Verified Document

Plato's And Xenophon's Works Both Essay

One of the points clarified in this way is then, as mentioned above, Socrates' apparent stubborn foolhardiness in refusing to refute the court's decision. Xenophon notes that Socrates found death desirable over life. This is a point that Socrates himself also addresses in Plato's work, when he considers the possibilities of life after death. Socrates appears to consider both complete annihilation and the migration of the soul as preferable to his current life: annihilation would be like a restful and dreamless sleep, while the soul's migration would result in reuniting with old friends. Both of these possibilities are highly desirable to Socrates.

Unlike Plato, Xenophon places Socrates' ideas surrounding death at the beginning of his work. This places the rest of the philosopher's actions into perspective right at the beginning of the action. In Plato's work, on the other hand, the reader only receives this revelation when Socrates reacts to the death sentence.

As mentioned above, the issue of the court's corruption is also more explicitly and clearly explicated in Xenophon's work than in that of Plato. In Plato, Socrates appears oddly unsurprised by his sentence. Rather than the court specifically, he appears to implicate rival philosophers who brought him to his doom. This is further puzzling, as his defense appears articulate, and more than adequate to prove his innocence regarding all the...

The reason for this can be seen in Socrates' subjective view of his situation as it relates to his accusers and the court. Having the utmost respect for the State and its institutions, the philosopher appears much more concerned with his personal inner battles than his public battle in court. Although he might therefore be aware of the corruption of the court, Socrates may be unwilling to speak openly against it, rather focusing on the enmity between himself, Meletus, and his other rivals.
Xenophon's narrator however has not such limitations, and states openly that the court is not only corrupt in the sense of condemning the innocent, but also of freeing the guilty. Socrates is nonetheless unconcerned, as he is at peace with his fate. By his eloquence and fearless acceptance of his fate, Socrates then earns the respect of both Xenophon's and Plato's readers.

In this way, Xenophon's work appears to address some of the possible confusing elements in Plato's work by providing a wider perspective, and certain background information. Both works are however also great works of literature, each highly enjoyable as a unit unto itself as well.

Sources

Plato. Apology. Trans. By Benjamin Jowett. http://classics.mit.edu/Plato/apology.html

Xenophon. Apology of Socrates. Trans. By H.G. Dakyns. http://www.gutenberg.org/files/1171/1171-h/1171-h.htm

Sources used in this document:
Sources

Plato. Apology. Trans. By Benjamin Jowett. http://classics.mit.edu/Plato/apology.html

Xenophon. Apology of Socrates. Trans. By H.G. Dakyns. http://www.gutenberg.org/files/1171/1171-h/1171-h.htm
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Plato -- Life and Works Plato Was
Words: 961 Length: 3 Document Type: Research Paper

Plato -- Life and Works Plato was born in Athens circa 425 BC, just after the onset of the Peloponnesian War between Athens and Sparta. He lost his father at an early age, but through his mother's marriage to a friend of the leading statesman and general of Athens at the time, Plato became affiliated with some of the most influential circles of a city enjoying a Golden Age. The early

Socrates and Plato Greek Philosophy Held a
Words: 1909 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Socrates and Plato Greek philosophy held a preeminent place in the middle ages among scholastics like Thomas Aquinas, whose Summa Theologica was an attempt to reconcile faith and reason. The faith aspect was supplied by the Church, but the reason came from classical (pagan) ecclesiology -- notably from Greek philosophers like Plato and Aristotle. The latter was the pupil of the former, and the former was the pupil of the first

Socrates Both Comedy and Tragedy Are Related
Words: 1171 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Socrates Both comedy and tragedy are "related to emotional needs and religious longings that became crystallized and structured in ritualistic celebrations and festivals," (34). Both can be framed as "catalysts" that force "some sort of conversion" in the individual (34). Moreover, both comedy and tragedy reflect the "eternal spectacle of human nature and its weaknesses," (35). Both art forms use imitation or mimicry of a political figure or idea. However, there are

Epistemology and Philosophy of Socrates and Plato
Words: 2104 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Epistemology and Philosophy of Socrates and Plato Epistemology is the theory of knowledge. It attempts to answer such questions as: How does one acquire one's knowledge? What is knowledge? What is possible for us to truly know? Epistemological inquiry also deals with skepticism regarding certain claims of the true nature of knowledge. Ontology is the science of being. Ontological inquiry attempts to answer the fundamental questions of existence, and thus is

Myth of the Cave ' Why
Words: 2081 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Existentialism takes the human subject -- the holistic human, and the internal conditions as the basis and start of the conceptual way of explaining life. Taking idealism From Descartes, Kant, and Hegel, then building upon it, existentialist thinkers strip away the external and look at questions that surround human existence, and the conditions of that existence, rather than hypothesizing or dreaming of different forms of being. Thus, the inward

Greek History the Pericles Is
Words: 1841 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

The Plato was acknowledged for his contribution towards the development of the philosophy and arts. The scholar was deeply respected for his interest in the poetry and literature, and content of which narrated the political and social situation of the country, the Plato was always encouraged to join the political wing, but he expressed his reluctance because he believed that the cause was not strong and justified enough to offer

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now