Verified Document

Saving Affirmative Action Laws Affirmative Action Laws Thesis

Saving Affirmative Action Laws Affirmative action laws apply to many sections of societal interactions be it school admissions, business, or employee hiring, they attempt to balance the history of racial discrimination that marked the period before the laws came into being. Affirmative action requires that persons making decisions relating to employment, business and education take into account factors such as religion, sex, color, race and national origin. The major advantage of the laws is that they promote the opportunities available for minority groups in the society. The major proponent of the laws is that they compensate for persecution, discrimination and exploitation that was present in the past. Over the last few years, there has been debate on the benefits and harms brought about by affirmative action with several arguing that though it has met its intended benefits, the law also disadvantages minority groups since they may end up in institutions that will not serve them as well as less elite ones would. Therefore there is a need to examine the benefits and harms brought about by affirmative action in the quest to create new solutions that would benefit the whole population.

History of affirmative action

Affirmative action was introduced by President John F. Kennedy in 1961 as one of the methods of addressing discrimination that was quite rampant in spite of constitutional rights and civil rights laws. However, the idea was first developed and enforced by President Lyndon B. Johnson four years later. In Executive Order 11246, President Johnson prohibited employers from using race, religion, color and national origin as discriminative factors. He them amended the law two years later in 1967 to include sex. Everything seemed to be going well until the late 70s when reverse discrimination became rampant. Several whites were irked by rejection from institutions that they qualified to as a result of places being reserved for less qualified minorities.

In 1986, affirmative action was put to the test in Wygant v. Jackson Board of Education when the Board of Education laid off white...

Paradise480 U.S. 1491987
first problem arising from affirmative action laws. According to the theory of mismatch, affirmative action harms those who it is supposed to help by affording them opportunities which they fall below the median ability level. Therefore these individuals have a tough time coping with the situation at present an even in the future )

. In a systemic review published, it was found that students who gain special admission to elite schools on partly nonacademic grounds are likely to struggle more and this adversely affects their outcomes. Thus they have lower pass rates, problems fitting into the job market and higher attrition rates. The analysis established that the magnitude of these effects outweighed the benefits of prestige Sander, 2004.

The mismatch theory has been disputed by several professors. Ho (2011)

stated that minority students afforded positions on partly nonacademic grounds perform equally as well as the others on the bar irrespective of their history.

As posited by (///), mismatching leads to increased dropout rates as a result of the non-minority students being unable to survive in the elite and competitive institutions where they preferentially entered on partly nonacademic merits. Critics have, however, argued that without affirmative action, the number of non-minority professionals would decrease greatly.

Second problem: reverse discrimination

Affirmative action has over the years led to many cases regarding reverse discrimination. This has increased the attention and pressure on law makers to have a second look at the situation. According to affirmative action laws, women and minorities are entitled to preferential treatment. These two groups account for two thirds of the population…

Sources used in this document:
References

1986. Wygant v. Jackson Board of Education.

1987. United States v. Paradise.

2003a. Gratz v. Bollinger.

2003b. Grutter v. Bollinger.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Affirmative Action Plan in Human Resources
Words: 2743 Length: 9 Document Type: Research Paper

Affirmative Action Plan It is a fact that there has been discrimination in employment, where minorities, women, veterans and the disabled are sidelined in favor of the rest of the population. This ought to be provided with equitable access to employment opportunities and this is exactly what affirmative action plan does. By statistical analyses of the demographics, affirmative action programs are able to do away with the negative effects of employment

Laws Affecting the Human Resources
Words: 4295 Length: 16 Document Type: Term Paper

Add to this confusion the growing prevalence of telecommuters and the issues of the FLSA become even more complicated. Of course some telecommuting positions fall into the exempt category, and therefore are not subject to overtime pay, however some do. Due to the freedom to engage in 'private pursuits', employers may monitor when a virtual employee logs onto his or her computer and may require that he or she get

Law Sexual Harassment Teddy's Supplies' CEO Dear
Words: 1472 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Law Sexual Harassment Teddy's Supplies' CEO Dear Sir, In pursuing the facts of the case I think Teddy's is having a written sexual harassment policy and a method for employees to report sexual harassment -- either to the supervisor or in secret by using the www.ReportTeddysafely.com. As an employer some of the necessities stipulated by law have been followed. The Supreme Court defined two principles regarding the sexual harassment at the workplace.

Employment Law Policies Employee Policy
Words: 2554 Length: 9 Document Type: Thesis

The employer has an established protocol for dealing with allegations of sexual harassment, and a sexual harassment complaint triggers protections for the employee. An employee engaging in sexual harassment of any other employees, clients, or business associates of the employer, will be disciplined. Any employee engaging in sexual harassment who has been notified by the victim, a supervisor, or any other employee of the employer, that such conduct is

Employment Law
Words: 3665 Length: 12 Document Type: Research Paper

Organization Behavior Human Resource Management Policies of Wal-Mart Employment Law Wal-Mart Human Resource Management Policies of Wal-Mart Wal-Mart is a large scale multinational retailer that employs more than 2.2 million employees in 27 countries. The management of this large workforce requires it to implement effective human resource management and employment relations policies at its workplace. Wal-Mart believes in effective recruitment and selection process in order to fill the vacant job positions with the most

Living With Disabilities Certainly Exposes Life to
Words: 868 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Living with disabilities certainly exposes life to a variety of challenges including the challenge of securing and keeping a job. But today fortunately for most people with disabilities, increased awareness and technological advancements have given a boost to their quality of life. Also societal and legislative changes have reduced the discriminations against disabled peopled especially at work by making it mandatory on employers to make reasonable accommodations for people with

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now