Verified Document

Race And Revolution Book Critique Term Paper

Who would say that the revolution was inevitable, without the fight of the patriots and the leadership of the Founding Fathers? Yes, the question of slavery was a contentious issue -- but it was just as contentious a hundred years later, a hundred more years of bondage for blacks, and a hundred more years of making the unacceptable institution acceptable and entrenched in the American fabric. The book is organized particularly effectively in that it allows the author to advance his clearly articulated thesis, structure the different historical experiences of African-Americans before, during, and after the actual warfare of the Revolution and then include an appendix of primary source documents. The book has a chronological structure in this sense, which makes it easy for non-experts in the Revolutionary War period to follow, but still advances a compelling argument with a clear thesis that makes the book interesting reading, not merely a textbook.

Nash also introduces many ideas regarding this period of history that may be surprising to a layperson, and perhaps even to a historical expert. For example, he illustrates slavery made the new republic weaker and less safe, because it divided the populace and because slaves were less productive as workers. Slaves were also less loyal to the territory they lived upon than full, free citizens, and thus made the nation more ripe and open to foreign invasion. Of course, all of these arguments have parallels between the arguments of the Founding Fathers in favor of entitling the colonies to representation in Parliament, and then to independence.

Furthermore, dividing a nation between slave and freed states made the nation weaker, not stronger, as is illustrated by the constant chafing of slave, Southern states against the North's attempt to exert federal control upon the territories. Allowing slavery in parts of the union essentially kept the dream of confederation, rather than union alive, in the hearts of many southerners, and southern state legislatures. Besides the human cost of extending the debate over slavery for nearly a hundred...

Or perhaps it might have been possible for the new federal government to extend compensation for freed slaves, given that the cost would have been less prohibitive in the 18th century. Yet, despite all of these possibilities, still the idea is perpetuated that slavery was necessary in the interim for the new nation.
Nash's most valuable insight, besides exposing the tragedy and cowardice as well as the triumph that was the American Revolution, is to question commonly shared historical assumptions and myths. Americans like to think that their nation is unique, yet America has been equally beset with racial and ethnic divisions as the nations of Europe, and struggled just as mightily and imperfectly to overcome these divisions. America also experiences a fundamental disconnect between its espoused ideology and the way that it has behaved historically as other nations.

Nash's thesis is clearly stated regarding the revolution, but his treatment of American history has implications beyond that of race -- Americans can never accept their own uniqueness, or believe that America was the first nation to 'discover' human freedom. After all, African-Americans, some in the service of the British, were fighting for their freedom and their inalienable rights to be human long before the constitution was even created. Nash's book is scholarly, and contains impressive support from its primary documents, but the actual essays, without extensive digression or tangential footnoting, read like cries of justice and critiques of the American experiment of democracy as well as supported historical analysis.

Works Cited

Nash, Gary. (1990). Race and the Revolution. New York: Madison House Publishers, Inc.

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Nash, Gary. (1990). Race and the Revolution. New York: Madison House Publishers, Inc.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

George Washington Gomez Book Critique:
Words: 1292 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Mexicans were treated as an inferior class and an inferior race of people, in both the rhetoric of the nation and in the actual physical subjugation and displacement they were threatened by as a community. Thus, individuals such as Gualinto came to regard themselves as inferior, or the 'part' of themselves that was Mexican, as inferior. Such external threats created internal, psycholgical ideological impingements in the vulnerable hearts and minds

House of the Spirits Book
Words: 1649 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

As he examines how this was done in Chile, Silva fleshes out a great deal of the latter half of Allende's novel about the right-wing coup initially embraced by Esteban, but then used against his near and dear as absolute control falls in the hands of those whom he harmed earlier in his life. Final Evaluation According to Silva in Prevost and Vanden, the history of Chile is a history of

Gender Race and Politics in the New Nation
Words: 1084 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Race and Revolution is a voluminous examination of the revolutionary generation's early efforts to rectify the apparent contradiction of slavery and of their ultimate compromises that not only left the institution intact, but provided it with the protection of a vastly strengthened government after 1788. "Race and Revolution" by Gary Nash describes the free black community's response to this failure of the revolution's promise, its vigorous and articulate pleas for

Terminator and Matrix Revolutions When a Californian
Words: 2107 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

Terminator and Matrix Revolutions When a Californian speaks of the "terminator," almost anyone listening will wonder briefly if the emerging dialogue is to be about the actor/governor of California (Arnold Schwarzenegger) or the film, The Terminator. And if the discussion is to be about the movie The Terminator then which "Terminator" will be in focus - one, two, or three? For purposes of this paper, the focus will be on The

American Revolution Was Modeled After Revolutions in
Words: 1999 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

American Revolution Was Modeled After Revolutions in France and England The American quest for freedom, modeled after reform movements in England and France, has resulted in the most revered democratic society in the world. We are free of the religious and political tyranny that plagued Europe in the 18th Century and early colonialists would approve of our government in 2002. While the American Revolution and the quest for freedom was modeled after

Eleanor Roosevelt. The Critique Is
Words: 2132 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Paper

" Her intelligence enabled her to come up with solutions to various problems in the real world. As an illustration, she identified the fat that women reporters were being unfairly treated. She stood up for them publicly and this saw the situation change. This indicated that she had a high level of practical knowledge. Practical knowledge is described as the ability to comprehend the day-to-day problems (Mayer, 2007). Eleanor Roosevelt was

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now