However, also by agreeing that another party has the right and responsibility to enforce public order, citizens give up some of their individual rights.
By living in the United States, one has made a quasi-contractual agreement to abide by the laws that govern the country. As such, individuals have surrendered at least some of their individual rights in the name of public order. As an example:
ten people who live on an island may all possess liberty to do as they please. These people, however, constantly fight with one another over the limited food on the island. The ten people can use their liberty to enter a contract, which grants one of the individuals the power to make and enforce the rules they will all live by. These individuals have essentially contracted away a portion of their liberty for the sake of survival, creating a situation in which consent exists in the absence of liberty (Hale, 1999).
The Criminal Justice and its Concern with Public Order:
It is this public order that the criminal justice system needs to concern itself with. The citizens of America have given their consent to relinquish some of their individual liberties, to ensure that public order is maintained by the criminal justice system. Therefore it is their duty.
As mentioned earlier, certainly the criminal justice system should be concerned that they are not infringing upon a citizen's negative rights, however they were not established to enforce the positive rights that individuals have. They were put in place to ensure public order was maintained.
Individual rights has many other champions, such as the ACLU, who fight in the courtrooms, on collegiate campuses, and in the legislature, to try to tip the delicately balanced scales that weight individual rights and public order. These organizations often skew individual rights to that dysfunctional extreme discussed previously, and it is only through maintaining some semblance of public order that the scales can be righted and chaos averted. And it is this "public order (which is) guaranteed by state authority" (Gregg, 2004) such as the criminal justice system.
For this reason, public order is needed to "re-establish equilibrium between liberty and governmental authority" (Hale, 1999).
Individual rights unchecked can throw this delicate balancing act off kilter. For this reason, the criminal justice system should concern itself with the protection of public order, in order to maintain this balance. It is "public order and the preservation of the human race (that) are the underlying prinicples of justification for any society" (Hale, 1999). and, in the end, it is the criminal justice system's duty to protect "the right of the public to public order" (Weeks, 1995).
References
Gregg, S. (Fall 2003 - Spring 2004). Markets, morality, and civil society. Intercollegiate Review. Retrieved February 21, 2005, from Thomson-Gale database.
Hale, J.L. (1999). Takings, liability, and externalities:
The appropriate balance in classical liberalism. Retrieved February 21, 2005, at http://www.belmont.edu/lockesmith/student.html.
Individual rights. (18 Aug. 2004). Retrieved February 21, 2005, at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Individual_rights.
Weeks, J. (Sept. 1995). Making the peace: Public order and public security in modern Britain. History Today. Retrieved February 21, 2005, from Thomson-Gale database.
Williamson Jr., C. (11 Jan. 1985). Disabling America: The "rights industry" in our time. National Review. Retrieved February 21, 2005, from Thomson-Gale database.
Public Order vs. Individual Rights
Individual Rights VS. Public Order Individual right - the right to privacy VS. public order - the need to use surveillance Cameras to deter crime. The Surveillance cameras are regularly connected to machines for taping the proceedings, but nobody looks at these tapes unless something untoward happens. These cameras are on the march and have spread to gas stations, ATMs, mini-marts, sporting events as also on the streets. After the attack on
No electoral college would be used to prevent individuals from making a direct selection of representation. Slide 5: Infrastructure Public office must be dedicated first and foremost to the maintenance of infrastructure. In an island nation which is both advantaged and disadvantaged by its geographical isolation, such issues as meteorological patterns and contention with population needs are key to the quality of life and preservation of individual rights which are of
Individual rights advocates have always held that the criminal justice system must endeavor to protect the personal freedoms of individuals. On the contrary, public order advocates do believe that under certain circumstances involving criminal threat to the public safety, societal interests should take precedence over individual rights. Criminal justice is synonymous with law enforcement. The criminal justice system insulates both the accuser and the accused from any form of impartiality by
The enforcement of the law will also be dependent upon public jury trial and civil court case proceedings, which will be intended to devise the conditions by which a dispute between citizens or between state and citizen has come to pass and the conditions by which justice can be restored to any given scenario. It is the right of the people to see that the system of laws in place
criminal justice are that of public order and that of individual rights. While each side has its merits and in some sense complements the other, there are those who favor either perspective. Public order advocates argue that the safety of citizens and the cohesion of civil society is paramount. Individual rights advocates are more focused on the autonomy of each person, even where it threatens the cohesion of society.
Individual Rights for a Nation Introductory Supporting Analysis The legal and political philosophical principles that ostensibly will advance the Nation of Tagg and its political establishment are the focus of the first section of this paper. The Nation of Tagg utilizes a democratic republic form of managing the body politic via the use of popular determinism. The question as to whether Natural Law or Legal Positivism as a philosophical approach to
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now