Verified Document

Philosophy Exam Mosca: We Hear Term Paper

Mosca writes: "But the man who is at the head of the state would certainly not be able to govern without the support of a numerous class to enforce respect for his orders and have them carried out; and granting that he can make one individual, or indeed many individuals, in the ruling class feel the weight of his power, he certainly cannot be at odds with the class as a whole or do away with it. Even if that were possible, he would at once be forced to create another class, without the support of which action on his part would be completely paralyzed."

Here, Mosca establishes that the ruler has no love for the teeming masses, but simply needs them to enforce his rule. He would need to create a class to enforce his rule if one did not exist. But other than the ability to enforce his rule, he has no need for the ruled majority.

Michels would agree. Organization is key for Michels, and without the organization of the masses, nothing would actually get done. Of course, it is the rulers job to see to the organization structure, but without the ruled majority's support, the ruling class is up a creek without the proverbial paddle.

Take Michels' words, for instance: "We live in a time in which the idea of cooperation has become so firmly established that even millionaires perceive the necessity of common action. It is easy to understand, then, that organization has become a vital principle in the working class, for in default of it, their success is a priori impossible."

Michels intimates here that even the success of the rulers depends on this same organization and cooperation.

Murcusa's new left acknowledges a paradigm shift in recent years in which the concept of democracy and capitalism has changed entirely. "The rights and liberties which were such vital factors in the origins and earlier stages of industrial society yield to a higher...

Freedom of thought, speech and conscience were - just as free enterprise which they served to promote and protect - essentially critical ideas, designed to replace an obsolescent material and intellectual culture by a more productive and rational one."
However, today, free enterprise reigns supreme in modern democracy and capitalism. The freedoms of speech, thought and conscience are subjugated today to the right to make a living. Those traditional first amendment freedoms do still exist, but they are constantly precluded for the "benefit" of man's comforts. Take the Patriot Act, for instance. Suddenly, our very basic freedoms are being eroded for the protection of our society and the advancement of economic freedoms and benefits.

Marcusa truly believes that the nature of democracy has changed from a theoretical basis to a practical basis. It is no longer important what democracy stands for; it is important only that democracy - through capitalism - leads us to wealth.

Wolfe agrees that there has been a marked shift in the foci of democracy, but he does not believe that the traditional freedoms democracy was meant to protect are completely eroded.

In fact, he believes that the capitalistic tendencies of modern democracies exist side-by-side with the traditional freedoms. The Patriot Act, for Wolfe, would be a simple agreement that in order to save our traditional freedoms, some practical concessions must be made; the freedoms are not being eroded at all for the right to make a profit.

Essentially, both Marcusa and Wolfe agree that times have changed democracy, but they do not agree on the level to which the changes have occurred.

Marcusa is much more doomsday in his new left assessment of our democratic situation now, and Wolfe is much more giving.

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Consumerism Zombies Culture of Consumerism Much of
Words: 1377 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Consumerism Zombies Culture of Consumerism Much of the Western World has been transformed into a Cult of Consumerism and grounded in Fashionable Consumption. As the Limitations of the Natural World become more clear, something must be done to Challenge Consumerism It can be hard to pinpoint a definition for consumerism. However, generally the term is used to describe people that conflate wants and needs. For example, some people might identify the new iPhone

Consumerism in Movies Consumerism Is
Words: 1155 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

"The things you own end up owning you." This quote from Tyler Durden, the protagonist in the movie Fight Club, sums up the message of this movie. The movie, Fight Club takes a critical stand against consumerism. Unlike Sex and the City which accepts consumerism with open arms, embraces and celebrates it, the characters in Fight Club are portrayed to be enlightened, resists and fights consumerism. Tyler Durden especially, the

Consumerism in Mrs. Dalloway Social
Words: 2714 Length: 9 Document Type: Research Paper

And yes -- so she breathed in the earthy garden sweet smell as she stood talking to Miss Pym who owed her help, and thought her kind, for kind she had been years ago; very kind, but she looked older, this year, turning her head from side to side among the irises and roses and nodding tufts of lilac with her eyes half closed, snuffing in, after the street

Consumerism the Story Behind Consumerism
Words: 1165 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Many of the products we see in developed countries seem really cheap. For example, consumer electronics in the United States are cheaper than in many developing countries although the income level is much higher in the United States. So, how do manufacturers provide consumers with cheap products? According to Leonard, manufacturers force workers and Third World natives pay the price. Distributors in giant supermarkets such as Wal-Mart pay their

Consumerism Everybody Consumes. Consumerism, However,
Words: 1421 Length: 5 Document Type: Thesis

To this day, high-end automobile companies make cars by hand for the luxury market, and those vehicles still are demarcations of status. The increased complexity of modern consumer society reflects the increased complexity of our social strata. We are no longer characterized in broad categories of nobility, bourgeoisie, workers and peasants. Our society today has a near infinite number of strata. This has taken consumption as a marker of status

Consumerism, Tragedy, and Patriotism September
Words: 560 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Daniel Harris describes this coping mechanism the "kitschification of Sep. 11." Harris's main argument is that we stopped asking critical questions about the actual reasons of why 9/11 happened. Instead, he says, we resorted to mythologizing history, viewing ourselves as the absolute good and depicting the enemy as the absolute evil whose actions could never be explained with reason. I think, Harris is pretty harsh in his scathing criticism

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now