Verified Document

Religious Freedom And Amendment Term Paper

¶ … First Amendment Shutting Mosques, Trump and First Amendment

The proposal by trump, at its very core, would seek to sanction a religious institution by virtue of the adherence of its members to certain religious beliefs. Indeed, this is exactly what the first amendment speaks against. The first amendment protects religious freedom and outlaws anything that would bar the free exercise of one's religion of choice. It is referred to as the Free Exercise Clause. Trump could say that he only sought to sanction the mosques that propagate what he refers to as radical Islam. However, he did not provide any evidence of activity or advocacy on any mosques.

The crucial right to religious freedom is enshrined in the U.S. constitution's first amendment. It states that Congress is bound not to make any law that respects establishment of a given religion or stops the free exercise of religious practice. The Free Exercise Clause, which is the latter half of the declaration guards religious freedom in various contexts. It bars the government from interfering with the religious practice of a group or an individual and further bars the government from targeting religious acts for circumscription (Dreisbach and Hall, 2009). Religious persons and groups are also provided with limited protection against laws that can be applied generally. This is also how the contraceptive mandate finds fault with the First Amendment.

Such a modified proposal would still not only be ineligible; based on the Free Exercise Clause but also in light of the Free Speech clause also enshrined in the First Amendment; which allows for stopping speech that is inciting with immediacy but not one that is simply widely controversial and that might trigger some violent act in future. Any talk that attempts to restrict the religious practice of Islam comes in direct conflict with the First Amendment (Dreisbach, Hall and Morrison, 2009).

The reason for the above observation...

Suffice to say, shutting down a mosque would obviously be unconstitutional. The issue of whether it is unconstitutional may also be determined by whether we apply the constitution as was intended by the crafting fathers or using it as mangled and twisted by the court systems.
Lawyer: plaintiffs- Muslim Mosque

In the event of attempt to close mosques, the resultant case would, most probably, have two parties; the government/the residency as defendants on one hand, and the mosques as the plaintiffs on the other hand. I will argue the case on behalf of the mosques in this paper.

Arguing for the Muslim Congregation

The First amendment clearly protects a number of basic liberties, i.e. freedom of speech, freedom of religion, press freedom, freedom to petition and freedom of assembly. The interpretation of the limits of the First amendment has proven to be a hard task. Many cases have made attempts to define the scope of the freedoms. Indeed, the definition of the First Amendment has also evolved through the history of America. It has not ended. The freedom of religion is catered for in two clauses in the constitution. There is the establishment Clause that bars the government from starting an official church, and the Free Exercise Clause that allows freedom of worship (Dreisbach et al., 2009). It is notable that the phrase on separation of the state and the church does not…

Sources used in this document:
References

Dreisbach, D.L. & Hall, M.D. and Morrison, J. (2009). The Forgotten Founders on Religion and Public Life Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press.

Dreisbach, D.L. and Hall, M.D. (2009). The Sacred Rights of Conscience: Selected Readings on Religious Liberty and Church-State Relations in the American Founding. Indianapolis, IN: Liberty Fund Press.

Emerson, T.I. (1963). Toward a General Theory of the First Amendment, Yale Law Journal, vol. 72, no. 5, pp. 877 -- 956.

Kabala, J. S. (2013). Church-State Relations in the Early American Republic, 1787-1846. London: Pickering and Chatto.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 2012 Was
Words: 1226 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 2012 was introduced by Senator Marco Rubio for the purpose of repealing the recent mandate that infringes religious freedom and conscience rights of religious organizations by the recent mandate within President Obama's healthcare law. The bill was developed in order to revoke the provisions in the new health care law that compels religious of faith-based institutions to provide employees with insurance coverage for contraception without

Religious Freedom and Freedom
Words: 1482 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Paper

Isaac Backus Role in Shaping of the Southern Baptist Religion in the Early American Colonies Only a few Baptists were present in colonial America but their number was highest in Pennsylvania and Rhode Island because of the freedoms in those places. Baptists were greatly despised in nearly all regions but mainly in New England. Luckily for the Baptists present in America, they actually gained more from the Great Awakening compared to

Constitutional Law Religious Freedom and
Words: 810 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

In addition to the argument that the law's requirement of hanging the Ten Commandments is contrary to a country with no established religion, the commandments were also serving no functional purpose but a religious one. In many schools, the teaching of religion and religious ideas occurs in social studies, history, and culture classes. This contributes to students' understanding of different viewpoints, heritages, and the foundations of countries and institutions. Thus,

Do Religious Freedoms Violate Gay Rights
Words: 1399 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Ethics & Gay Rights The author of this report seeks to explain and fathom the current debate that is going on as it relates to gays and other "non-traditional" couples like lesbians, transgenders and so forth getting married much like heterosexual couples in the United States have done for centuries. The author of this report shall be truly ethical and say up front that she supports gay marriage but she will

Freedom of Association Facts the
Words: 1997 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

S. citizens. In this program designed to help young ones value the freedoms they currently experience: according to Tyler Barnwell, stands for grievance, as in "to petition the government for a redress of grievances." which denotes religious freedom, Leslie Anne Hill, a Presbyterian, states: "means you don't have to follow a certain religion." stands for freedom of assembly, Sherri Jones states is "the right to get together with other people peaceably, but

Freedom of Association in Malaysia When One
Words: 4830 Length: 15 Document Type: Essay

Freedom of Association in Malaysia When one talks about the foundation of a powerful civil society, freedom of association is very important for the foundation along with the rule of law, freedom of religion, freedom of expression and free and competitive elections. Freedom of association is also an important part of the pluralistic democracy (Tekle, 2010). The previous communist countries of the Central and Eastern Europe which had been, in the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now