Verified Document

Private Vs. Public Schools In Research Paper

These profiles of students' family background who attend public and private schools demonstrate that school choice is a combination of parents' values towards education and their socio-economic backgrounds and capabilities. Teacher performance (Quality of teaching)

Quality of education is also linked to teacher performance, specifically, the competence and quality of teaching that teachers give their students. Teachers with impressive or highly commendable qualifications tend to teach at private schools instead of public schools. Thus, it can be surmised that because of teacher "quality" based on credentials are higher in private schools than public schools, students in private schools are getting quality education than public schools.

However, this assumption is disproved in Xu's (2006) study, which determined if teachers' credentials translate to quality of teaching. The researchers found that teachers' credentials "shows no relationship" with students' (improvement in) academic performance (355). Thus, teaching quality assumed to be driven by teacher credentials do not necessarily translate to improved academic performance of students. This also disproves the notion that since private schools are able to hire teachers with more impressive credentials than public schools, the latter would have a lower education quality than the former.

This finding provides an important insight into the role that teachers play in providing quality education in whatever type of educational institution -- whether public or private. It is the teaching quality variable that levels the standard between public and private schools -- that, despite differences in their curriculum, system, student profile and culture, teachers and teaching quality will not be school type dependent as other factors relevant to identifying the distinction between the two (i.e., public and private schools).

Students' academic performance

In a study conducted by the U.S. Department of Education, it was determined that at the middle school level, school type has no bearing on students' academic performance. This report took into consideration school characteristics such as "teacher experience, school location and school size" to be not significantly related to students'...

However, not taking into account these characteristics, or removing these school characteristics as variables in the study, it was determined that private school students performed better in reading and mathematics subjects/courses than public school students (NAEP, 2006 & Mendez, 2005). (This finding is still relevant only to middle school level students). Although to a certain extent this provides empirical evidence about the quality of education provided in private schools, the report emphasized the importance of taking these findings in the context of the study, specifically, the kind of data and method used for the study. The report cautions its readers and end-users to consider that data used for the analyses as obtained using "observational" methods rather than experimental, "so the estimated effects should not be interpreted in terms of causal relationships" (v).
Conclusion

This analysis on the similarities and differences between private and public schools demonstrate that among the variables studies, students' profiles and teaching quality are the only variables found to be significantly contributing to their differences and similarities, respectively. Students' academic performance is still a variable that is not strongly established to be significantly influenced by school type.

References

"Comparing private schools and public schools using hierarchical linear modeling." (2006). Published by the National Assessment of Educational Progress, U.S. Department of Education.

Goldring, E. And K. Phillips. (2008). "Parent preferences and parent choices: the public-private decision about school choice." Journal of Educational Policy, Vol. 23, No. 3.

Mendez, T. (2005). "Public schools: do they outperform private ones?" Christian Science Monitor, Vol. 97, Issue 11.

Toppo, G. (2010). "Recession fuels shift from private to public schools." Available at: http://www.usatoday.com/news/education/2010-01-06-1Apublicprivate06_CV_N.htm

Xu, Z. And C. Gulosino. (2006). "How does teacher quality matter? The effect of teacher-parent partnership on early childhood performance in public and private schools." Education Economics, Vol. 14, No. 3.

Sources used in this document:
references and parent choices: the public-private decision about school choice." Journal of Educational Policy, Vol. 23, No. 3.

Mendez, T. (2005). "Public schools: do they outperform private ones?" Christian Science Monitor, Vol. 97, Issue 11.

Toppo, G. (2010). "Recession fuels shift from private to public schools." Available at: http://www.usatoday.com/news/education/2010-01-06-1Apublicprivate06_CV_N.htm

Xu, Z. And C. Gulosino. (2006). "How does teacher quality matter? The effect of teacher-parent partnership on early childhood performance in public and private schools." Education Economics, Vol. 14, No. 3.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Private Public School Similarities and Differences Risk
Words: 1630 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Paper

Private Public School Similarities and Differences Risk and Benefits in Public and Private Schools Special Need Students Teachers Credentials in Private and Public Schools This research paper focuses on the similarities and differences of private and public school education. It deciphers several truths and realities associated with these two systems. Risks and benefits along with teacher's credentials in private and public schools are discussed in detail. Another factor brought to light is the positive

Private Vs Public Schools Parent Perspectives
Words: 2082 Length: 7 Document Type: Research Paper

METHODOLOGYParent Perspectives on Why They Send their Children to Private Schools, as Opposed to Public SchoolsMethodologyIntroductionThe relevance of quality education cannot be overstated. Towards this end, various stakeholders in the educational sector ought to be aware of the various factors that impact the delivery of quality education. This way, interventions and better policies can be formulated and implemented in an attempt to create effective and conducive learning environments. A significant

Private Vs. Public Schools Many Parents Find
Words: 1373 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Private vs. Public Schools Many parents find themselves caught in a dilemma when trying to decide on which choice of education to take for their children. They ask themselves whether to take their children to private schools or public schools. For a parent to choose the ideal school for their children they always have to take into consideration all the available options. They consider things like the cost of the school,

School Uniforms in Public School Has Been
Words: 1355 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

School uniforms in public school has been a subject of national debate. Private and Parochial schools have a long history of school uniforms. Its implementation in public schools has been met with sharp criticism, it came to gain momentum in the late 1980's and it has been increasing steadily throughout the years. In some past few years the subject has gotten various boosts. The biggest boost was when in January

Public Schools Vs. Private Schools
Words: 4609 Length: 17 Document Type: Term Paper

Inconsistent evaluation methods between public, private, and charter schools, as well as the ever-present problems with whether or not achievement is actually measured accurately by standardized test scores, are two issues that must be taken into account when evaluating the findings of this report. Despite all of this negative press for charter schools, some studies do appear to show that these schools may be a positive learning atmosphere for students

Public Schools Vs. Private Schools - Culturally
Words: 3395 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Public Schools vs. Private Schools - Culturally appropriate education Review of the literature Education and culture Teaching dispositions Outmoded educational model Would vo-tech be a better public school goal? Developing the person instead of the mind Opposition to change in public schools Alternatives to public and private school School reform has been a constant theme of public debate for much of the past two decades. Standardized testing, which was supposed to solve the problem of poorly prepared students graduating

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now