Verified Document

Post Tenure Ann Bib Tenure Research Proposal

Allen makes the case that this functions to improve the quality of higher education and the experience had by the student. Like Scheuerman, Allen argues that tenure is under attack for reasons other than the perceived erosion of educational quality, but makes a more direct case against administrators and public officials by arguing that tenure is actually attacked as a matter of posturing for control over the work of instructors. Indeed, Allen notes that in spite of claims that the academic freedom afforded to instructors is problematic, "the evidence shows that most tenured faculty are more productive than ever in this era of tighter resources." (95-96) This functions as an effective argument in favor of maintaining and defending the institution of tenure. Miron. (2001). The Econoimcs of the Tenure System. Library of Economics and Liberty.

Miron's article effectively straddles the middle of the line in an often deeply polarized discussion, indicating that though the tenure system is most assuredly flawed, it remains a necessary and valuable part of protecting quality teachers from intervention and administrative oversight. Miron indicates that the arguments against tenure are indeed misdirected, inappropriately blaming the concept of tenure when it is, more accurately, the execution of tenure which is so problematic. The question at hand, this article contends, relates to how great a degree of security is provided to tenured faculty, suggesting that there is a need to more critically examine the extent of the protections against poor performance or diminishing qualified imposed by tenure. Miron offers moderated approaches to tenure that scale pay with experience and effectiveness rather than with the simple awarding of tenure.

Plater. (2001). A Profession at Risk. Change.

Plater's article defends the importance of tenure while also putting forth arguments in favor of post tenure review. The article takes a relatively distinct path insofar as it discusses post tenure not as an enemy to the concept of tenure -- which is often how this approach is perceived by educators -- and instead as an approach due for refinement. This contributes to the present research the idea that post tenure review can be used not to penalize instructors...

(2003). Post-Tenure Review at Graduate Institutions in the United States. The Journal of Higher Education, 74(3), 241-260.
Aper and Fry provide what functions as a generally neutral overview of the concept of post-tenure review. This cites the arguments for and against it, as well as couching these arguments in pro and anti-tenure positions. The article effectively serves as a basis for much of the information which is discussed in greater detail by the articles considered throughout this review. Its balance is established by focusing its research on the degree to which post-tenure policies are currently being implemented and the perception held at the institutions where this has occurred.

Licata & Morreale. (1999). Post-Tenure Review: National Trends, Questions and Concerns. Innovative Higher Education, 24(1).

The article by Licata & Morreale is also a consideration of post-tenure review with a fully neutral approach to examining the unanswered questions prompted by ongoing debate. This is more of a qualitative discussion than that featured in the survey method by Aper & Fry. As a result, it provides a complimentary perspective to the research already encountered, and again, also remains neutral. Its findings, accordingly, seem to support post tenure review as a more refined process less connected to penalty and more based on performance incentive.

Johnson & Kelley. (1998). Productivity and Competence: Post-Tenure Review in American Universities. Issues in Accounting Education, 13(3).

The article by Johnson & Kelly provides a useful case against the use of post tenure review, suggesting that this has been a knee-jerk response to perceptions and public views that aging and incompetent instructors are a primary cause for diminishing educational standards. The article denotes that there has rarely been empirical proof that a review policy such as this is either necessitated or can be connected to improvements in education. Nonetheless, it denotes that with the adoption of such methods of quality assurance, protections must be maintained and professional development improvements sought for instructors.

Sources used in this document:
The article by Licata & Morreale is also a consideration of post-tenure review with a fully neutral approach to examining the unanswered questions prompted by ongoing debate. This is more of a qualitative discussion than that featured in the survey method by Aper & Fry. As a result, it provides a complimentary perspective to the research already encountered, and again, also remains neutral. Its findings, accordingly, seem to support post tenure review as a more refined process less connected to penalty and more based on performance incentive.

Johnson & Kelley. (1998). Productivity and Competence: Post-Tenure Review in American Universities. Issues in Accounting Education, 13(3).

The article by Johnson & Kelly provides a useful case against the use of post tenure review, suggesting that this has been a knee-jerk response to perceptions and public views that aging and incompetent instructors are a primary cause for diminishing educational standards. The article denotes that there has rarely been empirical proof that a review policy such as this is either necessitated or can be connected to improvements in education. Nonetheless, it denotes that with the adoption of such methods of quality assurance, protections must be maintained and professional development improvements sought for instructors.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Annotated Bibliography for Their Eyes Were Watching
Words: 1390 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Annotated Bibliography for Their Eyes Were Watching God Curren, Erik. "Should Their Eyes Have Been Watching God? Hurston's Use of Religious Experience and Gothic Horror." African American Review, Vol. 29, Iss. 1 (1995), 17-25. An exploration of the novel that rebuts and contrasts with earlier analyses that call Their Eyes an "affirmative quest" story. Curren's thesis is that these analyses in fact discount the entire final third of the book which is

Annotated Bibliography: Research on Football Players
Words: 1067 Length: 4 Document Type: Annotated Bibliography

Sports Psychology and the self-Esteem of high school football players. Sports psychology: Annotated bibliography Cox, R.H., & Yoo, H.S. (1995). Playing position and psychological skill in American football. Journal of Sport Behavior, 18(3), 183 The Journal of Sports Behavior is a peer-reviewed journal focused upon research in sports psychology and its articles are not directed towards a popular audience. According to Cox & Yoo (1995) in this early study of the sports psychology

Annotated Bibliography for Performing Needs Assessment on Adult Learners...
Words: 2517 Length: 8 Document Type: Annotated Bibliography

Nursing -- Annotated Bibliography Annotated Bibliography Case, Bette. (1996). Breathing AIR into adult learning. Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing, 27(4), 148-158. Bette Case reviews an organizational scheme for adult learning called 'AIR', short for active involvement, individual differences, and relevance and motivation. Of the three learning strategies, active involvement is given the most attention. Active involvement seems to capture any learning technique that empowers the students and moves beyond the traditional didactic

Annotated Bibliography on Prison Overcrowding
Words: 1011 Length: 3 Document Type: Annotated Bibliography

Prison overcrowding is one of the major issues that have faced the criminal justice system for more than two decades now. It has grown to be an elusive phenomenon that has raised significant concerns of the local and international actors. The increasing population of the prisoners poses various challenges, including policy, financial, and health implications, thereby, the need for the adoption of responsive strategies to curb its effects. Among the

Annotated Bibliography Telehealth Models
Words: 1761 Length: 6 Document Type: Annotated Bibliography

Annotated BibliographyOriginal Research Question: Did implementing remote and virtual front desk services, including live representatives via webcam, impact staffing efficiency for underserved patients, especially patients with English as their second language in FQHCs post-pandemic?Revised Research Question: Did implementing telehealth improve staffing efficiency and delivery of care to underserved populations in FQHCs post-pandemic?Auchus, I., Jaradeh, K., Tang, A., Marzan, J., & Boslett, B. (2021). Transitioning to Telehealth during the COVID-19 Pandemic:

Annotated Bibliography and Healthcare Case Study
Words: 611 Length: 2 Document Type: Annotated Bibliography

Annotated bibliography1. Coombs, N.C., Campbell, D.G. & Caringi, J. A qualitative study of rural healthcare providers� views of social, cultural, and programmatic barriers to healthcare access.�BMC Health Serv Res�22,�438 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12913-022-07829-2This resource details the barriers to entry that many middle- and lower-class Americans face with access to healthcare. Here, the resource details the rising cost of healthcare. Here the article provides detailed insights into the rising cost of healthcare relative

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now