Verified Document

Rhetoric In "Should College Athletes Be Paid " Article Review

Rhetoric In "Should College Athletes Be Paid?" Allen Sack argues that colleges and universities are exploiting their athletes but that they should still not get paid. A professor at the University of New Haven and a former college football player for Notre Dame, Sack has also written a book on the subject called Counterfeit Amateurism: An Athlete's Journey Through the Sixties to the Age of Academic Capitalism. The phrase "counterfeit amateurism" is a phrase Sack uses to describe the progression of college sports from a purely amateur athletic scenario to a big business. Yet athletes are rarely receiving the full benefits of their success. Sack would prefer to see a return to true amateur college sports devoid of the big media attention garnered today, but acknowledges that the current trend is towards the "sports entertainment empire," (Sack 2).

Paying athletes is unnecessary and would not necessarily help them achieve their academic goals, notes Sack. Athletes are also "already essentially paid to play" because they receive scholarships (Sack 2). According to the author, athletes should instead receive medical benefits, workers' compensation, and, most controversially, "the right to engage in the same kinds of entrepreneurial ventures that are the stock and trade of celebrity coaches,"...

By this, Sack suggests that athletes in college should be allowed to hire agents that can plan their careers, endorse products or become celebrity spokesmen, get paid for speaking engagements, and retrieve revenues from any college-based merchandise or publications that includes their image.
The purpose of Sack's argument is to inspire self-reflection on the part of NCAA stakeholders. A former college athlete with a national championship team, Sack remains pro-sports and values the contributions of athletes to their schools. Sack does not argue that college sports is harmful in general, or that athletes are not benefitting by receiving an education. The subtitle of Sack's article is "Go all amateur, or give them pro-benefits," which sums up his argument. Sack urges the NCAA to consider the rights of their athletes and the implications of allowing their athletes to receive forms of compensation that would not directly interfere with their education or their ability to play sports as true amateurs. Sack does note that he would prefer true amateurism.

Sack's article appears in print and online versions of The Christian Science Monitor and not a sports-focused publication. Audiences will generally consist of curious readers interested in issues related to social justice,…

Sources used in this document:
Work Cited

Sack, Allen. "Should College Athletes Be Paid?" Christian Science Monitor. 7 march, 2008. Retrieved online: http://www.newhaven.edu/20719.pdf
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Philosophy of Sports but IT's
Words: 2208 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

Even the much despised soccer is popular amongst American youths. Yet Americans cheer on their favorite individual stars in all of these sports, especially if the starts engage in charity efforts to justify their bloated salaries. The tension remains about what good sports do for both the individual or society, and Americans today are clearly using sports as a means of practical self-improvement like the Greeks as well as

Dual in the Sun by
Words: 3369 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

" In fact that showdown with labor "produced a cultural shift, a new sense of what can be appropriate in business management." The entire Reagan era, according to Will, a well-known conservative commentator - who wrote this piece at the time of Reagan's passing - is remembered "more for the tax-cutting and deregulating that helped, with the information technologies, to shift the economy into a hitherto unknown overdrive." Another event that

Starbucks' Human Resource Management Policies and the
Words: 3854 Length: 15 Document Type: Essay

Starbucks' Human Resource Management Policies and the Growth Challenge In recent years, there has been much interest in the notion of "high commitment" human resource management (HRM). The high commitment HRM is focused on developing self-regulated behavior among employees that is based on mutual trust rather than external sanctions and pressures. Considering this premise, this paper provides a review of the relevant peer-reviewed, scholarly and organizational. literature concerning the advantages of

Advertising - Ad Campaign Analysis
Words: 838 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Likewise, her mannerisms, body positions, movements, facial expressions, makeup, and her attire selected for the commercial reinforce sexuality and physical attractiveness throughout (Gerrig & Zimbardo, 2001). Logos: The appeal to logic takes the form of the only spoken words in the advertisement. The words "sexy," "powerful," and "attitude" are repeated throughout the commercial, uttered in a sexual, breathy female voice. The clear message is that use of the product will increase a

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now