Verified Document

Policy Statement Analysis The Tri-Council Research Proposal

Ongoing Duty to Inform

The 2008 draft version of Chapter 3: Free and Informed Consent, Article 3.3 under Section A. General Principles adds a comprehensive explanation of the specific duty of researchers to continue the information disclosure element of the duty to inform throughout the participation in the research project. In that regard, the 2008 draft version details the obligation of researchers to bring to participants' attention any information that comes to light subsequent to the initial informed consent acquisition process. That provision further details the obligation to continue providing relevant information even beyond the conclusion of the research study where appropriate or necessary.

Incidental Findings

The 2008 draft version of Chapter 3: Free and Informed Consent, Article 3.4 under Section A. General Principles adds an Incidental Findings section that is absent from the 2003 draft version. In principle, this provision defines incidental findings as findings that could have potentially significant social, psychological, health-related, or other relevant consequences to the participant.

Specifically, according to Article 3.4, researchers have an obligation to develop a plan for handling any incidental findings, to submit them to the research ethical board, and to advise potential study participants in conjunction with the informed consent acquisition process. Furthermore, Article 3.4 also sets forth that obligation within the earlier-described obligation to of continuing ongoing disclosure of any information relevant to study participants.

The Burden of Responsibility to Justify the Need for Protocol Departure

In the 2003 draft version, Section A. General Principles Article 2.1 subsection c does establish the requirement for research ethics board approval of consent procedures that alter any aspect of the general informed consent process. However, in the 2008 draft version, Section...

Departures from General Principles of Consent Article 3.8 imposes a new obligation on researchers to justify the need for any such departures objectively.
Implications

In general, Chapter 3: Free and Informed Consent of the 2008 draft version of the Tri-Council Policy Statement: Ethical Conduct for Research Involving Humans evidences substantially greater respect for the spirit of the ethical responsibilities incumbent upon researchers to ensure the breadth and quality of informed consent. This reflects an ethical concern expressed throughout contemporary ethical approaches to consent in connection with medicine and human research (Levine, 2008; Tong, 2007).

The 2003 draft version addressed some of the most important concepts and definitions, but in a manner that could be considered cursory or merely designed for quick compliance and the mitigation of potential legal risks and liabilities on the part of the researchers and the institutions conducting research (Halbert & Ingulli, 2007; Tong. 2007).

The 2008 draft version greatly enhances the protective functions of the provisions that are in common between the respective draft versions. More importantly, the 2008 draft version amends the 2003 version with provisions that establish additional obligations that were entirely ignored by the 2003 version. Undoubtedly, the 2008 draft version provides far more comprehensive and meaningful protections for the interests of research subjects.

Bibliography

Halbert T. And Ingulli E. (2007). Law & Ethics in the Business Environment. Cincinnati,

OH: West.

Levine C. (2008). Taking Sides: Clashing Views on Bioethical Issues. Dubuque, Iowa:

The McGraw Hill Companies Inc.

Tong R. (2007). New Perspectives in Health Care Ethics: An Interdisciplinary and Cultural Approach. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education, Inc.

Tri-Council Policy…

Sources used in this document:
Bibliography

Halbert T. And Ingulli E. (2007). Law & Ethics in the Business Environment. Cincinnati,

OH: West.

Levine C. (2008). Taking Sides: Clashing Views on Bioethical Issues. Dubuque, Iowa:

The McGraw Hill Companies Inc.
http://pre.ethics.gc.ca/eng/policy-politique/tcps-eptc/readtcps-lireeptc/.
http://pre.ethics.gc.ca/eng/policy-politique/tcps-eptc/readtcps-lireeptc/.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Analysis of Canadian Research Integrity
Words: 1756 Length: 5 Document Type: Book Report

Integrity in Canada Even though Canada has one of the best systems dealing with research integrity and disciplining of misconduct, the system just like any other, has a few disadvantages. In fact, many people in the Canadian research community are of the opinion that something needs to be done to make the system more efficient to avoid any destructive future effects of negative research conduct. However, Canada is not the

Geopolitical Analysis of China From
Words: 3969 Length: 12 Document Type: Essay

America's engagement with China, with historic ice-breaking between the two countries carried out by Henry Kissinger, has been complicated. I would suggest that it were the U.S. domestic preoccupations and compulsions that did not allow me to take any bold stance on the issue of Dalai Lama. I disagree with notion that U.S. betrayed the cause of human rights while not choosing to visit Dalai Lama. It must not be

Identifying Ways to Tear Down Organizational Silos
Words: 2435 Length: 10 Document Type: Methodology Chapter

Silo Mentality: An Organizational Case Study Living in specialized silos might make life seem more efficient in the short-term. But a world that is always divided into a fragmented and specialist pattern is a place of missed risks and opportunities. – Shayne Kavanaugh, 2015 Chapter One: Introduction The interconnectivity of teams within a company requires information to be shared both laterally and vertically with all teams to positivity impact morale, labor, and production

Devised; It Has to Be
Words: 5709 Length: 15 Document Type: Thesis

At times, even though the research may be complicated by varying definitions of homelessness, researchers are establishing methods for estimating the size of the homeless population, which includes people who have nowhere to go; at risk of losing housing through eviction or institutional discharge (Drury, 2008). Case Study Methodology In the case study methodology, a form of qualitative descriptive research, according to M. Dereshiwsky (1999) in "Electronic Textbook - Let Us

Narcoterrorism and the Future
Words: 18088 Length: 70 Document Type: Capstone Project

Mexico faces an array of drug-related problems ranging from production and transshipment of illicit drugs to corruption, violence, and increased internal drug abuse. Powerful and well-organized Mexican organizations control drug production and trafficking in and through Mexico, as well as the laundering of drug proceeds. These organizations also have made a concerted effort to corrupt and intimidate Mexican law enforcement and public officials. In addition, the geographic proximity of

Argentina's Definition of Terrorism Is
Words: 3585 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

These policies aim to prevent such proceeds from being utilized in future criminal activities and from affecting legitimate economic activities" (Anti-Money Laundering Authority, n.d.). Another action taken at the international level this time is represented by the cooperation programs which are designed to strengthen the level of information exchange on the one hand and the financial possibilities of the countries involved in the projects on the other hand. Thus, "Argentina

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now