Verified Document

Prenatal Testing Term Paper

Prenatal Testing For many people, prenatal testing has opened many opportunities to treat potential illnesses and to save lives. Administering tests that involve visualization, ultrasounds and amniocentesis allow physicians and parents to identify illnesses and disabilities in children even before birth. More advanced surgical techniques have been used to treat babies even before they are born.

Many others, however, have expressed concern over the ethical implications of prenatal testing. While the treatment of diseases is a noble cause, many ethicists worry that prenatal testing will lead to a de facto form of eugenics. In these cases, prenatal testing could be used to screen out mild disabilities and other non-life threatening conditions.

This paper looks at the social implications of prenatal testing, with a particular emphasis on the definitions of disability and preferred genetic makeup. The first part is a look at the reasons why parents avail of prenatal testing techniques. These range from non-invasive processes such as ultrasounds to fetal tissue analysis. The second part of the paper then looks at the many advantages and arguments in favor of continued prenatal testing. In the third part, the paper examines the various ethical arguments against tampering with natural genetic development, including concerns that prenatal testing would cause a great increase in abortion rates.

In the conclusion, this paper argues that thee fears of ethicists regarding abortion and eugenics are remain merely conjectures and worst-case scenarios. However, the advantages in terms of in-utero surgery and early treatment are already available. In light of these two factors, prenatal testing should continue...

At the forefront was amniocentesis, a technique wherein cells taken from amniotic fluid are grown in the laboratory. By analyzing these cells, scientists and physicians can identify the presence of genetic markers for diseases like Down's Syndrome ("Genetic Testing and Screening").
Researchers find that people who opt for prenatal diagnosis do so for common reasons. Many would-be parents request prenatal testing due to the advanced age of the mother. More than 90% of prenatal tests are performed for mothers who are aged 35 and over. Parents with a history of genetic abnormalities like Tay-Sachs Disease also avail of prenatal testing techniques. Related to this, many people who belong to ethnic groups known to be at risk for specific illnesses also turn to prenatal testing ("Genetic Testing and Screening").

The rest of prenatal diagnoses are conducted for patients who have had difficulty conceiving, difficult pregnancies, have already had miscarriages or who have given birth to babies with birth defects. Many couples who have had a child with Down's Syndrome are also prime candidates of prenatal testing, regardless of maternal age ("Genetic Testing and Screening").

Despite the different reasons for seeking prenatal tests, parents who opt for such testing are concerned with the same thing. Their main concern is to predict the possibility of birth defects and disease. Even for diseases that are still classified as untreatable, many parents still find the knowledge regarding their children's health invaluable.

Advantages of prenatal testing

Research has shown that many patients and healthcare practitioners favor prenatal testing. Many pregnant women understand that while prenatal screenings do not constitute a definitive diagnosis, these techniques can identify those with a high risk of abnormalities (Suter). In this sense, prenatal testing has become a norm for many pregnancies.

With advancements in science, prenatal testing allow for the diagnosis of many inherited diseases and abnormal chromosomes. Related to this,…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Allen, Garland E. "Is a New Eugenics Afoot?" Science. 2001. Proquest Database.

Anderson, Gwen. "Nondirectiveness in Prenatal Genetics: Patients Read Between the Lines." Nursing Ethics. 1999: 126-129.

Genetic Testing and Screening." Bioethics for Students: Issues in Medicine, Animal Rights, and the Environment. 4 vols. Macmillan, 1999. Reproduced in Opposing Viewpoints Resource Center. Farmington Hills, Mich.: Gale Group. 2004 http://0-galenet.galegroup.com.catalog.houstonlibrary.org:80/servlet/OVRC

Suter, Sonia Mateu. "The routinization of prenatal testing." American Journal of Law and Medicine. Boston: 2002. Proquest Database.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Abortion After Prenatal Testing Methods of Prenatal
Words: 595 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Abortion After Prenatal Testing Methods of Prenatal Diagnosis There are four methods of prenatal diagnosis that is available to women. The first and most commonly known is ultrasonography, colloquially referred to as "ultrasound." A picture of the fetus is developed through the implementation of sound waves. Ultrasound is used to identify abnormalities that are physically apparent such as deformed limbs, defective chest, and heart. During the fourteenth to sixteenth week of the

Editorial Letter on Prenatal Testing
Words: 828 Length: 2 Document Type: Peer-Reviewed Journal

Editor, In his letter printed June 8, 2014, Alistair Pullen discusses the fact that the advent of prenatal testing has helped transform pregnancy from a time of joy to a time of fear. He discusses his wife's pregnancy with his first daughter, in which prenatal testing revealed the existence of a disorder that was incompatible with life. As a result of the testing, Mr. Pullen and his wife chose to

Prenatal Genetics: Tay Sachs Diagnosis
Words: 1788 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Moreover, some genetic testing is inaccurate, creating the possibility of false positives and false negatives. The second problem with genetic testing is that it can provide information about diseases where there is no treatment or intervention. This is the case for Tay-Sachs. There is no way to prevent the disease, which is fatal in children. However, unlike some other genetic disorders, the baby is born healthy and begins to deteriorate

Prenatal Care for the Homeless Families and
Words: 742 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Prenatal Care for the Homeless Families and children in the context of social change The Homeless Prenatal Program The goal of the Homeless Prenatal Program (HPP) in San Francisco is to break the cycle of childhood poverty by providing a variety of services to homeless families (Homeless Prenatal Program, 2010). The original and still primary service offered is prenatal and parenting support, in addition to housing assistance, training in personal finance and computer

Genetic Testing
Words: 1596 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Genetic Testing: Identifying Associating Issues This paper will examine Shelley Burtt's writing "Dilemmas of Genetic Testing" as well as other sources on the subject of genetic testing. After having examined the resources available an opinion will be formed as to whether genetic testing is positive or negative for the patient and the expected child. Genetic testing is becoming an option more commonly used by women during pregnancies to assess particular information concerning

Genetic Testing Prenatal Diagnosis Serves a Variety
Words: 635 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Genetic Testing Prenatal diagnosis serves a variety of purposes and I believe in its fundamental purpose it is good. In some cases, prenatal genetic testing can lead to timely medical intervention to mitigate or eliminate disease such as with congenital adrenal hyperplasia or a-thalassemia. In some cases, prenatal diagnosis reveals a lethal condition, such as anencephaly, trisomy 13, or trisomy 18. The choice to do genetic testing in the beginning is

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now