Verified Document

Religion And Abortion When A Hospital's Moral Book Report

Religion and Abortion When a hospital's moral and ethical decision making process comes into conflict with the source that provides funds for the hospital -- or goes against the grain of the values of the funding source -- the results can expected to be controversial at best and harmful to humans at the worst. Indeed, to be specific, when the Roman Catholic Church provides funds for a hospital, the Church expects that its tenets, canons, codes of belief and moral values will be reflected in the policies of that hospital. Is this fair to the doctors and nurses in the hospital who have their own oaths to guide their professional actions? And is it fair to the patients who come to the hospital with urgent healthcare needs that to them, supersede any spiritual values or creeds that hospital funding sources might expect to be followed? The answer to both of those questions is a resounding "no"!

The case that brought about a lawsuit by the American Civil Liberties Union

The issue in question is the case in Muskegon, Michigan, in 2010, when Tamesha Means needed urgent hospital care and the only hospital in her county was Mercy Health, a hospital funded by the Roman Catholic Church. Means was 18 weeks pregnant and suddenly her water broke, which created a situation in which the baby had little to no chance of surviving. She had no choice but to seek immediate medical help, and according to a lawsuit filed against the Roman Catholic bishop's by the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), she went to Mercy Health only to be turned down twice for care.

An article in The New York Times by Erik Eckholm points out that Means' first attempt to get help at Mercy Health was met with rejection. In fact, cruel though one can clearly see in hindsight, the doctors at this Catholic-supported hospital failed to inform Means that her fetus would have zero chance of survival and that continuing her pregnancy...

The next morning Means, the mother of two children, returned to Mercy Health. She was "bleeding and in pain," Eckholm reports, and what was the hospital's response during her second visit? Cruelly, he was sent home again.
When she went back a third time, hoping the doctors would see the enormous amount of pain she was going through -- and the third time she had an infection as well -- the hospital prepared to send her home - again. But while the hospital staff was preparing her discharge paperwork, "…she began to deliver," the ACLU press release explained. "Only then did the hospital begin tending to Tamesha's miscarriage," the ACLU continued. The lawsuit is not against Mercy Health Partners, but rather against the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB). The ACLU stated in its press release that the directives that the USCCB places on the hospitals it funds -- which prohibit "a pre-viability pregnancy termination, even when there is little or no chance that the fetus will survive, and the life or health of a pregnant woman is at risk" -- then the USCCB is "…ultimately responsible" for the unnecessary pain, trauma, and emotional harm that Tamesha was forced to endure (ACLU, 2013).

How insensitive can a healthcare organization be and still be recognized as a legitimate source of medical care in the community? This is an issue that isn't just about hospital care or abortion; this boils down to the inhumane actions of a facility that is supposed to be serving the healthcare needs of the public. It is germane to this issue to take a look at the modern version of the Hippocratic Oath, published in NOVA (a Public Broadcast Service -- PBS -- program). These passages are part of the oath that all doctors and nurses are asked to live up to.

"I swear…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

American Civil Liberties Union. "Tamesha Means v. United States Conference of Catholic

Bishops." Retrieved December 13, 2013, from http://www.aclu.org. 2013.

Eckholm, Erik. "Bishops Sued Over Anti-Abortion Policies at Catholic Hospitals." The New

York Times. Retrieved December 13, 2013, from http://www.nytimes.com.
Retrieved December 13, 2013, from http://www.nytimes.com. 2010.
Tyson, Peter. "The Hippocratic Oath Today." NOVA / Public Broadcast Service. Retrieved December 13, 2013, from http://www.pbs.org. 2001.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Abortion and Critically Examine Various Christian Responses
Words: 2980 Length: 11 Document Type: Essay

Abortion AND CRITICALLY EXAMINE VARIOUS CHRISTIAN RESPONSES ( CATHOLICS, EVANGELICALS, AND LIBERALS) TO SUBJECT. CHRISTIAN ETHICS IS TGE COURSE. THANK YOU AGAIN, GOOD JOB. Christian Views on Abortion The Christian Church has always had strict regulations when concerning matters like abortion. Even with the fact that the Christian Bible contains no information about the practice, many Christians have gotten actively engaged in trying to denounce it as being against God's will. Some

Hospital Ethics to Do or
Words: 5897 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

The clinical trial team includes doctors, nurses, social workers, data entry technicians and other health care professionals (NWHRC 2005). They review a participant's health history and current medical intakes before the trial begins. They impart adequate information and instructions about the clinical trial, monitor each participant in the conduct of the trial and may contact the participant after the conduct of the trial. Clinical trials or researches may also be open-label,

Abortion in Politics
Words: 2649 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Abortion in Politics The argument on legality of abortion is nurtured deep into root of American society. The judgment on Roe v. Wade where abortion became legal to today's politics. This paper analyses in depth the issue surrounding this subject and present solutions and considerations. The struggle for sexual rights has been linked to the process of building citizenship and has been challenged mainly by entrenched conservative groups like Parents' groups, or

Abortion Nature Intends That an Offspring Should
Words: 2555 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Abortion Nature intends that an offspring should begin and develop in the mother's baby until it is mature enough to be delivered and live on its own. Those nine months of gestation in the mother's womb pose a long-standing controversy, which pits the rights of the unborn child against the rights of the mother. One side, called pro-life, holds that the embryo or fetus has full and distinct rights to life

Abortion or Not
Words: 521 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

theories being used in the Jessica cases study. The essay suggests that a theory of morals is being implemented for all involved. The baby itself and its condition, including its soul or spirit is not being respected. The case study depicting the working couple of Marco and Jessica presents some interesting moral and ethical dilemmas for health care and the role of providing useful and practical medical advice. Morals

Legalization of Abortion
Words: 3603 Length: 11 Document Type: Research Paper

Abortion: Pro-Choice Abortion (pro-choice) Women in the United States faced many difficulties before the legalization of abortion. The case of Roe vs. Wade is famous as this case allowed for the legalization of abortion K. Jones & Chaloner, 2007. Before the legalization of abortion, there were women who still aborted illegally, and all that legalization provided for was a safe environment for the women to perform abortion. Legalization of abortion provided women with

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now