Verified Document

Revenue Sharing Tax Revenue Sharing: A Solution Essay

Revenue Sharing Tax revenue sharing: A solution to the inequities in school funding?

Tax revenue sharing is one of the most popular yet controversial potential solutions to the problem of inequitable funding of school districts. In the debate over fairness in education, the fact that property taxes are usually the primary method of school funding frequently leaves poorer districts with substantially less revenue than their wealthier counterparts. Revenue sharing is based upon the idea in which "each community in a region designates some percentage of a new tax stream or new tax base to a regional pool, where it is divided among all the towns in the pool based on some formula that may involve population or other variables" (Region agenda, 2009, The Hartford Courant). Revenue sharing is designed to equalize revenue between local governments that have differing capabilities of raising revenue, and thus create better opportunities for residents.

This method of financing local services is particularly critical in the field of education, given that education can be a potentially great social equalizer, in terms of the ways it can open up opportunities for the chronically disenfranchised. However, when schools are underfunded, poverty becomes a vicious cycle. Poor districts have less revenue from property taxes and thus less money to fund schools and provide a high-quality education for students. Revenue sharing seems to provide local school districts with the best of both worlds -- retention of local control coupled with expanded opportunities to invest in other economic sectors. Even wealthier state residents can benefit from the wider community improvements generated from revenue sharing, such as a decreased need to attract large, polluting industries to generate tax revenue and the general improvements education can bring to the community.

Most local governments have a "limited revenue-raising ability" (Revenue sharing, 1998, Michigan in Brief). The most obvious way poorer districts can make up discrepancies in funding is through raising local...

But this source of funding can have a long-term negative impact upon an area for two, critical reasons. Firstly, poorer residents are penalized to a greater extent by sales taxes. It means that they must pay more money for the same goods and services, with the same amount of income. The poor devote a larger proportion of their salary to necessary items affected by sales taxes. The regressive nature of sales taxes means that it is counterproductive to the stated aim of increasing social equality.
Secondly, higher local sales taxes also stifle the growth of new enterprises, when new business is precisely what is needed to create job growth in depressed regions. "A classic case is Detroit, which levies a 3% income tax (as well as high property taxes), needed partly because it has a low property tax base (that is, the value of its taxable property is low relative to other cities, in part because high city taxes have driven residents and businesses from the city -- a vicious circle). A state revenue-sharing program allows local governments to levy lower taxes and mitigates competition among jurisdictions" (Revenue sharing, 1998, Michigan in Brief). Revenue sharing also allows poorer districts to allocate more resources for affordable housing and other programs to improve the plight of the poor and stimulate long-term, wider economic development, rather than channel their available revenues solely upon unavoidable costs for schools and other essential services.

Another argument in favor of revenue sharing is that it can have positive environmental consequences and improve the life of residents. "Towns desperate for property tax revenue to pay for schools and local government have often made poor land-use decisions -- given up farms and scenic vistas for strip malls and other developments they otherwise would have passed on" (Region agenda, 2009, The Hartford Courant). The drive to increase tax revenue to pay for schools can decrease the quality of life of children and adults, reducing the open spaces for children to play…

Sources used in this document:
References

Dare to share: A review of tax revenue sharing in the United States. (2004). Sierra Club.

Retrieved March 29, 2011

http://ohio.sierraclub.org/issues/sprawl/taxrevenue.htm

Pinho, K. (2011, February 23). Schools, pensions revenue sharing could take major hit.
Spinal Column. Retrieved March 29, 2011 at http://spinalcolumnonline.com/schools-pensions-revenue-sharing-could-take-major-hits/
Retrieved March 29, 2011 at http://articles.courant.com/2009-12-30/news/hc-regionalagenda4.artdec30_1_sharing-tax-revenue-tax-base
Revenue sharing. (1998). Michigan in Brief. Retrieved March 29, 2011 at http://www.michiganinbrief.org/edition06/text/issues/issue-49.htm
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Solutions to Poverty Among the Elderly
Words: 3788 Length: 11 Document Type: Capstone Project

Poverty is defined as having a meager annual income, insufficient for meeting basic expenditure. Research has confirmed that older adults, from the age of 65 years and above, when poor, confront immense burden in meeting with their basic housing, food, healthcare and other expenses. Poverty in the elderly populations is a persistent and grave issue in America. Almost 10% of elderly individuals (aged 65 years and above) belong to families

Global Tax Treaties, UN Model and OECD
Words: 4790 Length: 12 Document Type: Dissertation or Thesis complete

global tax treaties, UN model and OECD model with the view of analyzing their consideration towards rights to capital and tax income. By throwing light on differences and similarities among the models, the fundamental logic of each of them is explained. The article explains the prospecting policies of consideration when tax treaties are to be signed. It is because there is strong need to enforce a flexible but more

Fiscal Federalism: Spending and Taxes
Words: 1436 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Foremost, when they occur, they generate massive financial setbacks for the institution implementing them as they generally require a large sum of money. "It is difficult to properly handle investments in public budgets. The rewards are spread out over an extended period of time while the cost or the pain of investing is immediate. That makes if difficult to finance public investments" (Penner, 2008). For the state and local governments

Basics of Consolidated Returns and Gosystem Tax Rs: Taxation
Words: 1903 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Consolidated Tax Returns and GoSystems Tax Software Consolidated Tax Returns The consolidated tax return, in simple terms, is "a method by which to determine the tax liability of a group of affiliated corporations" (Pratt and Kulsrud 8-2). It is based on the assumption that the business operations of affiliated companies represent a single entity and that, hence, the group's aggregate income ought to be taxed, as opposed to the separate incomes of

Social Service Solutions
Words: 1232 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Coffee-Town Problem Human Service Plan Coffee-Town is an area with great social service professionals that do a great job of service delivery to help the people of the community. However, even with the great performance there are some shortfalls and shortcomings that are under way whereby people are unable to get the full depth and breadth of the services that they need. In addition, the bureaucracy of all of the different social

Obesity Prevention Marketing Plan Obesity Prevention Nonprofit
Words: 3245 Length: 12 Document Type: Research Paper

Obesity Prevention Marketing Plan Obesity Prevention Nonprofit Organizational Marketing Plan The primary purpose of this report is to help investors understand the need for a program which will help reduce obesity throughout the UK and then less developed countries in Eastern Europe. The problem is that the environment that many developed countries have created for themselves advances obesity without intending to. There is also the danger among less developed countries, that are beginning

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now