Verified Document

Privatizing Social Security Social Security Can Be Essay

Privatizing Social Security Social security can be generally defined as a program that provides social protection or protection against conditions that are socially recognized to workers and their dependents. Such social conditions include old age, poverty, disability, and unemployment. This program is funded by the social security tax.

In most industrialized economies and a good portion of developing countries the postwar period has been spent to dramatically expand the pay-as-you-go social security programs that already existed. Although this expansion has led to a reduction of poverty rates among the elderly, it has as well led to the tremendous redistribution of sums from young and future generations, as a group, to simultaneous older generations, as a group (Altig and Gokhale, p.03). The mechanism that causes the redistribution to the initial elderly is clear. A bonus is received by the generations that are retired or close to retirement when an increment on the pay-as-you-go social security benefits is effected. However, the mechanism that causes redistribution away from younger and future generations is not very clear. The understanding of the public is that the expansion of pay-as-you-go social security implies higher payroll taxes for the current and future young workers, but it also recognizes the higher benefits that will be received by these generations when they retire.

However, many countries are facing an impending demographic/social crunch and this has led politicians into considering privatization of social security with a belief that privatization of social security programs may be a painless way out of this demographic dilemma. This is not an obvious case. Ignoring the potential efficiency gains from social security privatization would mean fiscal policy is a zero-sum game (Cooley and Soares, p.89). Consequently, privatizing social security programs as a means of mitigating the prospective increase in the fiscal burden on future generations, it is likely that the...

These possible and varying outcomes make it necessary for those involved in decision making to take a middle ground and analyze both extremes before making a decision.
All social security programs have the intention of providing a safety net protecting workers and the dependents when faced with certain social conditions as those mentioned earlier. Privatizing social security is meant to allow workers to control their personal retirement money through personal investment accounts. Those in support of privatization argue that this will allow retirees to freely invest their retirement money in the stock market as they wish, theoretically this would give them higher returns as compared to government-invested funds. On the other hand, those opposing the privatization of social security programs argue that investing retirement money is complicated and risky since bad decisions can lead to loss of the retirement safety net. In order to come up with a conclusion concerning this topic it is necessary to look at the pros and the cons of privatized social security programs.

When the existing system is used in averting the pending collapse of social security will necessitate deep cuts in benefits, increased borrowing, or significant hikes in tax. Switching to private investment accounts that are funded with existing payroll tax is a better solution, this will avoid benefit cuts or hikes in tax. It is also evident that privatization of social security programs will have retirees pocket more money (Feldstein and Samwick, 1996). Another feature that will be introduced by private retirement accounts is the contractual rights for workers to their retirement benefits, this is a feature that is currently missing. Contrary to the belief that putting social security into private accounts will expose money to risk, it actually does not. The regulation of the current accounts are subject to federal regulation and individuals are only…

Sources used in this document:
References

Altig, D., and Gokhale, J., "Social Security Privatization: A Simple Proposal," Working Paper

97-03, 1997. Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland.

Cooley, T.F., and Soares, J.. "Will Social Security Survive the Baby-Boom?" Carnegie

Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy 45, 89;12. 1996.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Social Security System Is Designed
Words: 1232 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Paper

("Canada Social Security and Welfare," 2012) (Aaron, 1999) (Livingston, 2007) This is different from Social Security as these areas are not covered. Any kind of assistance for health care would fall under other programs (i.e. Medicare and Medicaid). However, these are only designed to protect those individuals who meet the age and income requirements. To provide assistance for low income families, this would fall under the WIC program (which is

Social Security Is Financed With the Idea
Words: 642 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Social security is financed with the idea that those people currently working, along with their employers, can donate enough money to pay the benefits to those currently getting them: not only retired people but some people with disabilities, and some widows with young children. When Social Security first began, this system worked well. The problem facing Social security is that the numbers of retirees are going to increase at the

Social Security There Are Huge Differences Between
Words: 837 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Social Security There are huge differences between Social Security and privatization. As this paper will discuss, Social Security is more than just an investment strategy. It is a guarantee to all citizens that they won't be subjected to the dire economic consequences resulting from inadequate income to save for retirement, failed investment strategies, and untimely death or a disability. These reasons require that Social Security remain in tact to protect Americans

Social Security Reform
Words: 1834 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

Social Security Crisis While the United States does not provide a pension and health care for all its citizens as some countries do, we do have a program designed to make sure that all our older retired workers have some money on which to live. Called Social Security, it also provides money to people who are so disabled before retirement age that they cannot work, and (depending on the age of

Social Security IT's Been More
Words: 2503 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Social Security can be an effective tool in public personnel administration and can benefit common American a great deal if used effectively. Therefore it is imperative to look into the future prospects of the programs and remove loopholes and bottlenecks in its future implementation. Future Under the Social Security plan government is collecting more money today then it is paying out as benefits to citizens. The surplus money remains safe in

Social Security: On Thin Financial Ice
Words: 1232 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Social Security The Original Concept of Social Security The concept of social security as originally conceived by President Franklin Delano Roosevelt was that Americans should enjoy security at home, and they should expect to have a secure livelihood, and they should also have social insurance as "…a minimum of the promise that we can offer to the American people" (Houser, et al., 2014). The President also said, on June 8, 1934, that

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now