Verified Document

Quality Assurance Kaiser Permanente A-Level Coursework

Quality Assurance: Kaiser Permanente Case Management Programs are More Concerned with Reducing Costs Than with Improving the Quality of Care

Rather than relying on generalized statements about case management programs, focused research on Kaiser Permanente (Kaiser) shows an egregious example of a "profits over patients" mentality in case management. By delaying, misdiagnosing, undertreating or not treating at all, Kaiser evidently save millions of dollars, until It gets caught. For example, in June 2010, the California Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC) fined Kaiser a $75,000 administrative penalty for unreasonably delaying diagnosis and treatment of autism for Andrew Arce. According to the DMHC, due to Kaiser's delays and denials, Andrew's treatment was delayed for more than a year and he did not receive needed treatment until he was damaged by Kaiser's delays and denials (Kaiserthrive.org, 2010).

Binding arbitration boards are also finding that Kaiser delays adequate treatment. For example, in November 2008, a Valencia, California couple was awarded $5 million by a binding arbitration panel because Kaiser was failed to timely diagnose and treat Timothy Howard's "transient ischemic attacks (TIA) of the retina which resulted in a devastating stroke" (Kaiserthrive.org, Courtesy of Vicki Travis of the Kaiser Papers, 2009). Though the treating Kaiser neurologist was aware of the need for more extensive testing, she did not order...

Misdiagnosed and underdiagnosed, Mr. Howard continued to suffer TIA, and then had a massive stroke for the incorrectly diagnosed, untreated condition. Since the stroke, Mr. Howard, a once-healthy 46-year-old Middle School assistant principal: is wheelchair bound with no use of his left arm and weakness on his left side; needs 24/7 assistance with all life aspects; suffers cognitive and mental deficits; is clearly unable to work. The cost of his future care is estimated in the millions of dollars (Kaiserthrive.org, Courtesy of Vicki Travis of the Kaiser Papers, 2009).
Finally, cases like the Arce's and Howards' are not isolated incidents; rather, it appears that Kaiser deliberately, methodically puts costs over quality of care. In October 2010, Dr. Richard Della Penna M.D., a former Kaiser physician and one of the country's foremost experts in treatment of the elderly and special needs patients, announced that he will file a lawsuit against Kaiser for its deliberate plan to treat only 5% of the 57,000 chronically ill patients for which Kaiser received $13 Billion in Medicare funds. Directly violating the Medicare Modernization Act of 2003 and the Medicare Improvements for Patients and Providers Act of 2008, Kaiser deliberately avoids proper care management that would provide vital yearly physical, functional and psychosocial assessments for 95% of those 57,000 elderly and special needs patients (Kaiserthrive.org, 2010). Furthermore, Dr.…

Sources used in this document:
3,564,966

(Silberman, JD, DrPH, Poley, & Slifkin, PhD, 2003, p. 25).

The same study shows that case management improves "clinical outcomes" by resulting in fewer emergency room visits, fewer hospitalizations, shorter lengths of stay, fewer re-hospitalizations, more patient satisfaction and greater patient knowledge (Silberman, JD, DrPH, Poley, & Slifkin, PhD, 2003, p.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Kaiser Permanente
Words: 1492 Length: 3 Document Type: Assessment

Kaiser Permanente is a titan of the managed health care industry. Established in 1945, it has grown to enormous proportions, serving approximately 9 million members through the efforts of 180,600 employees. Such gigantic proportions and wide arrays of services necessitate complex management. The organization has succeeded in establishing management that works "from the top down" with mixed results. Assessment of the Various Management Levels and Their Role in Kaiser Permanente Kaiser Permanente

Kaiser Permanente
Words: 942 Length: 3 Document Type: A2 Outline Answer

Kaiser Permanente Quality Assurance Program Kaiser Permanente Facility description. Kaiser Permanente is a healthcare organization that had its origins in the pre-war industrial sector. The program offered health care for workers in the steel mills, the shipyards, and the construction companies in a nation just recovering from the depression and attempting to stand apart from the conflict and volatility evidenced across the globe. A young surgeon, Sidney Garfield, borrowed money to build Contractors

Licensure Certification and Accreditation Kaiser Permanente
Words: 982 Length: 3 Document Type: Assessment

Kaiser Permanente (N. California) NCQA Accreditation Kaiser Permanente (Northern California) NCQA Accreditation Accreditation is a comprehensive evaluation process in which a health care organization's systems, processes and performance are examined by an impartial external organization -- an accrediting body -- to ensure that it is conducting business in a manner that meets predetermined criteria and is consistent with national standards (Iglehart, 1996). The 2010 federal Affordable Care Act (ACA) calls for use

Cultural Competency and Healthcare in Canada
Words: 4914 Length: 15 Document Type: Essay

Cultural Competency Health Professionals Canada This paper discusses cultural competency for health professionals in Canada. Defining cultural competence for healthcare as respectful awareness of cultural differences, the importance of this perspective is discussed. Aspects of cultural competency, ranging from the purview of the healthcare insurance industry, to the perspective of the Canadian Nurses Association, are presented. Also, Rani Srivastava's 'Guide to Clinical Cultural Competence' is used to guide the discussion. Also,

Health Reforms and the Role of Nurse Practitioners
Words: 1696 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Nursing Practice Expected to Grow and Change Ageing of population and healthcare providers, coupled with reforms to healthcare, will raise demands for professionals in the field, also expanding existing professionals' required skill sets and roles. Physicians, physician assistants, nurse practitioners, nurses, and medical assistants are included in this growth area. Fortunately, healthcare is characterized by a swiftly expanding and large workforce (with 23000 new entrants every month, nationally); this sector progressed

Electronic Medical/Health Records Utilizing Electronic
Words: 5456 Length: 18 Document Type: Thesis

However, because they make billing more efficient, the majority of large urban practice groups and hospitals have already made the switch to electronic records, according to Michael R. Costa, attorney and associate at Greenberg Traurig, LLP, in Boston, Mass. However, he adds, most of these organizations maintain warehouses where they store paper records that have been transcribed to electronic form. "There is resistance from some about going to a

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now