Verified Document

Psychology - Foundations For Graduate Discussion Chapter

Unfortunately, the above-cited paragraph on computer science does not achieve these standards. First and foremost, although directed to a general audience, it blatantly assumes that the reader agrees with the author when it states that computers have changed the world in a self-evident fashion. Even if the reader is an enthusiastic consumer of technology, the question arises of what evidence there is of a real change in terms of society, versus superficial and cosmetic shifts. Even the selection of 'fifty years' taken to manifest this change seems arbitrary rather than justified by any evidence. "What, if any, scientific research supports such claims? It appears that there are no scientific studies published in the peer-reviewed scientific literature that establish the validity of these statements. It is not just conclusions, such as those above, but also evaluative instruments that may lack a basis in research providing scientific evidence of their validity or reliability" (Pope 1998).

When analyzing a passage for its logical consistency, it is important to ask what the "main inferences/conclusions" are (Paul & Elder 2003: 36). As well as assuming the importance of the computer as a form of life-transforming technology, the existence of a 'digital divide' is also assumed. This is critical given that the 'digital divide' is one of the main components of the author's argument. He states that the 'divide' has been closing between rich and poor because more poor people are now able to afford computers, as manifested by the fact that 80% of all high school students are 'plugged in.' But what is meant by 'plugged in?' Does this mean that all of these high school students have access to computers on their school campuses? Having access to a word processing computer on campus is very different from being able to use the most advanced technology on one's home computer, or having the familiarity with a smartphone to use it for research on a consistent, daily basis. Merely being plugged in at school does not mean a student...

Furthermore, 'plugged in' may not refer to having a computer at all, and while mobile devices can be a useful enhancement of the application of computers in research, a student still needs a laptop or desktop to function effectively in a classroom environment, to write papers and to access long-form articles via academic databases. Not all 'plugged in' technology, in other words, is created equal.
Another assumption which must be questioned is what is meant by 'poor.' The term 'poor' is quite amorphous. Does it mean someone who is too poor to buy cutting edge technology, or someone who struggles to afford even the basic necessities? The different 'levels' of poverty will surely affect the extent to which there is a digital divide. Also, not all poor persons are young people, yet the author of the paragraph merely cites evidence of students being connected in school, rather than in other facets of American life. and, of course, relying upon schools to bridge the digital divide does nothing to address the problems of older people who are not 'plugged in.'

A final problem with the essay is the source of the article it cites. Businessweek is not a scholarly source. Although it is not completely lacking in credulity (it is a professional work of popular journalism), it is not a scholarly book, peer-reviewed journal, government website, or government report. More than a single bit of evidence is needed to make the sweeping claims of the author.

References

Douglas, N.L. (2000). Enemies of critical thinking: Lessons from social psychology research.

Reading Psychology, 21(2), 129-144

Paul, R., & Elder, L. (2003). Critical thinking: Teaching students how to study and learn (Part

III). Journal of Developmental Education, 26(3), 36-37.

Pope, K.S. (1998). Pseudoscience, cross-examination, and scientific evidence in the recovered memory controversy. Psychology, Public Policy, & Law, 4(4), 1160-1181.

Sources used in this document:
References

Douglas, N.L. (2000). Enemies of critical thinking: Lessons from social psychology research.

Reading Psychology, 21(2), 129-144

Paul, R., & Elder, L. (2003). Critical thinking: Teaching students how to study and learn (Part

III). Journal of Developmental Education, 26(3), 36-37.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Graduate School Statement of Purpose
Words: 921 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

graduate program in Social Studies is very important for me because it will give the best chance of unifying my interest in helping people through the therapeutic approach. I am very certain that when I finish my graduate program and specialize in the field of my choice, I will offer an immense contribution to the field of social studies and to the understanding of the socio- therapeutic approach in

Psychology Statement of Purpose With Brief Personal Statement
Words: 618 Length: 2 Document Type: Admission Essay

Psychology Statement of Purpose with a Brief Personal Statement My interest in psychology has over time been stimulated by a number of experiences. Top amongst these is my reading of a book I stumbled upon several years ago. The book, The Metamorphosis by Franz Kafka, essentially concerns itself with a character by the name Gregor Samsa who one day finds himself turned into a giant vermin. As a result, Samsa ends

Psychology Statement of Purpose and Personal Statement
Words: 612 Length: 2 Document Type: Admission Essay

Psychology Statement of Purpose and Personal Statement When I was 12 years old, a cousin (let us call her Jenny) who was living with us at the time as her parents sorted out their marital problems started exhibiting strange behavior. At the time, she was only 14. At first, her strange behavior was barely noticeable but with time, it became clear that something was amiss. We became alarmed when she started

Psychology Master's Degree: Methodology Degree
Words: 2396 Length: 9 Document Type: Term Paper

The subject promises to approach issues of theology, sociology, ethicality and behavior with necessary interdependency. Psychology: Professional Ethics and Legal Issues (523), though an elective, seems to be an absolutely indispensable channeling of study time. The examination of issues of ethical and legal centrality to the research or practice of psychology should arm future professionals with the underlying information and philosophical orientation needed to approach this complex field with sensitivity, objectivity and integrity. Teaching Introduction to Psychology (GIDS

Psychology History a Brief History of Psychology
Words: 935 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Psychology History A Brief History of Psychology The study of psychology is now deeply entrenched in our society's understand as to how a human, and specifically the human mind, functions. Understanding one's psychological needs is necessary in daily life in order to understand how to cope with various stresses and emotions. However, many decades ago, such ideas were truly visionary, as psychology was not considered a true scientific subject, and many who

Psychology -- Laughter & Humor
Words: 1026 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

" Hence, Ayan adds, with laughter, the lives of people with elevated levels of cortisol might be saved. Arguably that's a bit of a stretch, but for the purposes of his article Ayan is justified in using it. Keeping anxiety "at bay" through humor is the sum and substance of a 1990 study conducted by psychologists; 53 college students were told they were going to get an electric shock in 12

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now