Public Perceptions of Police Misconduct
Police Misconduct
Public Perceptions of Police Misconduct Divided Along Racial Lines
Public Perceptions of Police Misconduct Divided Along Racial Lines
For anyone paying attention to the news of late, the conduct of the police has been under increasing scrutiny. The news media and the internet world are currently following a number of major stories concerning alleged police misconduct. These stories are as diverse as the New York Police Department (NYPD) warrantless spying on Muslims (Sacirbey, 2012) to the pepper spraying of Occupy protesters on a University of California campus (Newcomb, 2012). This essay will discuss evidence that suggests communities view police misconduct differently along racial and generational lines.
Historical Perspectives
The infamous 'Third Degree' was probably first coined in the 1870s by police officers and was intended to describe the brutal interrogation methods employed to gain information, confessions, and guilty pleas from suspects (Leo and Koenig, 2010, p. 4-14). By the 1920s, newspapers had begun reporting allegations of police brutality on a regular basis, but everyone, from prosecuting attorneys to trial judges, were complicit to varying degrees. The use of brutal interrogation methods became so popularized that the methods were incorporated into plays, motion pictures, and crime novels. Investigations were started by bar associations, civil liberties organizations, and grand juries to no avail. The perception of widespread police misconduct had become so common, that even the mention of coercion in front of a jury could sway the verdict in favor of the defendant.
Finally, with publication of the Wickersham Commission report in 1931, which was titled Lawlessness in Law Enforcement, the resulting public outrage was sufficient that third degree methods faded from use (Leo and Koenig, 2010, p. 12-14). This report revealed widespread, systematic use of third degree methods on a national level. Rather than using the methods to obtain incriminating information from hardened criminals, the methods were used to clear the books of criminal cases through false confessions and guilty pleas, take revenge, and discourage claims of abuse and coercion.
Contemporary Perspectives
Although the widespread use of third degree methods faded after the publication of the Wickersham Commission report in 1931, the police still find it hard to police themselves. This past January, the Chicago City Council voted unanimously to ban torture, the first municipality to do so in the United States (Coffey, 2012). Close to 3,500 signatures had been collected by the National Religious Campaign Against Torture, Illinois Coalition Against Torture, and other religious organizations to bring this issue up before the city council.
Although the use of torture at Guantanamo Bay and other U.S. run prisons was used in part to justify presenting this issue before the city council, the fact that this took place in Chicago is particularly important. Between 1972 and 1991, the Chicago police officer Jon Burge and fellow officers tortured suspects to gain information, confessions, and guilty pleas (University of Chicago Human Rights Program, 2007). An estimated 135 African-American men, women, and children, one as young as 13 years old, were subjected to electric shocks, suffocation, beatings, burns, and mock executions.
The city government of Chicago reportedly has taken drastic, public steps to interfere with both local and federal investigations into the police torture allegations and the Illinois legislature recently pulled funding from the Illinois Torture Inquiry and Relief Commission (Mills, 2012). The executive director of this commission, David Thomas, stated that support for their efforts appear to be limited to the wrongfully convicted and their families. The torture commission was busy preparing cases for judicial review, so that the wrongfully convicted could be released from prison. In addition, there does not seem to be sufficient public outrage to force prosecuting attorneys to convict the many police officers accused of torturing suspects. The police commander accused of being the torture ringleader is the only one who is currently serving time, but only for a federal charge of perjury (Brown, Ruzich, and Cox, 2010).
Where is the Public Outcry?
Given the apparent public tolerance and indifference...
Police Excessive Use of Force and the Supreme Court Supreme Court Case on Police Misconduct Graham V. Connor 1989 Landmark case set the precedent for U.S. Supreme Court in matters relating to unethical Police decisions or immoral practices by the police (Baker & Thomas R., 2012). This paper presents discussions on how the U.S. Supreme Court analysis injustices by the police in the process of investigating or making an arrest a crime. Case:
Police Ethics Ethics, therefore, is not something that a policeman learns in the classroom -- yet, training classes are regularly scheduled -- and this picture of student not understanding why he is in the classroom is indicative of the problem of police ethics as a whole (Crank, Caldero, 2011). There is no established, realistic connection between policing and classroom ethics. The world of the streets is a different from the world
From all neighborhoods the answers were the same, that when police, residents and merchants worked together, crime was reduced. It was also recognized that there was room for improvement in Seattle's community policing efforts. First, it was stated that the citizens of Seattle must become more involved in crime-fighting activities, for it is insufficient for only a handful of residents in neighborhoods across the city to identify projects for
Police Reform in Post-Authoritarian Brazil A majority of new democracies entail an unbelievable illogicality of an immensely feeble citizenship coalesced with a stern description of the constitutional guarantees. In order to explicate this disparity it would be prudent to contemplate the significance of political institutions regarding representation of citizen, which were prevalent subsequent to the military establishments attributed as troublesome and a majority of the new restrictions. A few defined in
But, many citizens respond more favorably to "civilian-style uniforms" and in line with that, Bailey asserts that civilian attitudes towards police (ATP) are the "most positive" when in the presence of "non-authoritarian police officers" (682). Whether a police chief in a medium size city could undertake a transformation from a military-style police uniform -- the style used almost universally in the U.S. And elsewhere -- to a more civilian-formatted
Course Number Police Corruption A Problem with the law Name [Date] Summary This paper will focus specifically on police corruption and the ways in which to lessen and decrease instances of police corruption. The first section includes an introduction explaining the effects of police corruption from rapes to murder and how it impacts society. It also expresses the need to act, as the United States becomes more like the exceedingly corrupt African countries of Nigeria and
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now