Verified Document

Physical Activity And Body Mass Term Paper

We know that the results were hindered by water -- so those who sweat may have disabled the device or changed the result. 11 Were the relevant outcome measures ignored?

There was no analysis of the results of sexual maturity on BMI or exercise. Since all three groups could be aggregated for this portion of the study, the results might have been interesting and suggestive.

12 Are the statistical methods described?

Yes and no. We need to have an indication of the n. For each compliant subgroup, not just the total group.

13 Did untoward events occur during the study?

Yes, and the non-compliance should have been explained. Also, moving from the target of 7 days to 3 days smacks of a failed study -- either the measurement technique was too fussy, or the girls didn't want to comply. That implies even more selection bias than with the initial selection by brochure.

14 Was the basic data adequately described?

No. If there were additional data points, such as sexual maturity, they should have been presented.

15 Did the analysis allow for the passage of time?

No. 7 days establishes a point in time. It would be more interesting to understand the longer-term changes in exercise levels and BMI. The fact that there was only a 6% difference between those who exercised and those who didn't wasn't helpful.

16 Do The numbers add up?

The comparison between the "actigraph" and heart rate, oxygen uptake and heart rate are all too low. Although they mention the r, or correlation, they should use r2, which would look even worse. That is, the oxygen uptake, which has aan r=.73, is actually an r2 of about 0.50, which is way below the level needed for statistical significance.

17 Was the statistsical significance assessed?

"p"...

See above note on correlation with the actigraph and the amount of exercise actually done...very poor correlation.
18 What do the main findings mean?

Not much. We don't have a correlation between the movement and the amount of calories burned, such that we could create a graph showing the relationship between the two. A 6% difference between the "more active" and "less active" groups in BMI doesn't seem to meet statistical significance, even cumulated, with only ~80 total compliant subjects.

19 How are the null findings interpreted?

They are not interpreted

20 Are important effects overlooked?

Yes, the effects of puberty on BMI and on exercise levels.

21 What else might influence the observed outcomes?

We have a 7-day snapshot which was then reduced to 3 days within the 7-day window (in order not to lose all the data). We don't know if this corresponds to the amount of activity that girls are experiencing more broadly. If, for example, a girl was having her period during the 7-day period, it could be that she is less active.

How do results compare to other reports?

It is clear from the study/literature review that there is a correlation between BMI and exercise. It is also clear that Hispanics and African-Americans exercise less and have higher BMI. Therefore, there were no surprises and no new questions raised by the study.

23 What are the implications of the study?

The most interesting new work would have been on the impact of puberty on exercise levels. Although the data was taken, it wasn't revealed or explored.

Relationship between Physical Activity and Body Mass Index in Adolescents.

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Physical Activity in Prison the Effects That
Words: 4156 Length: 15 Document Type: Essay

Physical Activity in Prison The effects that prison incarceration has on the health and well-being of inmates are multi-faceted and complex. The prison environment presents stressors not experienced outside of the prison context that can bring about exacerbated health problems and psychological difficulties. Health care delivery in prisons is an important issue, as primary healthcare initiatives designed to focus on disease prevention are required in order to maintain health in the

Body Mass Index Knowledge of Older Adults
Words: 563 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Body Mass Index Knowledge of Older Adults and Motivation to Change This article is authored by Wills, Fehin, and Callen and published in the British Journal of Community Nursing, 16:3. It was selected as an example of a quasi-experimental design. This is a summary of a quasi-experimental design in which multiple measures were used. This study found that older people did not know their own body mass or the fact they

Physical Activity and Overweight
Words: 3090 Length: 7 Document Type: Research Proposal

Weight and Obesity The Prevalence of Overweight and Obesity in Immigrant Women from Sub-Saharan Africa Living in Grande Prairie, Alberta In spite of the increased prevalence of overweight and obesity in the general population, little attention has been paid to immigrant communities, which are at a greater risk of weight gain compared to the majority. This is quite disturbing given the increased rate of migration from low-income countries. Lack of epidemiological data

Physical Activity and Breakfast
Words: 1390 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

breakfast "trumps" all other meals for the top spot." It is widely believed that breakfast is the most important meal of the day. The likelihood of children who always take breakfast having favorable nutrients like carbohydrates and fiber and less cholesterol and fat is higher than is the case among children who seldom take breakfast. Consuming breakfast is also linked to improved overall lifestyle. Children who do not have breakfast

Importance of Physical Activities
Words: 691 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Physical Changes In the past few months my current exercises has changed my physical life dramatically. I have already realized that movement is a medicine when used appropriately and I have managed to significantly develop my ability to listen to the needs of my body and get involved in the type of practice that will be most beneficial to my life. Different physical changes have taken place in my life in

Promoting Physical Activity in Elementary-School
Words: 3150 Length: 9 Document Type: Research Paper

In other words, sports participation may actually discourage some children from being physically active. Another current intervention is to reduce the amount of time that a child spends in front of a screen of some sort. Screens, whether computer screens, video game screens, or television screens all encourage children to be passive recipients of entertainment, rather than active players in a game of some sort. What is fascinating is that

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now