Verified Document

Same-Sex Marriage Rights The Debate About Same-Sex Essay

¶ … Same-Sex Marriage Rights The debate about same-sex marriage rights is at the forefront of contemporary American civil rights politics. Supporters of same-sex marriage believe that exclusion from marital rights is a form of unjustifiable discrimination. Opponents of same-sex marriage believe that marriage is a concept defined by the biological norm of opposite-gender pair bonding and that making it available to same-sex couples would undermine its validity as a traditional social institution. Strictly from my position as an objective observer who is not directly affected by the issue in the least, a fair comparison of the respective arguments suggests that same-sex marriage should probably be permitted and regulated in the same manner as and according to all the same other principles as traditional marriage because there is no justifiable basis for denying marital rights based on gender preference.

Discussion

According to proponents of same-sex marriage rights, denying the rights of homosexuals to marry is very similar to the shameful laws from the first half of the 20th century that once criminalized interracial marriage in many states throughout most of the century. That position seems to be strengthened considerably by the fact that marriage is no longer only a ceremonial act and an expression of religious belief and identity. Today, marriage is associated with many legal rights and privileges and benefits that are entirely unavailable to unmarried couples. Only some of those rights and privileges are capable of being established and secured through other means. For example, healthcare proxies, power of attorney, last wills and testaments, and...

However, other rights that are automatic through marriage, such as the rights of survivors to inherit property in intestacy, immunity from certain legal obligations to testify in one another's criminal trials, and child custody (among other rights) cannot be established outside of marriage. In any case, it seems unfair that same-sex couples would have to make the effort to secure and every one of those rights when marriage would provide them all at once, just as it does for traditional couples.
Opponents of same-sex marriage argue that the original basis for marriage was religious and that same-sex relationships, let alone marriage, violate almost every known religious faith. In fact, both of those two suggestions may be entirely true. The problem is that once a religiously-inspired ceremony becomes associated with secular rights and privileges, it can no longer be fairly denied to others. Atheists and other on-believers have the same right to marry as the religious, just not with the approval or involvement of any specific religious faith that does not recognize certain types of marriages. Catholics do not recognize the legitimacy of divorce; but that is not a valid defense in a civil divorce court.

More importantly, one of the most fundamental propositions upon which this nation was founded is the notion of separation of church and state. At the most basic level, the First Amendment to the United States Constitution expressly forbids the government from establishing any religion. According to a very long history of precedent in the U.S. Supreme…

Sources used in this document:
References

Bennett, W.J. "Gay Marriage: Not a Very Good Idea." The Washington Post, May

21, 1996. Accessed 25 July, 2012 from:

http://www.catholiceducation.org/articles/printarticle.html?id=1013

Gates, G. (2011). "How many people are lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender?" The
http://williamsinstitute.law.ucla.edu/wp-content/uploads/Gates-How-Many-
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Marriage Vs. Cohabitation Adulthood Brings With It
Words: 617 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Marriage vs. Cohabitation Adulthood brings with it many milestones. Learning to drive, going to college, taking on new relationships -- all facets of life that many people strive toward. However, as time goes on, these milestones have veered from the traditional and into new territory. For instance, instead of heading down the aisle, many couples are choosing to bypass the formality and move right into cohabitation. Many would say that this

Right to Life - Terri
Words: 1634 Length: 5 Document Type: Thesis

On this matter, House Democratic Leader Nancy Pelosi stated, "Congressional leaders have no business substituting their judgment for that of multiple state courts that have extensively considered the issues in this intensely personal family matter." (Euthansia and Terri Schiavo b). Federal Judge James Whittemore heard the Schiavo case and ruled on March 22, 2005 that the Schindlers had not established a "substantial likelihood of success" at trial and refused

Should Australia Have a Bill of Rights
Words: 3069 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Australia Have a Bill of Rights? Australia is the last remaining Common Law country without a Bill or Rights or Human Rights Bill. It is important to note that the Australian variant of liberalism differs from the Anglo-American model in two important ways. First, the establishment of Australia as a series of British colonies under authoritarian governors and the absence of any political revolution has meant a lesser stress on

Right Embodies the Notion That One Has
Words: 724 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

right" embodies the notion that one has the sovereignty to act without obtaining the permission of others (Lea, 2004). This concept carries an implicit unstated postscript with it in that one may exercise one's rights as long as one does not violate the individual rights of others. Individual rights pertain to the rights that are deemed universal to all people regardless of any group affiliations they may have. For

Rights and the French Revolution
Words: 2520 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Paper

The Rights of Man and Revolution in France Introduction Despite the push to eradicate a class based system during the Enlightenment and events leading up to the French Revolution, it was replaced instead by classes based on property and wealth rather than nobility. Two leading figures for and against the new classes were Robespierre and Sieyes. Sieyes supported separating voting rights from human rights while Robespierre believed voting rights were inherent rights

Gay Marriage Is a Topical and Controversial
Words: 2476 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Gay marriage is a topical and controversial issue, as evidenced by the subject's coverage in the media, presence on ballot initiatives and the high visibility of the controversy in general. There are a few different ethical issues where gay marriage is concerned. To opponents, the primary ethical issue relates to concepts such as the sanctity of marriage and the survival of the species. For proponents, the ethical issues are greater,

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now