Verified Document

Philosophy And Law Just Justification: Essay

H.J. McCloskey gives a different account, however. He makes his argument for the Retributive Theory of Justice in opposition to the utilitarian notion of justice, but maintains that the criminal has a right to punishment. He says that the utilitarian approach to justice takes crime to be bad and punishment a necessary ill to stop the bad (crime). In utilitarianism, punishment does not even require a person to be guilty of any crime so long as the punishment deters other crimes to ensure the greatest good in society (thereby sacrificing one for the good of many). McCloskey says that this is not just and that the person being punished must be deserving of that punishment. He says "evils should be distributed according to desert and…the vicious deserve to suffer" (120). His version of the retributive theory, therefore, says that individuals who commit crimes deserve (have a right) to be punished because they deserve to suffer for committing the crime. Further, the criminal made myself unequal by committing the crime, so he deserves to be treated unequally (i.e., unlike other members of society who are, e.g., receiving various freedoms).

Throughout all of the takes of the retributive theory of justice from these philosophers, though, one major theme has remained the same: the offender's right to punishment. Whether the offender is punished because she has punished...

The individual victim of the crime is mostly absent from the theory. Further, society at large is often the object of the victimization and repayment in this theory. A criminal has hurt society; she has, e.g., made the balance of power unequal or has made the social contract less binding by her actions. The victim's rights are not overtly honored by punishment in this theory (indeed, it is not even clear what the victim's actual rights are). However, it does make some sense if it is understood that the victim's rights are bound up in that of society's. For example, if society has a right to equilibrium, the victim is compensated in that restoration of that equilibrium (and the restoration of equilibrium every time anyone is victimized before or after her). Society has an obligation to help the wrongdoer because it helps everyone (be it, e.g., by reinforcing the social contract or by redistributing the balance of benefits or burdens). This is the society that the victim knowingly chose to live in, so in that sense, her rights are being honored as well.
Works Cited

Ezorsky, Gertrude, ed. Philosophical Perspectives on Punishment. Albany: State University of New York Press, 1972.

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Ezorsky, Gertrude, ed. Philosophical Perspectives on Punishment. Albany: State University of New York Press, 1972.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Philosophy - Free Will Throughout
Words: 1831 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Yet, when you go beyond the generalities, it is obvious that this a taking a one size fits all approach when it comes to society. Where, you are assuming that everyone will react the same to the various rules / laws that have been established. However, the pessimists argue that such thinking does not take into account how various experiences and personal relationships will determine someone's morals and values.

Philosophy - Rights and Freedoms
Words: 379 Length: 1 Document Type: Research Proposal

However, in principle, the rules and laws of society merely ensure our freedom from unwanted behavior of others. In many cases, in fact, the particular rules themselves are purely arbitrary, such as the simple rules of the road about stopping on a red signal and going on a green signal because the reverse rule would be just as good. The purpose of the rules of the road are simply to

Philosophy - Ethical Dilemma Weighing
Words: 1510 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

In the event you cannot honestly recommend him as an employee without lying to the new employer, you might consider explaining the truth of the situation to the new employer by telephone while providing your sister with a "file copy" of a the supposed letter addressed to the new employer on your letterhead, being sure to scribble something like "Here you go Sis...I don't feel right about this, but here's

Philosophy the Cosmological Disagreement Can Take Many
Words: 1735 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Philosophy The cosmological disagreement can take many forms, but it works with the basis since the cosmos (universe) exists, there must be a God. How can the information that the universe exist point to any other conclusion than that the universe exists? The first argues that God must exist because He is "The Temporal First Cause" of the universe. The second argues that God must exist because He is "The Ontological

Philosophy and Morality Instructions the Exam Consists
Words: 2703 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Philosophy and Morality INSTRUCTIONS The exam consists essays. Please essays document. Please plagiarize. Be paraphrase verbatim language authors putting quotation marks. You document sources, -text citation ( footnotes) a reference page. Philosophy John Arthur's "Morality, Religion, and Conscience," A concern on the relationship between morality and religion is an ancient argument that continues in philosophy in the present times. The argument is mainly on whether morality emanates from an institution or religious background. Theologians

Philosophy - Economic Ethics the
Words: 1476 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Further Consideration of the Issues: Actually, Singer's use of the term absolute affluence is not perfectly analogous (because the corresponding analog to the conditions of absolute poverty are those of extravagant wealth not working class wealth), but the idea itself is still valid just the same. The point is simply that once human society in part of the world reached the point where even most of those considered "poor" receive

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now