Verified Document

Robert Nardelli -- A Controversial Leader Leadership Essay

Robert Nardelli -- a Controversial Leader Leadership landscape has evolved greatly over the last few decades. Where there has been an extensive research performed in this area, major emphasis has been levied on distinguishing managers from leaders. And, in today's robust and diversified workplace, leaders with exceptional motivating power and business management ability is what every organization needs. This is the reason why obsolete leadership styles when exercised, tend to bring out disastrous results. This is precisely what happened when Robert Nardelli of General Electrics was made CEO of Home Depot, a leading store with a glorious history of excellent customer service and major customer satisfaction. Although Nardelli brought a rich experience to Home Depot but the ideology he was following had major clashes with the original vision of Home Depot which later on made him declared as one of the worst CEOs in the history of United States.

Before analyzing the leadership style of Nardelli, it is important to understand the culture that in which he was operating and grew throughout his career. It is acclaimed fact that the culture of General Electric is driven by numbers reflected in the balance sheet. Without criticizing this culture, one may agree that this work model works for GE due to its enormous size and highly extensive operations. Secondly, this culture is rooted in the foundation of GE. Whereas, if the case study of Home Depot is considered, the founders Bernie Marcus and Arthur Blank, had introduced a culture of entrepreneurship in this organization. For decades, employees were made responsible for their respective work domains with complete independence in terms of decision making and creativity. Hence, the motivation level of the employees was different prior to Nardelli. It was the difference between two sets of ideologies which made Nardelli a failed CEO.

After joining Home Depot, Nardelli introduced various measures which redefined not only the culture but also the business model of Home Depot. Some of these measures were replacement of a major number of skilled permanent workforce with contractual labor with relatively less experience (Colvin,...

Where such policy allowed a major reduction in fixed overheads, the decline in the customer service and efficiency and effectiveness of labor's performance was visibly observed. Nardelli further introduced extreme centralization of the work processes. New technological interventions with major investment were introduced with the decision making authority only resting with the Head office in Atlanta, the whole new process introduced uniformity in the business processes at all the outlets but too away independence at departmental level which made the employees highly demotivated.
Coming over to customer side, he also introduced a Do-it-Yourself shopping model which was contrary to the earlier vision of the store (Deutsch, 2001). Furthermore, change in the return policy also caused major customer loss as the customers failed to accept the new outlook of Home Depot. Resultant was major decline in customer service and customer base with loss in market share and reduction in listed prices of the store. If analyzed carefully, we would come across the fact that it was the desire of Nordelli, to control everything and become the ultimate decision making authority in the organization which made him fail as a CEO. He was highly task-oriented and visibly a believer of autocratic leadership.

Analyzing the personality of Nardelli as per trait theory, he was supposed to be agreeable, conscious, extrovert, open to experiment and emotionally stable (which are the evident traits of an effective leader). On the contrary, he was conscious but only towards the growth of the company and his objectives as the CEO instead of employees' motivation and customer's satisfaction. His failure to experiment and adopt the contemporary leadership practices with inability to form alliance with the stakeholders (employees, customers etc.) In the business raised question marks on his leadership later (Colvin, 2007).

Secondly, if the behavioral aspects of contemporary leadership models is considered, various factors can be identified which would lead to identification of reasons which caused failure of Nardelli as a leader (DePree, 2004). For example, consideration is…

Sources used in this document:
References

Bass, B., & Riggio, R. (2006). Transformational Leadership. London: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

Colvin, G. (2001, January 8). Home Depot Mirrors the Way I Operate. Retrieved March 1, 2008, from Money.CNN.com:http://money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/fortune_archive/2001/01/08/294458/index.htm

Colvin, G. (2007, January 3). Nardelli's Downfall: It's all about the stock. Retrieved February 5, 2008, from money.cnn.com: http://money.cnn.com/2007/01/03/news/companies/colvin/_nardelli.fortune/

DePree, M. (2004). Leadership is an Art. New York: Doubleday.
Deutsch, C.H. (2001, July 29). A Do-it-Youtselfer Takes on Home Depot. Retrieved from The New York Times: http://www.nytimes.com/2001/07/29/busines
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Leader's Self-Insight 1.1: Your Learning Style: Using
Words: 3023 Length: 12 Document Type: Essay

Leader's Self-Insight 1.1: Your Learning Style: Using Multiple Intelligences I scored evenly on all of the types of intelligence measured by this self-assessment: logical-mathematical, verbal-linguistic, interpersonal, intrapersonal, and musical. This indicates that I am a well-rounded person with the ability to work in multiple environments on different tasks. Leader's Self-Insight 1.2: Your Leadership Potential I scored slightly more (7) on the even-numbered indicators than on the odd ones (6), indicating I have leadership

Leaders in American Policing
Words: 3123 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

Leaders in American Policing: Police officers in the United States are in an exceptionally demanding position since they confront predicaments and conditions that are characterized with physical danger, emotional challenges, and psychological difficulties. Generally, these professionals are placed in situations with great need though with limited resources. This in turn places them in circumstances where it's easy for them to develop feelings of skepticism and lethargy. As a result, the officers

Leaders and Managers the Points
Words: 929 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

The concepts of leadership -- charisma for example -- become subject to academic study and analysis. This ultimately produces insight into particular leadership types and understanding of the nature of those types (Westley & Mintzberg, 1989). Managers, therefore, can become leaders by adopting more of the traits of leaders. Any split that remains between management and leadership therefore rests on the assumption that some of the traits associated with leadership

Leader Member Exchange Theory Leader-Member
Words: 1848 Length: 6 Document Type: Research Proposal

In contrast, a high-stress job, such as in a police department or hospital may create a sense of solidarity between friendly colleagues that is extremely strong to the point that it can influence job performance ratings. Bias can influence superior's perceptions of how much a friend deserves a promotion or a raise, and there is a strong sense of being part of an 'in-group' that is intrinsic to the

Leaders on Leadership One Can See Why
Words: 944 Length: 3 Document Type: Book Report

Leaders on Leadership One can see why a person might not pick up Leaders on Leadership on first glance. There are a good number of business books on the topic, and it could well be difficult to understand the mix of business and biblical thinking. But this product lives up to the promises of the subtitle. It is a good offer of Wisdom, Advice and Encouragement on the Art of Leading

Leaders and History Having a Leadership Position
Words: 580 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Leaders and History Having a leadership position and being a leader are not the same thing, even though many people believe it is. Being appointed to a leadership role is entirely dependent upon circumstances; being a leader is an innate quality that moves beyond the tactical and into the strategic, allows those with greatness to rise to the occasion, and often results in drastic changes in society and culture. We can

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now