Verified Document

Randomized Critical Appraisal Controlled Trial Chapter

Related Topics:

¶ … Randomized Controlled Trial The objective of this study is to carry out a critical appraisal of the article titled "Physical activity long-term after liver transplantation yields a better quality of life." (Rongles, St.-pniewska, Lewandowska et al. 2011 p 126). The authors investigate the relationship between quality of life and physical activity in a randomly selected patients.

Validity of the Results

The goal of the RCA (rapid critical appraisal) is to evaluate the validity of the research results, and the relevance of the results for the treatment and intervention of liver complications. The results are valid because the authors collect data of Group A and Group B and compare their results to present the outcome of the physical activities after transplantation. The Group B indulges in weekly physical and recreational activities that include cycling (53.8%), swimming (30.9%) and hiking (30.9%) compared to Group A with zero weekly physical activity. A comparative analysis of the quality of life of the two groups supports the validity of the study because the results of group A are substantially worse with reference to the quality of life assessment. However, better results are recorded for group B with reference to BP (bodily pain) outcomes, PF (physical functioning), SF (social functioning) and GH (general health).

The researchers randomly selected group A and group B for the experimental and...

However, the author selected the group B for the experimental group and group B, controlled group, from the patients of OLT (orthotopic liver transplantation) who filled the questionnaire. After the data analysis has been carried out, the researchers labeled group A as patients who do not indulge in a physical activity and group B as patients who perform a physical activity at least once in a week. The data analysis shows that the control group is appropriate because the same number of participants are used for both the control group and experimental group. However, the authors concealed a random assignment from the subject participants to eliminate the possibility of bias in the experiment using a random method to select the participants and the randomization was concealed from the participants.
Rongles et al. (2011) used "a modified SF-36 (36-Item Short Form Survey Instrument, RAND 36-Item Health Survey 1.0 Questionnaire Items" (p 128) as an instrument for the experiment. The tool is considered reliable and accurate, and "has been used in numerous scientific studies" (Rongles et al. 2011 p 128) making the instruments be reliable and valid. The results reveal that the subjects in each group are similar with regards to their baseline health and demographic. For example, 13 participants (9 female and 4 males) were recruited for group A. Similarly, 13 participants (9 females and 4 males) were recruited for group B. However,…

Sources used in this document:
Reference

Rongles, W., St.-pniewska, S., Lewandowska, M. et al. (2011). Physical Activity Long-term after Liver Transplantation yields Better Quality of Life. Ann Transplant, 16(3): 126-131.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Critical Analysis Mental Illness
Words: 3769 Length: 10 Document Type: Essay

Mental illness appears in various forms. It is characterized by some serious disruptions in someone's thoughts or even demonstrated in their actions. The person presenting these symptoms is often unable to deal with the day-to-day activities and patterns of a normal life. Mental illness can take over 200 forms each having an effect on the patient's disposition, character, traits, and even the way they interact with others. Some of the

Evidence-Based Nursing Assessment Item Critical
Words: 1304 Length: 3 Document Type: Questionnaire

Sampling method -117 patients with primary breast cancer; all who had same-day surgery as part of their treatment. Appropriateness of sample -- Appropriate for circumstances under consideration. Results (when applicable: credibility, transferability, dependability, & conformability) Study found significant differences between the control and experimental group in terms of post-surgery mood, confusion, tension, and home management. Ethical considerations -- All ethical considerations; privacy, etc. followed- professional study. Relative strengths of each publication -- Peer reviewed strong

Combating Workplace Stress Using Cognitive Behavioral Therpay
Words: 20851 Length: 44 Document Type: Essay

…Occupational Stress and Scientific MonitoringLiterature Review2.1 IntroductionThe definition of the term �occupational stress� is derived from the definition of its two constituent words. In this context, occupational refers to anything that is related to the workplace while stress is defined as a natural body reaction from physical, mental or emotional strain in an individual. Thus, occupational stress can be defined as any mechanism by which the body attempts to adapt

Treatments of Bulimia Nervosa the Best Option
Words: 2671 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Paper

Treatments of Bulimia Nervosa THE BEST OPTION Evaluation of Combined Therapy for Bulimia Nervosa Description and Significance Bulimia nervosa, simply bulimia or BN, refers to uncontrolled overeating or binging and then eliminating what has been eaten (SJH, 2012; Grange et al., 2004). Recent reports show alarming increases in the incidence, which now adolescents and pre-adolescents. The latest population statistics say that about 27.3 of the U.S. population is between 12 and 19 years old.

Assessing Use of Chlorhexidine in Prevention of VAP
Words: 795 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

oral chlorhexidine as preventative agent in of ventilator-associated pneumonia (VAP) in adults who are critically ill and mechanically ventilated in intensive care units (ICUs). The process of critiquing published studies leads to higher level of comprehension of empirical and evidence-based research. The discussion devotes some consideration to the way the authors addressed the protection of human participants, the research methodology -- including data collection, data management and analysis --

Diabetes Sigurdardottir, A., Benediktsson, R.,
Words: 619 Length: 2 Document Type: Article Critique

c.. Is the treatment feasible in my clinical setting? Yes No Unknown d. What are my patients/family's values and expectations for the outcome that is trying to be prevented and the treatment itself? There are several implications from this study: Identification of self-care needs are important to patients; mitigation of stronger, more invasive treatment options are thus prevented. However, some instruments are more useful than others in encouraging self-care or monitoring behavioral change. Use

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now