Verified Document

Philosophical Theories Term Paper

Philosophical Legal Theory: Analyzing the Rhetoric in Civil Rights Speeches by King and Wallace While Martin Luther King, Jr. (MLK) is remembered as a hero in the Civil Rights struggle, it is important to keep in mind that, during his time period, he was vilified by many who claimed that his efforts to secure equality for African-Americans were somehow unnatural. One of his most vocal opponents was George Wallace (Wallace), the governor of Alabama, who ran on a platform of opposing integration. This analysis will examine speeches by each of these men, who were diametrically opposed in their approach to Civil Rights: MLK's "I Have a Dream" speech and Wallace's January 14, 1963 inaugural address. In their speeches, both men used the same philosophical and rhetorical appeals to try to forward the moral, legal, and ethical correctness of their respective positions.

The analysis will begin with a discussion of Wallace's speech, because, in many ways, it reflected the prevailing sentiment among white people in the Deep South during that time period. Wallace does not believe that positive law should trump natural law. He believes that whites have a God-given superiority that is part of natural law, and that these divinely given rights should be the source of law,...

Wallace not only suggests that the citizens do not have a duty to obey the law, but openly encourages the people of Alabama to resist, violently if need be, the federal government's attempts to integrate the schools in the area. He also suggests that the Supreme Court justices who made decisions that required integration lacked the power to do so (Wallace, 1963). He makes references to the South rising up and using its power against the tyranny of Washington (Wallace, 1963). However, Wallace does not suggest a wholesale abandonment of the law; he urges not only those in Alabama, but those who sympathize with them to vote to effectuate legal change (Walker, 1963). Wallace makes claims that the law should be used to promote the common good, by providing an example of removing liquor agents from the state of Alabama and using that revenue for things like education (Wallace, 1963). In fact, he goes on to define several areas, such as education, the ability of a farmer to make a living, and concern about the elderly as areas where the government should promote the common good; however, Wallace makes it clear that he is only referring to whites in his assessment of what is good for people. He goes on to cite the riots in…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Rwandan Genocide a Philosophical Theory Jean-Jacques Rousseau's
Words: 1271 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Rwandan genocide a philosophical theory (Jean-Jacques Rousseau's theodicy). How philosophy successful Philosophical Healing It is extremely interesting to note how much relevance philosophy -- and in particular that which was propagated by Jean-Jacques Roussueau -- has with very pragmatic and lethal matters of reality such as the Rwandan genocide. Many of the very ideas and notions that were of extreme importance to Rousseau factored quite substantially into the reasons for the systematic

Nursing Philosophical Theory the Practice
Words: 705 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Nightingale's philosophy demanded a completely clean and sterile environment in order to best provide for a healthy recovery of patients in need. This is also seen in Martinsen's philosophy and the way it approaches nursing care and practice as a meticulous science. However, Nightingale's philosophies presented a passive patient, who did not really engage in their own health care strategies. These patients were not involved in the manipulation of the

Philosophical Schools of Thought
Words: 938 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

International Relations Philosophical Views: International Relations International Relations: Philosophical Views In studying International Relations, there are four philosophical schools of thought used to analyze such studies. Liberalism, realism, radical, and constructivist views have contributed to analyzing this field of study from ancient times to the contemporary era. In its simplest terms, philosophy means the quest for knowledge and truth. It is the quest for wisdom or universal knowledge of the whole. Hence, the

Philosophical Inquiries and the Nature of Science
Words: 1876 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

The nature of science A number of scientists have the feeling that philosophical inquiries are well outdated. They purportedly can handle matters in a better way than their social constructivists counterparts. Philosophers and physicists are very different from each other, especially taking into account what some renown physicist recently commented on philosophy. Stephen Hawking for instance is on a campaign to tarnish philosophers. He might not be so convincing in whatever

Theory Free Market Fairness for the Free
Words: 2230 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Theory Free Market Fairness for the Free New World When choosing between theories of distributive justice, Rawls' "Justice as Fairness" and Tomasi's "Free Market Fairness," Tomasi's theory best expresses the democratic ideal of society as a system of social cooperation between free and equal persons. In the 21st century global economic landscape, a very popular and profitable trend is "going green." Going green includes making improvements to operations of organizations that promote

Philosophical Perspective Action: I Decided
Words: 1103 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

However, when it comes to health-related issues, I do not believe that subjective personal impressions and feelings can influence one's ethical decision-making. The evidence is clear that smoking is harmful to the smoker, and also to the person who inhales second-hand smoke. Additionally, we were in my parents' home. I know that they have hard and fast rules about smoking on their property. My friend took a different point-of-view: he acquiesced

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now