Verified Document

Resolving The Challenge Of Nurse Staffing Ratios Research Paper

¶ … Leadership and Management In the medical field, the recent topic of debate relates to Nurse Staffing Ratios where many argue that governments need to intervene in setting minimum staffing laws. Currently, the only state that has enacted a law is California and nurse unions in other states are fighting for the implementation of the same in their workplaces. However, most of the attempts made by other states to implement California's strategy have failed since hospitals fail to participate (Schultz, 2013). The argument of many hospitals is that the laws do not give them the opportunity or ability to make decisions regarding staffing and at the same time be a financial burden (Schultz, 2013, par. 3). As seen from many nursing unions, hospitals have abused the system to the point of employing few nurses and yet the patients are ever increasing. Inappropriate staffing ratios influence the safety of patients, the satisfaction of nurses, and contribute to the further deterioration of work environment due to job stress and burnout. Nursing staffing ratios is a debate, and the only way to improve the situation is to use effective approaches for leading and managing the hospital environment. Thereby, avoiding negative effects that are inappropriate for nurse-to-patient ratios.

According to Aiken et al., a positive relationship exists between nurse-staffing ratios and preventable patient death (2002). Arguments raised consider legislations to be having a high potential of leading political and economic devaluation of the nursing profession due to the fixed ratios. Therefore, failure to deal with nursing staffing ratios will be rampant. The mandatory proponents for staffing ratios argue that it will improve quality of care. Since the satisfaction of patients and nurses is enhanced, the nursing work environment will be improved. Improvement in the work environment attracts new nurses and licensed nurses who are not working currently. Staffing critics argue that by mandating specific staffing ratios in environments where the shortage is on the high, leads to the reduction of hospital services, increased unit closures, increased diversions in the emergency...

Staffing ratios are complex with multiple variables and using the mandated staffing ratios approach does not guarantee a healthy working environment for nurses. Additionally, the safety and quality levels are not sufficient in preventing the adverse patient outcomes. AONE's position on mandatory staffing ratios asserts that it serves only to increase stress on systems in the health care as it is overburdened with escalating shortage of professionally registered nurses both nationally and internationally. Thus, the mandatory staffing ratios approach has a potential of creating greater risks to the safety of the public (AONE, par. 4).
Leadership and Manager Approach Comparison to the Issue

According to Hughes et al., the distinction between leaders and managers is as follows (2006):

Leaders develop, managers maintain

Leaders originate, managers initiate

Leaders innovate; managers administer

In terms of status quo leaders' challenge, managers accept it

Leaders view is long-term, managers use short-term view

Leaders inspire, managers control

Leaders ask why and what, managers ask when and how.

However, a leader is not made from an individual's job title only, but rather his/her behavior is the determinant. It is always expected that a leader can inspire, innovate, challenge and, guide as stated above. However, the underlying question is whether these behaviors and practices are present in today's nursing leaders (Curtis et al., 2011, p. 307).

Nursing staffing ratios impacts manager's responsibility since a shortage of nurses increases the chance of error due to the improper treatment accorded to patients and nurses being burned out. Additionally, nurses are easily overworked or discouraged as they…

Sources used in this document:
References List:

Aiken L., Clarke S., Sloane D., Sochalski J., Silber, J. (2002). Hospital Nurse Staffing and Patient Mortality, Nurse Burnout, and Job Dissatisfaction. Journal of the American Medical Association, 288: 1987-1993.

AONE. Mandated staffing ratios. Retrieved from http://www.aone.org/resources/leadership%20tools/staffingratios.shtml

Curtis, E., Vries, J. & Sheerin, F. (2011). Developing Leadership in Nursing: Exploring Core factors. British Journal of Nursing, 20(5): 306-309.

Hughes, R., Ginnett, R. & Curphy, G. (2006). Leadership: Enhancing the lessons of Experience, (5th Eds.). McGraw-Hill, Boston.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Nursing and Leadership Issues
Words: 3013 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Leadership for Advanced Practice Nursing 1 Staffing is not the main issue in elevating or containing costs: the main issue is retention. High turnover rates in nursing can drive costs up, but proper staffing with an appropriate ratio of nurses to patients can actually reduce costs over the long-term so long as turnover is not an issue. The reason is that appropriate staffing leads to improvements in quality care delivery (Martin, 2015).

Analyzing Nursing Shortage Risk Management Plan
Words: 2348 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Nursing Shortage Risk Management Plan Nursing staff scarcity constitutes a widespread issue across several segments of the healthcare sector. It is often a challenge to find an adequate number of qualified nursing professionals for meeting staffing requirements. Nursing professionals represent a crucial part of healthcare teams and facilities. A dearth of qualified nurses may leave a healthcare facility vulnerable. Furthermore, because of staff shortages, existing workers are usually expected to work

Theory and Nursing Practice Issues Nursing
Words: 3046 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Nursing: Theory and Nursing Practice Issues Theory and Nursing Practice Issues: Nursing The modern-day staff nurse faces a variety of challenges in the work environment. These include inadequate staffing, the authority gradient, and issues related to changing models of care. The nurse leader has a duty to aid staff nurses working under him in addressing the challenges posed by these, and other issues facing the nursing profession. Leadership theories provide effective guidelines

Inadequate Staffing In Nursing
Words: 2376 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Essay Topic Examples 1. The Impact of Inadequate Nursing Staff on Patient Care Quality This essay could explore the direct correlation between inadequate staffing levels in nursing and the decline in patient care quality. It may discuss specific outcomes such as increased patient morbidity and mortality, medication errors, and the inability to perform essential health interventions. Additionally, it should analyze how suboptimal patient care stemming from insufficient staff undermines the healthcare system's

Nosocomial Infections and Infections
Words: 1592 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Nurse burnout is a common occurrence. This can exacerbate an ongoing problem that is seen in hospitals, nosocomial infections. Nosocomial infections remain prevalent for patients with extended hospital stays like those in intensive care units. An infection that starts roughly 48 hours after admission, those in intensive care units (ICUs) experience a continued rate of infection leading to increase length of stay, mortality, and morbidity. The number of patients that

Management and Decision Sciences From
Words: 25680 Length: 90 Document Type: Thesis

76). As automation increasingly assumes the more mundane and routine aspects of work of all types, Drucker was visionary in his assessment of how decisions would be made in the years to come. "In the future," said Drucker, "it was possible that all employment would be managerial in nature, and we would then have progressed from a society of labor to a society of management" (Witzel, p. 76). The

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now