Verified Document

Pornographic Imagination," Susan Sontag Attempts Essay

For example, while Bill is restlessly waiting for his son's friend to eat the sandwich he has drugged, the film lingers on the boy's posterior, forcing the viewer to adopt the agitated, and aroused, perspective of Bill himself. However, far from engaging in the horror film trope of the assailant's direct point-of-view, the shot is not positioned directly from Bill's position on the couch, but rather from an intermediate space such that the audience is forced to inhabit Bill's particular sexual desire while remaining physically apart from him. In this moment, the viewer participates in the same pornographic imagination as Bill, if only because the viewer is capable of imagining how the image affects him. As such, "spectators may find it difficult, if not impossible, to digest or process" any "moral position" in regards to what is shown, and thus are left only with the position provided by Bill himself (Tylim 1999, p. 307). Similarly, Frisk forces a recognition of "the reader's complicity in [its] extreme representations," both because the reader must inhabit the mind of the narrator and because many of the most transgressive moments are relayed in the second person, such that the reader takes on the role of Julian reading Dennis' letter (Aaron 2004, p. 115). For example, when Dennis says "his ass was so little and perfect it felt more like a prototype than a real ass, which made me think about what you once said about Kevin's ass, that it was 'a toy ass'," the reader is momentarily placed in the role of commenting on an adolescent boy's ass, even if the "you" in the statement ostensibly refers to Julian (Cooper, 1991, p. 103). Thus, the text is pornographic in the sense that it represents an iteration of the pornographic imagination, even if it cannot be "used" by the reader for his or her own sexual pleasure (which is not to say that a reader cannot be aroused by Dennis' narration; in fact, one might go so far as to argue that the repulsion the reader might feel towards Dennis' actions is not fundamentally different from the arousal he feels, because it is merely the same kind of intense mental and physical reaction, albeit in a different direction).

In the case of Happiness, the relation between sexual transgression and knowledge is highlighted by the conversations between Bill and his son, Billy, because Billy looks to Bill for knowledge regarding his own sexual development. This is why the final scene between the two is so powerful; Billy's questions about his father being a serial rapist are not out of the blue, but rather follow from a procession of questions he has been asking throughout the film. Similarly, Dennis' killing spree can be seen as a quest to obtain the knowledge which has remained tantalizingly out of reach ever since he discovers that the snuff porn he viewed as a youth was faked, knowledge "too out-of-focus to actually explore with one's eyes, but too mysterious not to want to try" (Cooper, 1991, p. 4). This line, which actually describes the center of a young Henry's anus as he lies seemingly...

The pornographic images Dennis views as a youth reveal to him the limits of his current knowledge as well as the seemingly limitless knowledge offered by sexual transgression, and "draw him farther and farther into the outer limits of society" (Storey 2005, p. 67).
In "The Pornographic Imagination," Susan Sontag reveals the inextricable connection between transgression and epistemological yearning, by noting how transgression, in addition to representing a kind of break or rupture, simultaneously provides access to previously verboten knowledge, knowledge unattainable by any means other than transgression. Recognizing how pornography expresses this drive towards knowledge is only possible if one is willing to discard many of the moralistic assumptions and distinctions that have characterizes the historical consideration of pornography, both in academia and elsewhere, because only by approaching pornography in terms of what it does, rather than what many people assume it is supposed to do, is one able to effectively describe it functions and relations to human experience more generally. Sontag's approach to pornography is vindicated when one considers it in light of Dennis Cooper's Frisk and Todd Solondz' Happiness, because these texts remain somewhat impenetrable unless one considers how the sexual transgressions of their protagonists are related to the general desire for verboten or mysterious knowledge. These texts succeed in drawing their audience into the (admittedly deranged) desires and actions of the protagonists precisely because they appeal to the universal desire for knowledge and rely on pornography's unique ability to align that desire with the heightened physical and emotional states of sexual arousal. The audience cannot help but experience the vicarious thrill of new knowledge, because even if it recoils at the violence of the protagonists' actions, the representation of these actions allows the audience the briefest glimpse of a kind of knowledge usually reserved only for the most despised individuals in society.

References

Aaron, M. 2004, "(Fill-in-the) Blank Fiction: Dennis Coopers Cinematics and the Complicitous

Reader," Journal of Modern Literature, vol. 27, no. 3, pp. 115-127.

Cooper, D. (1991), Frisk, Grove Press, New York.

Happiness, 1998, motion picture, Killer Films, distributed by Good Machine, United States.

Kieran, M. 2001, "Pornographic Art," Philosophy and Literature, vol. 25, no. 1, pp. 31-45.

Levinson, J. 2005, "Erotic Art and Pornographic Pictures," Philosophy and Literature, vol. 29,

no. 1, pp. 228-240.

Sontag, S. (2002), Styles of Radical Will, Picador, New York.

Storey, M. 2005, "And as things fell apart": The Crisis of Postmodern Masculinity in…

Sources used in this document:
References

Aaron, M. 2004, "(Fill-in-the) Blank Fiction: Dennis Coopers Cinematics and the Complicitous

Reader," Journal of Modern Literature, vol. 27, no. 3, pp. 115-127.

Cooper, D. (1991), Frisk, Grove Press, New York.

Happiness, 1998, motion picture, Killer Films, distributed by Good Machine, United States.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Epistemological Beliefs and Organizational Leadership Epistemological...
Words: 1746 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Epistemological Beliefs and Organizational Leadership Epistemological Philosophies: Comparing Plato and Protagoras To understand our quest for knowledge, we often have to go back to some of the classical theories in order to get a full view of how modern theories have developed. Understanding classical philosophy is not blindly reading one philosopher and then assuming you have the knowledge of thousands of years of Greco-Roman thought. There were major differences within the philosophers

Epistemological Analysis of a Personal Experience in
Words: 1622 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Epistemological Analysis of a Personal Experience In people's most ordinary encounters with new information, and in their most refined knowledge pursuits, as human beings our beliefs regarding knowing and knowledge affect us. Human beings personal epistemologies, epistemic cognition, mean of knowing or epistemological theories get activated during the process of knowing and learning. For instance, when we read newspapers, we usually make judgment concerning the trustworthiness made in the newspapers. Similarly,

Epistemological Assumptions Reconciling Safety and Succession Planning...
Words: 778 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Epistemological Assumptions Reconciling Safety and Succession Planning Focus Organization This paper discusses the philosophical assumptions and epistemological stances of Belfast Petroleum, Inc. As they relate to issues of on-boarding, transitioning, and promoting new engineers to greater levels of responsibility. Belfast Petroleum is based in Calgary, Canada, and was acquired by Merit Energy, Ltd. On July 14, 1999. The core competencies of the Belfast Petroleum are services related to oil and gas exploration, development,

Epistemological Belief in the External World Can
Words: 2511 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Epistemological Belief in the External World Can We Know the External World Through Our Limited Sensory Perceptions? (1) Our senses are limited. (2) We can only perceive the world through our senses. (3) Therefore, our understanding of the external world is limited and not sufficiently justified in assuming that it is absolute in its existence. "What will then be true? Perhaps just the single fact that nothing is certain," so were the words of one

Epistemological Perspective Text Sources Coincides View
Words: 705 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

epistemological perspective text ( sources) coincides view truth human mind grasps reality. Explain find There are several different perspectives of epistemology, which is the justification for or the source of belief upon which all knowledge is based. One of the most compelling viewpoints that serve to explain how humans can actually perceive truth is empiricism. Essentially, empiricism is the notion that the truth can be ascertained via sensory information from

Woman: An Epistemological Programme of Mastery the
Words: 1647 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Woman: An Epistemological Programme of Mastery The philosophical discussion of the nature of the female mind and specifically the epistemology of women has been universally debated for as long as there has been recorded words. What is the nature of God? And then: What is the nature of Man? followed shortly there after by: What is the nature of Woman? It is not a secret that most of the first recorded

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now