Verified Document

Punishment Entails Some Standard Of Term Paper

On the other hand, cardinal proportionality supports maintenance of a realistic proportion amid all levels of punitiveness and criminal conduct gravity. While ordinal extent is scaled with respect to principles of desert, putting crime in comparison with punishment with a variety of punishments already set through cardinal limits determination, cardinal extent cannot be fixed in the similar manner. Given that there are no natural proportions amid punishment and crime, the real anchoring points of the system must be fixed with respect to some decisive factor and not desert. Once the limits are provided, proportionality becomes feasible. The proportionality of cardinal limits are set with respect to deterrence needs. According to Hirsch (1992), crime-prevention effects and accessible prison facilities are pertinent in affixing punishing scale. Given that the interpretation of prison sentences in ostensibly objective units of years or months, people acknowledge Hirsch views on the principle of proportionality. However, the principle of proportionality causes more injustices than it prevent, and its application limits intermediate sanctions, suppress their expansion, restrict their use and lead to unpreventable injustices. According to Tonry (2011), the principle of proportionality acknowledges equality in suffering for offenders; it calls for imposition of more intrusive and grave punishments than the ones needed by the prevalent political values and social norms. Tonry (2011) asserts that the principle of proportionality incorrectly objectifies punishment through allocating punishments with respect to like-situated criminals and generic punishments. This principle disregards the issue of just deserts in an unfair society since the perpetration of most common law offenses are by people from underprivileged backgrounds and these people do not deserve same penalties as people from less deprived backdrops. Tonry...

Like-situated criminals convicted of comparable crimes can fairly get different sentences that include financial penalties, incarceration and community-based sanctions.
Conclusion

Proportionality is a value for utilitarian that if not adhered to leads to dissatisfaction. However, punishment is an evil and should be employed as cautiously as possible in a manner that exclude some greater evil. The utilitarian concerns call for strict observance to principle of proportionality in punishment. This includes punishments that are separable from concepts of fairness. According to Hirsch (1992), punishment is an exercise in blaming while proportionality is a significant upshot where severe crimes call for severe punishments. While Hirsch (1992) has provided ideas of scaling the severity of crime, his proportionality assessment is not fair and practicable particularly if the offender is compelled by his mental impairment, social disadvantages or human motives to conduct a crime. Punishments that attach high value of proportionality disregard the different material condition of life. In most nations, the common law offenders come from disadvantaged and deprived areas making the issue of just deserts in an unjust society a major consideration for powerful proportionality limitation. Based on the views of Tonry and Hirsch, there lack a completely accepted means that guarantees proportionality of punishment to the crime committed and that upholds social fairness.

References

Hirsch, A. (1992). Proportionality in the philosophy of punishment. Crime and Justice, 16, 55-

98.

Tonry, M. (2011). Why Punish? How much?:…

Sources used in this document:
References

Hirsch, A. (1992). Proportionality in the philosophy of punishment. Crime and Justice, 16, 55-

98.

Tonry, M. (2011). Why Punish? How much?: A reader on punishment. Oxford: Oxford
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Punishment Program
Words: 1860 Length: 7 Document Type: Research Paper

Punishment Program This punishment program is a middle ground between incarceration and traditional probation and parole. The individuals participating in this program are released into the community, however, they are subject to very strict guidelines and conditions; failure to meet the requirements leads to a jail term in one of the state's jails to serve their sentence. The punishment program is divided into three types; house arrest, day reporting and

Eschatology the Destiny of the Unsaved
Words: 985 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Eschatology Eternal punishment is clearly outlined and explained in Matthew 25:46: "Then they will go away to eternal punishment, but the righteous to eternal life." The concept of eternal punishment is unpalatable, signaling perhaps an unjust God who "permanently installs a place of suffering in the final, eternal order," ("Annihilationism," n.d.). Yet, eternal damnation is certainly supported by scripture. Unfortunately from an eschatological perspective, there is also ample scriptural evidence in

Corrections Rehabilitation the Limits of
Words: 3662 Length: 11 Document Type: Term Paper

While its goals may be commendable, restorative justice is nevertheless a disaggregated model. Uniting relational justice, participative or consensual justice and changing or improvement justice, restorative justice has become a concept that has something for everyone (Wilson, 2012). The Case for Rehabilitation The Attack on the Rehabilitative Ideal A premise that has endured all through the history of American corrections is that labors should be put forth to reform those who commit

Daughters in Literature Requires a Thorough Analysis
Words: 1924 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Daughters in literature requires a thorough analysis of gender roles and norms. The concept of daughter is directly linked to gender roles, as being a daughter entails specific social and familial responsibilities. Daughters' rights, roles, and responsibilities vis-a-vis their male siblings can therefore become a gendered lens, which is used to read literature. This is true even when the daughters in question are not protagonists. For example, Sonya in Fyodor

Science and Religion Seek the Same Thing
Words: 1755 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

Science and Religion Seek the Same Thing Science is the study of how the human race comprehends the world around them, while religion is what they apply to translate their study on the never-ending belief. There is a radical distinction between the two because the human beings use science to explain their relationship with God, while they use science to correlate with their surroundings. According to the Muslims and Christians, creation

Discipline in Classroom Problems and Solutions
Words: 7032 Length: 25 Document Type: Dissertation or Thesis complete

Teaching -- Classroom Management Discipline in Classroom - Problems and Solutions Classroom management is the phrase that teachers use to explain the act of managing their classroom and students to make sure those stressful and non-educational circumstances are avoided and students learn subjects successfully. Classroom management entails more than the management and discipline of the students but also the accessibility of additional information on topics. Effective classroom management will make life less

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now