Verified Document

Quantitative Proposal On Three Strike California Law Research Proposal

Three Strikes High crime rates are a societal problem that has changed the manner in which society functions. Recognizing the adverse effects that crime has on communities the state of California has implemented a three strikes law designed to deter crime particularly as it pertains to repeat offenders. The propose research will examine the effectiveness of California's three strike law as it pertains to deterring recidivism. Statistical data concerning crime rates and rates of recidivism following the enactment of the law will be analyzed and compared to the same statistic prior to the passage of the law. The results will examine the extent to which the deterrence effect has been effective as it pertains to the three strikes law.

Background

Crime is a major social problem throughout the country. More specifically criminals who are repeat offenders make up a substantial number of the individuals that commit crime. With this understood many, states throughout the nation have developed programs that attempt to deter people from becoming habitual criminals. These programs are based on the deterrence theory of crime. This particular theory asserts that

"the more certain and severe the perceived punishment for a particular crime, the more likely individuals are to believe that the crime is not in their best interest. Therefore, they will not engage the act. In this sense, deterrence theory may be placed beneath the umbrella of the theory of reasoned action and its extension, the theory of planned behavior (e.g., Ajzen, 1991). These theories seek to explain intention to behave in a general sense, whereas deterrence theory aims to predict a specific set of intentions; that is, those directed at lawbreaking (Strelan & Boeckmann 2006, 2912)."

The state of California implemented the three strikes law in March of 1994 as a type of legislation designed to deter criminals from repeatedly committing crimes. This legislation "was enacted as Chapter 12, Statutes of 1994 (AB 971, Jones) by the Legislature and by the electorate in Proposition 184 (A Primer: Three Strikes - The Impact After More Than a Decade, 2005)." Under this law there is a minimum sentence of 25 years to life for individuals who are three-time repeat offenders. The law pertains to individuals who have previous serious or violent felony convictions (A Primer: Three Strikes - The Impact After More Than a Decade, 2005). The Three Strikes law has been controversial because it drastically increases the sentences that some repeat offenders are given. For instance, "a defendant who has prior convictions for assault on a police officer and burglary of a residence, both considered serious or violent crimes. " This defendant is also arrested for receiving stolen property, a nonserious and nonviolent felony. Prior to the implementation of the Three Strikes law, he would have served a two-year sentence for the property offense. However as a result of the law, he would receive a life sentence (A Primer: Three Strikes - The Impact After More Than a Decade, 2005).

Goodno, (2007) explains that within the state of California the three strikes law was implemented as a response to the murders of young girls by career criminals. Indeed, in the early part of the 1990's the murder of two young girls increased the awareness of the citizens of California's to the problems of criminal recidivism. The first of the two murder occurred in 1992 when eighteen-year-old Kimber Reynolds was killed during an attempted robbery. The person who murdered her was a paroled felon whose criminal record included gun and drug charges. Following the death of Kimber, her father began to encourage legislators to implement more stringent sentencing for repeat criminals (Goodno, 2007).

In an effort to get tougher legislation passed Reynolds testified in front of the California Legislature in support of a bill involving the three strikes composition for habitual criminals. The bill called for sentencing of 25 years to life for repeat offenders. At the time the bill did not become law. However a few months after the bill was struck down Polly Klaas, who was twelve years old, was also murdered by an individual will a long criminal history. Eventually the Klaas murder became a major catalyst for the development and implementation of the three strikes legislation in California.

Since implementing the legislation, questions as to whether this program is working as a deterrent have persisted. Many argue that this program is too stringent and has done nothing more than increase the prison population. Many also assert that the problem of crime in California has only been decreased by a minimal amount and that such decreases would have been realized even if the state had...

Of the states that implemented such laws, California has been the most persistent in enforcing these laws. In the years since the implementation of the tree strikes laws in California there have been several studies aimed at determining whether or not the law has been successful at deterring crime.
Theoretical Goals of Three Strikes accomplished through three strikes

Goodno (2007) reports that there are two primary theoretical principles associated with the three strikes law. In addition to the deterrence effect already discussed, the law is also based on the incapacitation effect (Goodno, 2007). The incapacitation effect involves the idea of repeat offenders being detained for longer amounts of time, during this time of incarceration offenders are incapable of committing new crimes. Additionally, proponents of the law asserted that it would have a deterrent effect. This simply means that possible criminal activity would be deterred because of the potential for longer as a result of the Three Strikes law (Goodno, 2007). Goodno (2007) asserts that studies conducted in the years since the implementation of the three strikes law have shown that the law has an effect on incapacitation and deterrence.

As it pertains to the Incapacitation Effect, observations have found that since the inception of the three strikes law the amount of sentenced third-strikers decreased every year from 1996 until 2003. Goodno (2007) also notes a similar decrease involving second-strike offenders. However, 'some claim that the drop in capital sentences since 2000 may be linked to the Three Strikes law. One possible interpretation of this decline is that there are fewer strikers every year because the law is doing its job. In other words, defendants who are habitual offenders are incapacitated and cannot commit any additional crimes while serving the longer sentence (Goodno, 2007, 9)."

Goodno, (2007) also reports that prisoners with strikes have usually committed more serious crimes than those who don't have any strikes. This is a significant issue to take into consideration because it demonstrates that the law is functioning in the manner that it was intended to function. That is the law serves the purpose of incapacitating felons who, are usually more prone than others to engage in criminal activity (Goodno, 2007).

Goodno, (2007) also contends that the law has also had a deterrent effect. This deterrent effect is most evident as it pertains to the decrease in the crime rate since the law was first implemented in 1994. Goodno, (2007) reports the finding so a 1999 study conducted by the FBIwhich suggested that

"[s]ince California enacted its three strikes law in 1994, crime has dropped 26.9%, which translates to 815,000 fewer crimes. While numerous social and economic factors underlie crime rates, the correlation between the drop in California's crime rate and the enactment of the Three Strikes law is notable. One interpretation of this correlation is that potential offenders may be deterred from committing crimes because of the possibility of serving longer sentences (Goodno, 2007)."

In addition many studies have confirmed the deterrent effect of California's three strike law. Goodno (2007 explains that in one survey most juvenile offenders questions responded that they were aware that they would be sentenced to 25 years to life they would not commit a serious or violent crime. Additionally other studies have found that the three strikes model has a deterrent effect because it "reduces felony arrests rates among the class of criminals with 1 strike by 29 to 48% & #8230; and among the class of criminals with 2 strikes by 12.5% (Goodno 2007, )." Goodno (2007) also reports that when utilizing an economic model, another study found that the Three Strikes law continues to deter offenders from committing crimes that would qualify for a first strike (Goodno 2007, ).

In addition to decreases in crime rates in California, the deterrence effect can also be observed as it relates to the parole statistics (Goodno, 2007). Goodno (2007), reports that more parolees have left the state of California than have come into the state. When giving the opinion for Ewing v. California, Justice O'Connor asserted that as "[a]n unintended but positive consequence of 'Three Strikes' has been the impact on parolees leaving the state. More California parolees are now leaving the state than parolees from other jurisdictions entering California. This…

Sources used in this document:
References

Chen, Elsa Y (2008) .Impacts of "Three Strikes and You're Out" on Crime Trends in California and Throughout the United States. Journal of contemporary criminal justice. 24(4), 345

Goodno, N.H. (2007) Career Criminals Targeted: The Verdict is in, California's Three Strikes Law Proves Effective. Golden Gate University law review. 37(2), 461

Refine or alter search

Helland E., Tabarrok, A. (2007) Does Three Strikes Deter? A Non-Parametric Estimation. Journal of Human Resources, 42 (2) p309-330
A Primer: Three Strikes - The Impact After More Than a Decade, 2005. http://www.lao.ca.gov/2005/3_strikes/3_strikes_102005.htm
http://www.jointogether.org/news/headlines/inthenews/2002/three-strikes-law-ineffective.html
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Three Strike Law the Past
Words: 2610 Length: 9 Document Type: Research Proposal

Stratified sampling will allow the research team to take these prejudices into account when examining the data so as to avoid any skewing resulting from prejudices. The potential population in this study is clearly defined. Although the effect of the three strike rule on the general public cannot be completely disregarded, it is more likely that the general public is more greatly affected by generalized criminal statutes to govern their

Public Policy Alternatives to Improve
Words: 5886 Length: 21 Document Type: Term Paper

S. General Accounting Office (GAO) estimates' in 1991 stated that nearly 30% of those incarcerated had used drugs daily in the month before committing the offense for which they were in prison. By the year 2003 there were approximately 6.9 million individuals either on probation, in mail, or in prison which equals 32% of all U.S. adults residents or 1 out of every 32 adults. (U.S. Bureau of Justice Corrections

Wal-Mart Case Study Wal-Mart Faces
Words: 9789 Length: 25 Document Type: Research Proposal

The Price-Sensitive Affluents, Wal-Mart has learned (Wal-Mart Annual Reports) is more interested in finding an exceptionally good deal and not necessarily concerned about the shopping experience. This is particularly true as one of the strongest factors influencing the execution of their strategy, the emerging global recession during this timeframe, takes hold. Again as with the Price Value Shopper and the paradoxical purchasing patterns of the Brand Aspirational segment show,

Sustainability in the UK Construction
Words: 10576 Length: 38 Document Type: Term Paper

Buildings will be required to obtain energy certification. At the current time, construction engineers are the most likely candidate for the job. This being the case, it is estimated that approximately 12,000 engineers will need to be retained to carry out these functions (Coverdale, 2002). As one can see, the EPBD will place a strain on the construction industry in terms of knowledge and the manpower needed to carry out

Differences in Following Smrs by U S And Russia Prison Systems
Words: 4325 Length: 13 Document Type: Research Proposal

TREATMENT OF PRISONERS IN THE U.S. AND RUSSIA How Does the United States Compare to Russia in Following the UN Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners? There are nearly 9 million people under certain forms of incarceration or supervision across the globe. The United States has the highest number of prisoners or individuals under some of supervision since approximately 25% of the world's prisoners are held in the country (U.S.

Underage Drinking in Certain Minorities
Words: 23424 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Proposal

Parenting Style Influence on Excess Alcohol Intake Among Jewish Youth Clinical Psychology The health hazards that are associated with adolescent alcohol use are well documented, and there is growing recognition among policymakers and clinicians alike that more needs to be done to address this public health threat. The purpose of this study was to examine the effects of different parenting styles on alcohol consumption levels among Jewish college students in the United

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now