Verified Document

Pojman's View On Merit According Essay

A man's ethical behavior should be based effectually on sympathy, education and social ties, and needs. No religious basis is necessary." Einstein, 1954 [emphasis supplied]

Alternate Suggested Application of Pojman's Thesis

From many ethical perspectives, the implications of Pojman's analysis with respect to punishment (i.e. "just deserts"), is more problematic than his suggestions about rewarding positive human behavior at the other end of the spectrum. In fact, there is no reason that Pojman's entire thesis need be discarded just to purify it of its most problematic implications. For example, the following description of a human community would resolve many of the most serious ethical criticisms of Pojman's approach while still allowing some of his more beneficial aspects of his merit-and-just deserts-based analysis: The envisioned society would de-emphasize penal law to the extent it is designed for the purpose of retributive punishment of wrongdoers. On the other hand, it would sanction punitive confinement as necessary to protect potential victims and it would sanction any form of compensatory mechanisms and obligations on wrongdoers to make their victims whole.

There would appear to be much more merit, as it were, to Pojman's argument with respect to the justification of promoting correspondence between the benefit and value contributed by individuals to...

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

In principle, there is nothing inherently offensive about imposing some higher levels of taxes on income levels in the private sector to fund compensation of highly "productive" in the sense referenced by Pojman, such as to pay firefighters, police officers, and teachers a more competitive wage. That is also a moderate "socialist" position that allows every individual the personal autonomy to pursue capitalist ventures for profit while imposing some limit on the disparate earning level between those who devote themselves to more selfish goals and those who choose to contribute more to the community.
Under that approach, one could apply the general principles of merit-for-contribution suggested by Pojman. A society could operate under the assumption that everyone's lot in life is at least somewhat predetermined by nature and circumstances and therefore punish only for protection of the innocent and compensation for the aggrieved. Meanwhile, more "selfish" lifestyles would be permitted but, in essence, taxed appropriately to reward teachers and emergency service personnel and others who choose to commit themselves to less selfish lives.

References

Einstein, A. (1954). Ideas and Opinions. New York: Crown.

Pojman, L. "Merit: Why Do We Value It?" Journal of Social Philosophy, Vol. 30, No. 1;

(1999): 83-102.

Sources used in this document:
References

Einstein, A. (1954). Ideas and Opinions. New York: Crown.

Pojman, L. "Merit: Why Do We Value It?" Journal of Social Philosophy, Vol. 30, No. 1;

(1999): 83-102.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Merit Pay for Performance Is
Words: 4373 Length: 16 Document Type: Term Paper

Bonuses could also be earned by taking advanced courses in improving classroom techniques and by improving the scores their students achieved on state tests. These salary additions can add up to as much as $9,800 per year. In addition, teachers' pay can be docked if state testing demonstrates that their students have fallen too far below expectations (Philips & Tyre, 2007). The system has been so successful, that Denver has

Merit Pay the Advantages of
Words: 1760 Length: 6 Document Type: Thesis

On the other hand, merit pay systems may inspire unhealthy competition among coworkers or excessive peer pressure among teams of workers whose individual performance are measured together. In the worst case scenario, merit pay can result in unscrupulous conduct and undermine the camaraderie in the work environment to a degree that actually affects overall output negatively instead of positively. Certain vocational environments are more likely to benefit from merit pay

Merit Pay Teacher Performance Measured
Words: 2483 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

This involves "changing the role of school personnel in such a way that the resulting organization is capable of adapting the program of a given school to meet the needs of the child" (Conte, 1972) (finally, someone remembers that schools are about students not teachers). If the "objective of any reform measure is to increase the potential of the learning environment and facilitate the learning process" then creative ideas

Merit Pay Plans Incentive Pay Plans and Profit Sharing Plans As Motivators...
Words: 705 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Value of Merit-Based Plans, Incentive-Based Plans, and Profit Sharing Plans Merit-based payment plans, incentive-based payment plans, and company profit sharing plans all can be classified as organizational attempts to foster employee loyalty, increase employee productivity, and make the company a more attractive place to work. Their aim is to increase the motivation of employees to do quality work, above and beyond the expected minimum of the 'job description.' However, the

Public Administration the Merit Pay
Words: 6250 Length: 19 Document Type: Term Paper

This sentiment is echoed by a lot of supporters of merit pay who believe the way teachers are paid and how much they are paid must differ if districts are to attract a new cohort of teachers" (Drevitch, 2006). Some of the biggest disputes against merit pay have all been disputed previously, in the 1980's. In the 1980's, global rivalry was undermining U.S. businesses and corporations, and in an attempt

Pay for Performance
Words: 971 Length: 3 Document Type: Research Paper

Pay for performance is becoming commonplace in the business world. Pay raises and bonuses are often based on how well one performs on the job or on achieving specific results. However, this is not the case in education. Pay levels are typically based on years of experience and levels of education rather than on teacher effectiveness. As concerns about the quality of the nation's educational systems frequently appear in the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now