Verified Document

Power Relations And Battle Of The Sexes In Naomi By Junichiro Tanizki Essay

Power Relations in Junichiro Tanizaki's Naomi The most powerful and lasting contributions to the literature of a given era are invariably penned by bold thinkers struggling to comprehend the ever changing world in which they live. Spanning the late 19th and early 20th centuries, the Japanese Meiji Restoration period, which was propelled by the fusion of industrialized economy and Western culture, and personified by the authorial brilliance of authors such as Jun'ichir? Tanizaki, shaped and inspired a momentous political and social transformation within one of the world's most ancient civilzations. The toppling of previously infallible Shoguns and the sudden distribution of democratic ideals across boundaries of gender and class forced many traditional Japanese to recalibrate their worldview instantly, and the result is a wealth of material, including novels, plays and works of critical nonfiction, all of which focuses intently on the crumbling conventions of age-old gender roles. With the external foundations of the preexisting social order irrevocably shattered by the Meiji movement, young writers like Tanizaki focused their intellectual insight on the shifting structure of Japanese society itself, analyzing the evolution of concepts like fidelity, femininity, and power in a patriarchal society that has suddenly seen that power dynamic shift. Tanizaki's most renowned work of social analysis through fiction was Naomi, a novel written in simple yet searing prose that manages to cast a scathing lens on the conventional roles assigned to women in a male-dominated system, and the ramifications for both genders when these roles are reversed. By applying a feminist reading to Naomi, the modern reader can begin to surmise the ultimate import of Tanizaki's work, which stands today as a lasting testament to ability of literature to capture the essence of a historical era.

Tanizaki immediately establishes the thematic direction of Naomi in the novel's opening lines, as the narrator J-ji explains "I'm going to try to relate the facts...

it's probably a relationship without precedent" (1), before opining eloquently on Japan's increasingly cosmopolitan nature and the associated consequences. With this single, simply written but immensely powerful passage, Tanizaki positions the relationship between J-ji and his eventual wife, who he later compares in reverential tones to "the motion-picture actress Mary Pickford" by noting breathlessly that "there was definitely something Western about her appearance" (1), as an allegory for the collision of cultures occurring throughout Japan as Western ideals gained greater acceptance. The first chapter of Naomi ostensibly portrays the period of lovelorn longing every suitor experiences during the courting process, as J-ji clumsily proffers his affection through dinner dates and trips to the theatre, but Tanizaki subtly imbues the entire proceedings with an air of masculine superiority that the novel's narrator seems to simply accept as a matter of course. This rhetorical strategy employed by Tanizaki is especially evident when J-ji ponders his desire to make Naomi his wife. When he absently envisions this eventual state of matrimony, J-ji thinks about how he might "decorate the rooms, plant flowers, hang out a birdcage on the sunny veranda, and hire a maid to do the cooking and scrubbing," before revealing "and if Naomi agreed to come, she'd take the place of both the maid and the bird," (Tanizaki 3), the implication is that this young woman is meant to serve the traditional gender roles that J-ji and millions of his fellow Japanese men believed was their birthright. In his inimitable style of applying intense satirical insight to social norms, Tanizaki soon shifts this preexisting power dynamic on its proverbial head, with the young and seemingly timid Naomi emerging as a potent symbol of the liberated femininity enveloping Japan during the era.
As Naomi slowly ingratiates herself into J-ji's life through her subtle form of…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Tanizaki, Jun'ichiro. "Naomi," trans. Anthony H. Chambers." (1986).
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Acceptance and Commitment Therapy
Words: 621 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) is a form of psychotherapy that is similar to cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT). The theory that ACT is based on is the Relational Frame Theory, which launched out of cognitive therapy, supplying missing "steps" in Skinner's behaviorism by exploring more deeply the connections between language and thought. Essentially, ACT explores the idea that what and how a person thinks is highly impactful in that individual's daily

Acceptance Speech Opening Statement Humorous
Words: 348 Length: 1 Document Type: Term Paper

2. But I have also had some top-notch guidance bringing me to where I am now: teachers at the culinary institute and role models at my favorite restaurants throughout the world. III. How I will use the award for the benefit of humanity as a whole and myself in particular A. The prestige of the award 1. This is one of the most significant awards in the professional culinary community. 2. I am honored

Acceptance Letter to Physician Assistance School
Words: 640 Length: 2 Document Type: Application Essay

Acceptance Letter to Physician Assistance School I can still remember his face that day: ashen, writhing in pain, tremulous. It was a good face -- one that had reflected love and caring to almost everyone who had known him, one that had contended daily with a debilitating condition that he fought to hide in his zest for life. It was the face of my father, the man who had raised me.

Acceptance of Gay Rights: A
Words: 846 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Less than one-half of the respondents in the 57- to 90-year-old category thought that a homosexual should be allowed to teach in college or university. This is contrasted with less than 30% of either of the other two groups (with less than one-quarter of the youngest group feeling that homosexuals should be banned from teaching college). Table 3 Cells contain: Column percent (N of cases) Age Group 18-35 36-56 57-90 Row Total Should an admitted homosexual be allowed to

Acceptance Speech, Martin Luther King, Jr.
Words: 679 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Dr. Martin Luther King IMAGINING A PRESENT DAY NOBLE PEACE PRIZE SPEECH BY DR. MARTIN LUTHER KING The objective of this study is to imagine that if Dr. Martin Luther King were to win the noble peace prize today what he would say in his acceptance speech. This study will consider his ideals and principles when creating the speech as well as consider his noble peace prize acceptance speech decades ago. The Speech Your

Acceptance Business Legal Case the Author of
Words: 634 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Acceptance Business Legal Case The author of this response is offered a business legal case and is asked to give an opinion on whether one firm has a case against another. The author of this report will offer a response and will back it up using arguments going either way. In short, the answer up front is that ABC Corporation probably does not have a case but Mr. Jones acted quite

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now