Verified Document

Politics Of Administrative Law Term Paper

Politics of Administrative Law -- Weinstein, Wilson, and Shamir What is the political philosophy behind America's current state of federal and state administrative regulation? Although in an ideal historical environment, this would be easy to see in the recorded words of the Founding Fathers, the historian of American law is instead faced with a challenge, for the relationship between individual, state, and national government has changed considerably since this nation's founding. Also, the concept behind the historical and philosophic construction of administrative laws has varies considerably; depending on whether the political paradigm selected is political and corporative, economic, pluralist, or judicial in its nature and focus.

The historians and political philosophers James Weinstein, James Q. Wilson, and Ronen Shamir, would no doubt all agree that a seismic shift occurred during the turn of the century in America, in terms of the way individual rights were conceptualized, and continued to become prioritized over the course of the century from a legal and political perspective. During this period of time, America shifted from an America without a federal income tax, an America where the Bill of Rights was only strictly applicable to federal rather than state legislation, to a nation with a complex civil rights system of litigation and a bureaucratic tax and federal civil service structure. Over the course of the century and afterwards, legislation was passed to make American industry more humane, and to change the integration of women and blue-collar workers into the American nation. The 20th century saw changes as women began to vote, and worker's rights became protected in the capitalist system, and African-American rights were guaranteed legally and legislatively. The political and economic, as well as legal reasons behind this shift, however, remain controversial.

James Weinstein has been one of the foremost historical and legal advocates of what he terms "corporate liberalism," in tracing the reasons for this shift from the value placed upon the American ideal of independence, autonomy, and capitalist freedom to the acknowledgement that the state must protect individual rights...

Weinstein believes that the urban socialist movement, originally designated to create corporate structures of unity to force the state to recognize the need to protect the rights of workers to unionize and women to vote, is key to understanding the development of an American state that actively protects individual rights rather than to passively allow capitalism and individual rights to be exercised. (Weinstein, 1967)
In his seminal text, The Decline of American Socialism James Weinstein contended that, rather than being a primarily individualist or mosaic structure, the urban America of the Progressive era was far more cooperative than one might believe, from a social, legal, and political perspective. In this controversial text, which functions on its surface as a history of the now-defunct American Socialist party, Weinstein stressed that organizations such as the supposedly marginal Socialist Party were actually quite foundational in structuring what we think of as American law and society today. Because of the political and ideological influence of the Socialist Party, America no longer came to believe that the market forces alone could regulate such elements of modern life as the hours required for individuals to work in a capitalist environment. State intervention was required.

Weinstein cautions that merely because the word 'socialist' is often used in a derogatory fashion in political rhetoric does not mean that socialism has no presence in the establishment of a state that assumes responsibility for its citizen's well being. The Socialist Party may no longer be an active political presence in American politics, but its ideology, invisibly, has become woven into the social and legal fabric of administrative law.

To make his argument Weinstein outlines the history of the party in relation to the development of industrial America, the Progressive Movement, and the increased ethnic complexity of the urban locals of America. He states that rather than being a 'fringe' party the party made a significant impact in its united stand against World War I, although it was unsuccessful in preventing the war. Attempts to limit freedom of speech merely drew…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Weinstein, James. The Decline of American Socialism, 1967.

Wilson, James Q. Political Organizations. New York: Basic Books, 1973.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Politics of Administrative Law
Words: 1193 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Politics of Administrative Law An Examination of the Challenges Presented by NLRB vs. Jones & Laughlin Steel Corp. To the Political, Economic, and Legal Philosophies Developed from Munn vs. Illinois and Lochner vs. New York As the 19th century drew to a close, the impact of the Industrial Revolution resulted in shifts in the social contract and witnessed the beginnings of the concentration of corporate power in the hands of big trusts

Administrative Law
Words: 561 Length: 2 Document Type: Case Study

Administrative Law Lujan v. Defenders of Wildlife Facts: Lujan, the secretary of the Interior is representing the federal government. Defenders of Wildlife is an organization that exists for the purpose of protecting endangered animals. In 1973 the federal government enacted Section 7(a)(2) of the Endangered Species Act, which was originally designed to protect endangered species in the United States and foreign nations. However, the law was scaled back to only apply to

Politics and the Economy in
Words: 1813 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

1, 10.6, respectively 4.5. Behind these figures however, Haiti remains the poorest country in the western hemisphere. 80% of the total population in the country lives below the poverty line; 54% of them live in abject poverty. Over 60% of the population depends directly on agriculture to ensure food sustainability. Massive deforestations, combined with natural hazards (most commonly tropical storms), harden the living standards of the individuals (Central Intelligence Agency). While the

Soviet Law
Words: 1661 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

Soviet Law The legal system of Russia may be viewed through the prism of communism and Marxism, but that is not all that needs to be considered when discussing Soviet than Russian legal ideology and court systems (Bartlett, 2008). In reviewing the development in how western scholars think about the impact on Russian law from Soviet legal practices, Bartlett points out that law is more than just statutes it is also

Health Politics "What Is the Role of
Words: 3149 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Health Politics "What is the role of Congress in policy making process"? Policy is a plan to identify goal or possible course of actions with administrative or management tools to accomplish these goals. On the other hand, policy is the authoritative decision made by the U.S. executive, legislative, judicial branch of government to influence the decision of others. Government is a key player in decision-making process and congress plays important roles in

Gonzales V. Oregon and the Politics of Medicine
Words: 608 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Briefings on Administrative Law Case facts In 1994, the initial state law that gave physicians the authority to prescribe lethal amounts of controlled substances to terminally ill patients was established by Oregon. However, in 2001 the Attorney General Ashcroft affirmed that the physician-steered suicide dishonored the Controlled Substances Act enacted in 1970. The Attorney General threatened to revoke all the medical physician licenses of those who took part in the practice.

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now