Verified Document

Police Officers And Police Article Critique

¶ … POBR signifies. POBR stands for Police Officer's Bill of Rights. This bill, sponsored in the 1971 to 1972 session by late Congressman Mario Biaggi, was a bill that had the support at first, of over 121 cosponsors. A bill that kept the safety of police officers in mind while also providing them with occupational rights, the bill came from a source of concern by Biaggi who himself was a former police officer shot ten times while on duty (Page, 2013). Although the bill received great support, it took twenty years until it was sent to the Senate floor where it passed by an 8-point margin of 55 to 43 (Schmidt, 2005). It was not until 1995 it would be sponsored by both the Senate and the House. The current name for the POBR bills are "State and Local Law Enforcement Discipline, Accountability, and Due Process Act. The POBR bills have not passed through both Houses of Congress meaning there is no federal version of these bills (Aitchison, 2015). However, a minimum of seventeen states have enacted the POBR bills. Some of which are: Delaware, California, Louisiana, Tennessee, Texas, and Virginia (Schmidt, 2005).

Although some states have adopted the POBR bills, in the past ten years, states that do not have the POBR bills enacted have seen police union action in an attempt to enact them. They have been met with little success due to the lack of harmony in state POBR versions. Regardless of whether state or federal governments enacted the bills, some have sought to voluntarily adopt and draft their own POBR provisions. These two state associations are Colorado Association of Chiefs of Police and the Arizona...

These actions led to draft version of POBR law that would be utilized as a reference document in states where there is still pending POBR legislation. Although it was not approved by the IACP Legislative Committee, it did receive attention from several state associations of chiefs of police.
The subcommittee generate document remains in what can be considered 'stealth mode' and has been for the last eight years. This is due to the lack of IACP members wanting to accept any POBR legislation irrespective of how balanced the legislation may be. Due to the blatant and consistent opposition, there is desire to bring this issue back to the surface and provide people with adequate alternatives to the pending legislation seen in that area. While there is an employee bill of rights for police officers, the POBR bills can help provide clarity in an otherwise vague interpretation of rights of police officers.

An employee bill of rights exists in most states for police officers and must be sondiered in conducting personal investigations. Criminal justice employees are protected under the Bill of Rights of the U.S. Constitutions, as are other citizens. However, labor organizations have promoted the officers' bill of rights. This bill exists because most criminal justice employees perform within a hierarchical authoritarian structure that could result in employees giving up their rights because of commands from their superiors (Cronkhite & Cronkhite, 2013, p. 185).

The decision to revisit the POBR laws is to gain some type of alternative that can grant police officers additional rights that they otherwise would not be aware of in order to protect themselves from potential problems.

Alternative…

Sources used in this document:
References

Aitchison, W. (2015). The rights of law enforcement officers. Portland, OR: Labor Relations Information System Publications.

Cronkhite, C. & Cronkhite, C. (2013). Law enforcement and justice administration. Burlington, MA: Jones & Bartlett Learning.

Page, J. (2013). The toughest beat. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Schmidt, W. (2005). Peace Officers' Bill of Rights Guarantees: Responding to Union Demands with a Management Sanctioned Version. Law Enforcement Executive Forum, 5(2), 1-10.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Police Deviance and Integrity in
Words: 1631 Length: 6 Document Type: Research Paper

This is when they will abide by these guidelines. The enforcement of these provisions will create a procedure for investigating offenses, protecting the rights of the accused and punishing those who violate the code of ethics. ("Police Officer Code of Ethics," 2004) (Berg, 1999) What makes this approach so unique is the department will function as an independent entity. This means that Internal Affairs will have the power to overrule

Police Civil Liability Is One of the
Words: 1122 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Police civil liability is one of the more complex areas of civil law. Because of their unique position in society, police officers have to be free to engage in behavior that would be tortious if it was committed by people outside of law enforcement. However, that same unique societal position means that those in law enforcement are given opportunities to abuse power that others do not have. The apparent dichotomy

Police History Analyze the Relationship Between the
Words: 913 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Police History Analyze the relationship between the U.S. government and the policing organizations throughout the United States. The relationship between the U.S. government and policing organizations is loosely coordinated. This means that local agencies will determine what personnel they hire and how different resources are utilized. In some cases, the various departments work for specific entities such as: colleges / universities or transit departments. Evidence of this can be seen with observations

Police Ethics
Words: 3948 Length: 12 Document Type: Capstone Project

Police Ethics Ethics, therefore, is not something that a policeman learns in the classroom -- yet, training classes are regularly scheduled -- and this picture of student not understanding why he is in the classroom is indicative of the problem of police ethics as a whole (Crank, Caldero, 2011). There is no established, realistic connection between policing and classroom ethics. The world of the streets is a different from the world

Police Agencies Have Adopted Different
Words: 2275 Length: 6 Document Type: Research Paper

It was thus decided that the use of force by the police was justified by the circumstances and that accusations were more of an issue of violation of rights rather than violent demeanor against Graham. The motion filled by the accused for a directed verdict was granted. The case is now known to have provided, and still does, insight as to what defines reasonable use of force. According to

Police Ethics
Words: 1113 Length: 4 Document Type: Capstone Project

Police Ethics Description Ethics is a delicate topic in the context of policing, as police officers are often coming across situations when they need to act on account of their instinct rather than on ethical thinking. Individuals are subjected to a continuous amount of stress during their jobs as police officers and they thus have to be able to put across the best performance possible on a constant basis. Even with this,

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now