Verified Document

Policy Rules Discussion Chapter

Policy and Science Fiddler on the Roof

Science has traditionally been presented as the a priori fact-finding, theory-establishing stage one of policy making. Stage two of this conventional approach has policy makers utilizing the "empirical truths" that science offers in support of policies to be enacted to solve a policy problem. Yet both policymaking and empirical research are -- by their very nature -- ongoing human endeavors. Policymakers want the best that science has to offer -- when they need it -- for decision-making, policymaking, and policy implementation. Science marches to its own tune, with agendas set by dynamics such as funding for research or public and private priorities and pressures (Kingdon, 1984). And, increasingly, in a funding environment that is cooling off, the ability to do research is often determined by its application -- public service adding a positive valence -- and the ability to enact policy is dependent on scientific evidence that the policy problem will be robustly and adequately addressed through implementation of the proposed policy.

Haller & Gerrie (2007) argued that "Decisions must be made and not postponed until...

143). According to Haller and Gerrie, the power of science to support evidence-based policy decisions is undermined by the very act of exposing science to the demands and parameters set policymakers. The researchers further suggest that scientists position themselves as hired guns with particular interest groups rather than posing as objective consultants to decision-makers.
Speaking Truth to Power

The issue is not if science can provide "truth," but whether policymakers agree that there is not an efficient frontier for policymaking wherein all the policy makers will have perfect and complete information with which to formulate policy (Wildavsky, 1979). It is essential that scientists communicate that there is no perfect solution -- no silver bullet, no magic potion -- that can be offered up for timely utility in the policymaking stream. It is incumbent on scientists to communicate in such a way that they "identify and further the public interest by discrediting policy options serving only special interests…

Sources used in this document:
References

Haller, S.F. And Gerrie, J. (2007). The role of science in pubic policy: Higher reason, or reason for hire. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 20,(2).

Kingdon, J.W. (1984). Agendas, alternatives, and public policies. New York, NY: Harper Collins Publishers.

Pressman, J.L. And Wildavsky, A. (1984). Implementation. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

Wildavsky, A. (1979). Speaking truth to power: The art and craft of policy analysis. Boston, MA: Little, Brown Publishers.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Policy Process: On Long-Term Care Part II
Words: 1287 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Policy Process: on LONG-TERM CARE Part II Policy Process 3292 Health care and nursing is more complex today than ever before. New technologies and ever-growing population demands a much more disciplined and organized health care industry (Abood, 2007). This is possible when there are policies, rules and regulations about medical procedures. The medical industry involves some policies today that a person could never imagine few centuries ago. For example there are policies

Policies and Procedures Reliance Healthcare Computer Policies
Words: 878 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Policies and Procedures Reliance Healthcare Computer Policies and Procedures The installation of a new computer system requires many considerations from a managerial standpoint. Computer usage, particularly access to the Internet is controversial, as there is significant room for abuse by staff. The new system will help to streamline processes in the organization, but it will also provide opportunities for non-productive time. The forthcoming policies and procedures are designed to allow employees access

Policy Analysis Critique - Hong Kong Health
Words: 3476 Length: 11 Document Type: Thesis

Policy Analysis Critique - Hong Kong Health Care System Policy Analysis Critique: Hong Kong Health Care System The health care system in Hong Kong is believed to be one of the best in the world. The majority of people there live longer than people in many other developed nations, and the infant mortality rate is also very low. Those things show that people in Hong Kong are committed to their health and

Policies Human Resources Management Is Basically Something
Words: 6716 Length: 15 Document Type: Term Paper

Policies Human Resources Management is basically something that encompasses various activities in an office environment, some of them being: what sort of employees does a company need, what are the best methods to recruit as well as train these personnel, making sure that the performance levels of these people is at its optimum best, and also making sure that the rules regarding management issues are followed to the letter by the

Rules of Civil Procedure Scenario
Words: 1640 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

" (Redish and Phillips, 1979) the relationship is not as clear between the standard and balancing test that the court used in the Hanna and Byrd case. (Redish and Phillips, 1979; paraphrased) Burbank (1934) states in the "Rules Enabling Act of 1934" published in May 1982 in the University of Pennsylvania Law Review " that unless one is a cynic, it would leave one to wonder "that the original Federal Rules

Rules of Engagement for War
Words: 314 Length: 1 Document Type: Term Paper

Rules of Engagement for War In summary, there are a number of highly eminent reasons why ROE is creating an adverse effect on American military personnel -- particularly in overseas missions in Afghanistan. They are presenting a fundamental conflict of interest -- soldiers have to consider both their mission objectives as well as the legal ramifications of not adhering to ROE, which creates situations of hesitancy, delay, and American casualties as

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now