Verified Document

Reflexive Practice, Leadership And Critical Thinking All Essay

¶ … Reflexive Practice, Leadership and Critical Thinking All three themes -- critically reflective practice, leadership, and critical thinking, can be summarized in the following snippet: An American president, as President Reagan's speechwriter, Peggy Noonan (1990), discovered experiences America by looking down. Much of his time is spent encountering his country and people via helicopter from which he sees tiny houses, tiny people, tiny cars, tiny roads. Noonan wondered how this affected Reagan's perspective. She later found out that it compelled him to see them as outside of himself and as himself as distinct from them.

This snippet, it seems to me, is somewhat what reflective thinking, critical thinking, and leadership are all about. Each concept contains a meta-analytic sort of substance, similarly to inhabiting a plateau where the air is more refined and where the person is separate from others.

Let's take these concepts one by one.

Critically reflexive practice: Pungently, Brookfield (1998) compares this to a dog trying to catch its tail. Being 'in' ourselves', it is utterly impossible for ourselves to see ourselves and our existence (or ontology) in a transcendental manner. The closest we can come to this, Brookfield (1998) suspects, is via four types of lenses: the lens of our own autobiographies as critical thinkers; the lens of learners' eyes; the lens of colleagues' perceptions; and the lens of theoretical, philosophical, and research literature.

1. The lens of our own autobiographies as critical thinkers -- Our habits of thoughts, decisions, and actions are, invariably, rooted in a mix of enculturation, personal experience, and social programming. Critically examining our autobiography may help us uncover certain roots to our habits.

2. The lens of learners' eyes -- welcoming criticism and attempting to see the piece of learning through the eyes of the other

3. The lens of colleagues' perceptions -- discussing and sharing our thoughts and perceptions with colleagues provides us with access to their original insights and illuminations.

4. The lens of theoretical, philosophical, and research literature -- Theory provides multiple perspectives on our one habitual perspective of 'reality'. Multi-faceted perspective...

This can help her become more reflective and calm as well as enabling her to make more rational decisions.
2. Leadership

Describing three exercises that he habitually uses in his workshops, Ayers (2002) demonstrates how (with 'The Uncritical Inference Test') we each tend to think in different ways to the other; each of us has our own particular way of thinking. The second exercise ('The Ladder of Inference') demonstrates how personal inferences are apt to trip us up and it were advisable to share our thoughts and perceptions with another. And, finally, 'Thinking Out of the Box' entails not only 'getting out of my box' but also 'crawling into the box of another'.

None of these exercises are simple or easy to do on a continuous basis. Nonetheless, the benefits of doing them are enormous since they make us into more effective communicators; hence better leaders who become more self-aware of ourselves and aware and respectful of others.

3. Critical Thinking

Critical thinking is developed through critical reading and critical reading is a skill. Elder and Paul (2003) suggest various strategies that can be used in order to acquire this ability. Strategies include: (1) Reading for a purpose; continuously keeping in mind the objective of the reading task; (2) considering the author's purpose; why has the author written the book / article etc. What does she wish to transmit. (3) Developing a map of knowledge, i.e. seeing the interrelated parts between interdisciplinary subjects. (4) Reading to understand systems of thought; not merely reading but endeavoring to understand what one has read; and (5) Reading within disciplines -- seeing the subject matter as a unit within a greater particular subsystem of thought.

A good reader looks for systems of meaning in a text and thinks into them and into the author's intention. This promotes critical thinking and enhances one's reflective abilities.

Identify possible applications or areas to explore further in the scholar-practioner-leader model.

What has always intrigued…

Sources used in this document:
References

Noonan, P. (1990). What I saw at the Revolution: A political life in the Reagan era, USA: Ivy Books.

Brookfield, S.(1998). Critically reflective practice. Journal of Continuing Education in health professions,18, 197

Ayers, M.(2002). Leadership.Shared meaning, and semantics.etc. Cetera, 59, 287

Elder, L., & Paul, R.(2003). Critical Thinking...and the art of close reading (Part I). Journal of Developnment Education 27, 36 -- 39..
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Leadership That Influenced Me. Leadership
Words: 2341 Length: 7 Document Type: Thesis

Change may be difficult for a company, but necessary if the company is to survive. An effective leader is one who is able to harness and negotiate this change so that the company is able to deal with it and survive. Some limitations to overcome A leader has to possess the following characteristics: Empowerment; Risk-taking; Participation; and Development (Eicher; online). In a practical sense, this translates into the following schema: I

Leadership Characteristics of Administrators to
Words: 9690 Length: 30 Document Type: Term Paper

Most conclusions on this approach were vague or indecisive in terms of social, psychological or mental significance (Rice, 1978, 1981; Graen et al., 1972; Ashour, 1973). Furthermore, over the years, many scholars have come to the realization that leadership is situational and hence there are many realistic settings like the environment, the employees, the resources, etc. that determine the characteristics needed in a leader as well as his/her business approach

Nursing Theory From the View of a
Words: 1634 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Nursing Theory from the View of a Mirror, Microscope and Telescope The objective of this work is to examine perspective of nursing theory from the view of a mirror, a microscope, and a telescope. Theories are described as "a set of interrelated concepts that give a systematic view of a phenomenon that is explanatory and predictive in nature." (Nursing Theories, 2010) Theories are stated to be composed of "concepts, definitions, models, propositions

Personal Leadership Statement Leadership Is One of
Words: 1937 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Personal Leadership Statement Leadership is one of the most needed qualities and skills in today's world. Because of globalization, more and more diverse interests and cultures are coming into greater contact with one another. To reconcile these differences is the task of leadership (Rondinelli & Heffron, 2009). Effective leadership can help society to realize the promises of such interactions while ineffective leadership is more likely to stoke such differences and amass

Present a Problem
Words: 932 Length: 3 Document Type: Discussion Chapter

Reflexivity in a Leadership Context According to Ann L. Cunliffe (2004) in her article "On becoming a critically reflexive practitioner," effective managerial practice demands an existential understanding of the implications of leadership beyond conventional business theory of 'what works' and what 'doesn't work' in practice. The manager must have a clear understanding of who he or she is and his or her effect upon others. There is no single way

Nhs Change: Analysis of Nurse-Led
Words: 3444 Length: 11 Document Type: Case Study

The variability in problems faced by the King Edward Hospital NHS Trust during the period in question, instigated a multi-level response in knowledge sharing and inclusion on practice. Kotter's theory relies upon such a method, where strategies are an exercise multi-tiered obligation. As Kotter points out, the transformation model may not be suitable for organizations that are in pursuit of prompt change, and the series of responsibilities which result from

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now