Verified Document

Predictions Of A Second Korean War Article Critique

According to international relations scholar Kang (2003) one of the greatest puzzles of the postwar world is why the conflict between communist North Korea and South Korea has not re-erupted, despite the prediction that this would occur by most scholars. The purpose of Kang’s essay is to answer how so many respected scholars were so mistaken. In one succinct and concise sentence, Kang states: “The case of North Korea provides a window with which to examine these theories of conflict initiation, and reveals how the assumptions underlying these theories can become mis-specified” (Kang, 2003, p.302). Kang argues that both the theory of how conflicts occur and the actual conditions on the ground in Korea were misunderstood. Kang also identifies novel facets of the North Korean perspective which he says have gone unnoticed by the West. “The flurry of North Korean diplomatic and economic initiatives in the past few years show that far from having given up hope and seeing inevitable economic collapse, the North Korean leadership is actively pursuing a strategy they hope will ease their domestic problems” (Kang, 2003, p.302). The conflict perspective suggests that preventative wars are preferable from a rationalist perspective, but the North Korean perspective of the world situation and its own...

However, although Kang uses examples from real world events, he is less interested in analyzing why no conflict between the two regimes have occurred and more interested in understanding the failure of realism-based theories such as conflict theory to explain this.
Q2. Theoretical Debate and Historical Context

Although Kang’s research is founded in the Korean example of the postwar era, ultimately his article’s argument is a theoretical one. Realist and conflict-based theories of international relations see all interactions as the product of nations that function as “black boxes,” that are capable of making rational, unified decisions in a predictable and coherent fashion. Kang suggests that cultural analysis and an understanding of internal political conflicts is also necessary to fully paint a truthful picture of how and why international events occur. Kang’s essay draws upon a mix of scholarship, including theoretical works of realist political analysis (which he critiques); specific analysis of the Korean situation, and the specific research literature he is critiquing which…

Sources used in this document:

References

Kang, D.C. (2003). International relations theory and the second Korean War.

International Studies Quarterly, 47, 301–324





 


Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

First Language L1 in the Second Language
Words: 6580 Length: 24 Document Type: Essay

first language (L1) in the second language EFL classroom (L2). The study provides a brief historical background of the use of native or target language for a classroom teaching. The literatures are also reviewed to enhance to a greater understanding on the Contrastive Analysis Hypothesis. Theoretical arguments are provided to support or against the use of monolingual or bilingual approach in a teaching environment. While some scholars believe that

History of Korea
Words: 2125 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

North/South Korea + Korean-Americans The Two Koreas: South Korea is known today as one of the rising economic giants of the industrialized world. The nation is a respected U.S. ally, and a center for fashion and technology, not to mention other industries. While South Korea's "star" is on a constant rise, its neighbor, North Korea, continues to live in a tightly closed society, with restrictive and degrading practices, whereby its citizens are

Policy Choices of the Future
Words: 2858 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

To increase effective demand, Keynesians believe the government must balance the economy with deficit and increase expenditure. However, the constant alternation between booms and recession is causing the booms to get shorter while the recessions become longer. This phenomenon is the result of empirical evidence that indicates that in the end, the interest rates decrease. However, this situation creates a problem of capitalism as the rich increase their wealth while

Joshua's Goldstein Book 5th Edition
Words: 7033 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

history of events in the twentieth century, one might surmise that the twenty-first may not be all that different. Why? Because human nature and the pursuit of self-interest has not changed from one century to the next. To explain what drives international relations, Joshua Goldstein provides a brief history of the world, in addition to information about the geographical features and the consequences of different nation's economies. (Goldstein, 2003)

Influence of 2007 Economic Crisis on American Car Market
Words: 24230 Length: 88 Document Type: Thesis

2007 Economic Crisis on American Car market Effect of the 2008 global economic crisis on automotive industries Crisis in the United States Crisis in Canada Crisis in Russia Crisis in European markets Crisis in Asian markets Effects by other related crisis events In this paper, we will review the effects of 2008 global automotive crisis. Our main focus will be on the American car manufacturers and the negative impact they suffered due to the crisis. We will

Belonging, Web 2.0 and International
Words: 20197 Length: 70 Document Type: Research Proposal

RESEARCH QUESTIONS Research questions asked in this present study include the following stated questions: (1) What role does Internet technology (Web 2.0) play in the international student's development and maintenance of a sense of belonging in a new home country? (2) What role does length of residence play in the international student's development and maintenance of a 'sense of belonging' in a new home country? (3) Are there any differences in the adaptation of

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now