Verified Document

Philosophical Or Moral Issue Faxes Only: Evidence Term Paper

Philosophical or Moral Issue Faxes Only: Evidence There Is No God and the Problem of Evil and Suffering: A Response

Philosophical or Moral Issue Paper

Arguments, both for and against the existence and "goodness" of God as outlined in the readings fall short of convincing because they are based in unsupported assumptions. Chief among these assumptions is the definition of evil and good; and a narrow construction of pain, suffering, and death.

In both Evidence There Is No God and The Problem of Evil and Suffering: A Response each author seeks to make his point by employing the strategy of knocking down shallowly developed and diluted arguments of the opposition. Each essay spends more print describing the conclusions of its syllogisms than it does showing the veracity of the assumptions upon which those conclusions are drawn. In other words, there is a lot of jumping to conclusions and little establishing of solid logical foundations.

Both authors hint at their own assumptions regarding the nature of God or at least their interpretation of the Judeo-Christian ethos that forms the backdrop for their comments. The rationality of the conclusions all hinge upon the rationality of the assumptions. These attributes of God, or these doctrines concerning the nature of God, require deeper exploration for the conclusions to hold up.

For example, the anonymous author of Evidence There Is No God, begins his essay with a story about a baby dying in a house fire (a situation he describes...

He argues that a good God should have and would have saved the child from death and the associated pain. This assumes that both death and pain are bad and antithetical to the purpose of God. At first glance, this may seem reasonable, but a more thoughtful consideration would reveal that this standard would require God to employ a standard not even acceptable by human reckoning.
Why should we assume that death is bad or symptomatic of evil? Death is the certain end and culmination of the life of every human being (setting aside theological arguments about the extraordinary end to the life of Jesus or rare cases like Elijah or Moses as recorded in the Bible). If God has any intent about our existence, it surely involves death. Moreover, if we consider that death is the doorway, which we must pass through to return to the presence of God, then death takes on an even greater significance from God's perspective. It would be reasonable to assume that just as we long for the return of our loved ones in this life, God would long for the return of his children and that, in death, what we see as sorrowful parting, He sees as a joyous reunion.

Pain and suffering are also assumed to be synonymous with evil. The author clearly feels that no good can come from these discomforts. Yet humanity cannot even agree on this standard. Just the other day, I saw a man leaving a health club wearing a tee shirt that read, "pain is weakness leaving the body." Now this may be nothing more than cocksure arrogance,…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Moral Philosophy First Reading: Why
Words: 3744 Length: 9 Document Type: Term Paper

This would make the resource pool of charity large enough for the deprived sections of the society. 2): On the issue of morality Singer in his writing refers about the Brazilian film Central Station in which Dora, a poor retired school teacher gets an opportunity to earn $1,000 by handing over a 9-year-old homeless boy to an address where the boy will be fostered by wealthy foreigners. She hands over

Moral Relativism Is a Point-Of-View,
Words: 1459 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Then morality is relative, not absolute (Kreeft) Weaknesses One weakness of moral relativism consists of the consequences of not having moral constraints (Kreeft 2003). Correct or good morality, if valid, should always have good consequences. Incorrect or bad morality should always have bad consequences. The fact is that all wrong or immoral acts and attitudes bring on "good" or pleasant feelings. Moral relativism has never produced people worthy of praise. It

Philosophical Perspective Action: I Decided
Words: 1103 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

However, when it comes to health-related issues, I do not believe that subjective personal impressions and feelings can influence one's ethical decision-making. The evidence is clear that smoking is harmful to the smoker, and also to the person who inhales second-hand smoke. Additionally, we were in my parents' home. I know that they have hard and fast rules about smoking on their property. My friend took a different point-of-view: he acquiesced

Legislating Morality in America
Words: 5191 Length: 16 Document Type: Research Paper

Legislating Morality The ideas of Thomas Hobbes, the influential English philosopher who lived in the late 1500s to middle 1600s, are still considered important today. Hobbes is best remembered for his ideas on political philosophy. While Hobbes throughout his life championed the idea of absolutism for the sovereign he also is responsible for many of the fundamentals of Western political thought such as equality of men, individual rights, and the idea

Ethical Theory and Moral Practice
Words: 4260 Length: 15 Document Type: Dissertation or Thesis complete

Ethical Theory & Moral Practice Debates about theory and practice are ancient. Each generation considers the dynamics that surround issues about the interdependency of theory and praxis to be uniquely challenging. Complexity is a variable closely linked with knowledge. As science has added layer upon layer of knowledge, decision-making dilemmas have been confounded by new and staggering concomitant factors. In concert, theoretical frameworks for social science disciplines have been adapted to

Moral and Legal Questions of Stem Cell
Words: 3247 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Moral and Legal Questions of Stem Cell Research Stem cell research is an experimental, and research-based study as to methods of repairing the human body. By introducing stem cells into a damaged, or degenerating area of the body, the medical profession hopes to prompt the body to regrow healthy tissue, and repair the damage. Degenerative diseases, such as Parkinson's disease, or macular degeneration of a patient's eye retina are conditions

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now