1995). Rational Choice Theories (Theories of Ethnicity). American

Behavioral Scientist, 38(3), 478-498.

Banton, Michael. (2000). The Idiom of Ethnicity (Debate). Journal of Ethnic and Migration

Studies, 26(3), 535-543.
Bamshad, Michael J., & Olson, Steve E. (2003). Does Race Exist? Scientific American, Retrieved 14 Jan. 2007 at http://www.sciam.com/print_version.cfm?articleId=00055DC8-3BAA-1FA8-BBAA83414B7FOOOO
Satel, Sally. (2001). Medicine's Race Problem. Policy Review, Hoover Institution. Retrieved 15 Jan. 2007 at http://www.hoover.org/publications/policyreview/3462856.html.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Michael Pollan in 2006, Published
Words: 2777 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Paper

Pollan stresses the need to cook our own food and reassert the historical and cultural importance of food in our lives. Again this strengthens Pollan's rhetoric and continues the line of reasoning he began in Omnivore's Dilemma. So it's good to be encouraged by Pollan, who eulogises the pleasures of cooking, and to be reminded of some basic truths."When you cook at home, you seldom find yourself reaching for the

Math Achievement African-American Vs. White
Words: 6588 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

In grade four white males performing "At or Above Basic" math skills is stated at 90% while black males were performing at only 59% "At or Above Basic" skill levels. White males in the "At or Above Proficient" skills level is stated at 49% with black males in this category stated at a mere 13%. The following labeled Figure 2 shows the statistical report of NAEP (2005) in relation to

Mris Legal and Scientific Review
Words: 5397 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

There are three types of stimuli used, which are: 1) Targets; 2) Irrelevant; and 3) Probes. These are used "in the form of words, pictures, or sounds..." which a computer presents for a second or even a partial second. Incoming stimulus, if it is worth noting, results in a P-300, which is an electrical brain response. The P-300 is part of a MERMER or a memory and encoding related multifaceted electroencephalographic response,

African-Americans Baroch, Andrew J. 10 Years After
Words: 1397 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

African-Americans Baroch, Andrew J. "10 Years after Million Man March, African-Americans return to Washington." VOA News. Retrieved November 13, 2005, from http://www.voanews.com/english/AmericanLife/2005-10-14-voa7.cfm. This article was making a connection between the century-old Million Man March and The "Millions More" March that was scheduled for October 15, 2005. Though the Million Man March was specifically organized for efforts to register African-Americans to vote in U.S. Elections and also to increase black involvement in volunteerism

Leadership Case Study Michael Alfonso
Words: 2936 Length: 10 Document Type: Case Study

By integrating aspects of transformational leadership into his leadership, Alonso would have inspired his crew to follow him while also becoming leaders by themselves. However, this could have only been made possible if his thoughts, feelings, and actions were consistent. As a leader of change Alfonso should have shown some element of connection to himself, the world, and the people around him and be grounded in reality. He ought

Preferences in Learning Between American
Words: 23082 Length: 65 Document Type: Dissertation

The trainer will then focus on the steps to be taken to develop new skills. For example, if the trainer wants to talk about motivating, leading, negotiating, selling or speaking, it is best to start with what the learners do well before showing some chart on Maslow's theory, Posner's leadership practices, or selling skills from some standard package that has been develop elsewhere. Many foreign trainers make grave errors

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now