Verified Document

Police Officer And Lying Essay

¶ … law enforcement agencies have often struggled with officer dishonesty and the impact such an action leaves not just in the criminal justice system, but more specifically in court proceedings. When an officer lies, their credibility may be threatened due to their previous dishonest comportment. Agencies must, on a continued basis, disclose information to prosecutors concerning the issue of officer dishonesty if the officer in question must testify against a defendant. That defendant must also be made aware of the instance of officer dishonesty and if this is not done, the agencies and officers may be held accountable as well as potentially lead to dismissal of charges against the defendant. An example of this was seen in Brady v. Maryland. The landmark case of Brady v. Maryland demonstrated the effects of withholding information or evidence in case proceedings by the decision of the prosecutors to not submit Boblit's confession as evidence. As a result of the court ruling, the 'Brady disclosure' came into effect and requires prosecution must disclose what can be identified as 'material exculpatory evidence' to the defendant. This kind of evidence includes physical evidence, witnesses or statements that could impeach a prosecution witness' credibility.

Police officers that have been dishonest are nicknamed 'Brady Cops' because of 'Brady disclosure'. They are given this name because if any of those cops were to serve as witness in a court proceeding, the prosecutor would have to let the defense know the police officer was dishonest at one point. This not only creates conflict among police officers and prosecutors, but in how law enforcement manages dishonest police officers. Therefore, should someone catch a police officer lying, then the best decision would be dismissal. Messing with court proceedings is just one bad moment in a series of moments that can happen once a police officer has been recognized as dishonest.

Police officers should be terminated because dishonesty leads to distrust and misinformation among police officers as they, under the collective knowledge doctrine, rely on valid information offered to them by other officers. If that information is based on a lie, then it can cause a ripple effect among those involved in collecting the information. For example, supervisors have access to the collected information, and must render decisions based on...

The information network also extends to citizens.
Citizens may develop a distrust of police officers if they discover police officers can lie and not face consequences. Such distrust can also reach the court system. Prosecutors need honest reports, affidavits, and statements when pursuing cases. When judges assess warrants, they must rely on honest information. Finally, jurors determine the innocence of guilt of someone based on testimony given by a police officer and investigations performed by the police officer. At first it may seem unfair to dismiss a police officer for lying once, but they are held to a higher standard and their honesty is integral in the nature of their work. It is a price they must pay to ensure the stability of a criminal justice system.

That price can come at a heavy cost. Some personnel may have been outstanding officers during their career. They may have been exemplary in every way and then demonstrate weakness at one point in their careers. They lie and while their past indicates a great police officer, that one error in judgment could wipe it all away, especially if the police officer never faces severe consequences and continues on his or her job. New York City for example, has had dozens of police officers stay on the force even after they were proven liars. This led to law suits by civilians against some of…

Sources used in this document:
References

Lewis, R. & Veltman, N. (2015). The Hard Truth About Cops Who Lie. WNYC. Retrieved 16 October 2016, from http://www.wnyc.org/story/hard-truth-about-cops-who-lie/
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Ethics in Law Enforcement "Sometimes Police Officers
Words: 1373 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Ethics in Law Enforcement "Sometimes [police officers] may, and sometimes may not, lie when conducting custodial interrogations. Investigative and interrogatory lying are each justified on utilitarian crime control grounds. Police are never supposed to lie as witnesses in the courtroom, although they may lie for utilitarian reasons similar to those permitting deception & #8230;" (Skolnick, et al., 1992) Is it ethical for law enforcement officers to use deception during the interrogation process?

When Is It Prudent for a Police Officer to Shoot a Suspect
Words: 793 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Alleged Crimes -- Civil Action The four alleged crimes in this scenario are: a) an alleged armed robbery and assault on a woman at 2:00 A.M. in a high-crime area; b) an individual refused to comply with an officer's commands; c) that individual was found to be in possession of illegal substances (possibly cocaine); and d) providing false information from the woman who alleged she was robbed and assaulted. Review of the

Officer Accountability
Words: 1736 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

Officer Accountability A police officer's proven dishonesty is not a minor matter. Ignoring or covering up that dishonesty, if discovered, could be devastating to the police department's credibility. Furthermore, due to Due Process laws in the United States, his/her dishonesty could affect the outcome of past cases in which he/she testified and future cases in which he/she may testify. Finally, the prosecution is required to hand that information to defendants' attorneys.

Police Use of Force --
Words: 1107 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

One police officer for example referred to the chaos as a "holocaust," far removed from the real world (Shankman et al., 2010). Alpert and Smith (2001, p. 483) note that a survey of the public showed a general perception that the police is frequently excessively violent in their contact with the public. According to the authors, the targets of reported abuse are generally lower class males, with a common factor

Police Interrogation Techniques Within the
Words: 1668 Length: 6 Document Type: Research Paper

These individuals are at risk of either confessing to crimes they did not commit or otherwise compromising their rights by virtue of inappropriate police interrogation techniques (Gudjonsson, 2003), a fact that has increasingly been recognized by the courts in their evaluation of the constitutionality of the interrogation methods that were used by police during their confinement preparatory for trial (Kinports, 2007). Conclusion Taken together, the research indicated that police interrogation remains

Police Honesty
Words: 1604 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

Officer Misconduct Disclosing Officer Untruthfulness to the Defense: Is a Liar's Squad Coming to Your Town? Officer misconduct scenario Police officers must not simply be held to the same standards as members of the public. They must be held to a higher standard. This is illustrated in the following scenario: a police officers is found to have searched for pornographic materials on a work computer and when initially confronted about this violation of

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now