¶ … Allocate Funds in Order to Reduce Teacher Turnover and Improve Struggling Schools: An Analysis of 5 Academic Studies
The problem identified in this study is that the public school district receives Title One and Title Two funding, which goes to support 5 low-income schools that are struggling to show academic improvement in its student body. The funding has mostly gone to compensation for teachers, though some has also been used to support summer programs, data-driven professional development opportunities, etc. Regardless of how the funds are spent, the 5 schools have not improved: in fact, these schools have the highest rate of attrition and teacher burnout among any in the district. The result is that new staff of educators is constantly being hired and trained in these schools -- the majority of them new and inexperienced. The expected outcomes of allocating funds to these schools have not, in other words, been achieved: the district has seen no increased improvement in these schools. They remain struggling institutions, in which teacher turnover rates are the highest in the district and student academic progress is the lowest. Grovetown Elementary School is one of these institutions that seeks to understand the exact nature of the impact of funds spent, whether leadership is an issue, and whether there are any innovative possibilities that exist for making better use of the district's funding.
The following five articles were chosen because each approaches the subject of education from a unique form of inquiry, which allows the researcher to develop a better perspective on the problem at hand. The five forms of inquiry identified among these studies are: Critical Inquiry, Scientific Inquiry, Hermeneutic/Phenomenological Inquiry, Ethnographic Inquiry, and Theoretical Inquiry. Each study is described and discussed in terms of how its form of inquiry uniquely illuminates an aspect of the problem depicted above.
Critical Inquiry
Caldwell, P. (2012). Marxist Criticism of Public Education Funding and Social
Reproduction. Colgate Academic Review, 2(10): 54-58.
Caldwell's study on public education funding indicates that the primary source of funding for public schools in the U.S. is local property taxes. The study takes a critical inquiry -- specifically, Marxist Criticism -- approach to the issue of why the composition of social classes is perpetuated every generation. The finding of Caldwell (2012) is that "when public schools rely on local property taxes, their students are married to the social class from which they originated" (p. 54). What this means in terms of the larger problem identified above is that no matter how much funding is supplied by the state to the struggling schools, the essential character and social composition of the schools is not going to change because of the community in which the school is situated. These regional areas are essentially "fixed" in the sense that the composition is not likely to change short of a mandated move of persons in or out of the community. The effect that this would have would be evident in the make-up of the school, which would reflect the new social composition of the community as well as whatever social ills or positives are an extension of that community. From the critical theory standpoint, Caldwell's study of the relationship between class oppression and public school failings indicates that public school failures (in whatever form) are simply representative of the community's failure to rise above its "fixed" class system/level.
The critical form of inquiry thus helps to illuminate the "class" factor that is embedded in the problem of how to allocate funds, why teacher turnover is high, and what kind of leadership is needed to improve the schools. By ignoring the issue of class, especially considering the communities in which the 5 struggling schools are located, the researcher would be oversimplifying the problem and not addressing a significant variable -- namely, the role that community/class consciousness plays in how well schools succeed. The culture of the community and of the class of people who are stakeholders in the 5 schools will naturally have an...
School uniforms in public school has been a subject of national debate. Private and Parochial schools have a long history of school uniforms. Its implementation in public schools has been met with sharp criticism, it came to gain momentum in the late 1980's and it has been increasing steadily throughout the years. In some past few years the subject has gotten various boosts. The biggest boost was when in January
In fact, the No Child Left Behind Act, and other standardized test-based programs are "increasing incentives for school administrators to allow [poorly performing] students to quietly exit the school system ("Negative Implications," 2008). Being a high school drop out in today's society is not easy for these students, many of whom may already be disadvantaged in a variety of means. When they are simply allowed and encouraged to drop
Inconsistent evaluation methods between public, private, and charter schools, as well as the ever-present problems with whether or not achievement is actually measured accurately by standardized test scores, are two issues that must be taken into account when evaluating the findings of this report. Despite all of this negative press for charter schools, some studies do appear to show that these schools may be a positive learning atmosphere for students
Property tax relief is a subject that arises when the elderly or poor struggle to meet their property tax burdens. If they are long-term residents, they can be caught up when their neighborhood sees a dramatic increase in property values. There are sometimes mechanisms that governments use in order to provide relief. Both tax credits and rebates can be used to help return some of the money paid or that is
... Only one in 100 high school seniors could write a coherent response of more than one paragraph to an essay question; and only 7% of high school seniors could read at advanced level." (Hanushek) In the light of this vast body of very forceful evidence, we cannot but agree that our public education system has deteriorated to the extent that we can no longer expect our public schools to produce
Public School Prayer: Is it Constitutional and Moral? Proponents of allowing public school prayer cite both legal and moral reasons to allow prayer in public schools. On a legal basis they state that banning prayer in public schools is a violation of our First Amendment right of Free Exercise. From a moral standpoint they cite the so-called degeneration of the public school system and the so-called declining quality of public education
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now