Verified Document

Performance Management Total Quality Management Term Paper

No quantity of concern or talent in workmanship can conquer fundamental errors in the system. TQM proponents have been swift to censure performance assessment methods which are based on the supposition that the individual employee is chiefly in control of his or her own performance level. (Designing Performance Management Systems for Total Quality Implementation) Hence Deming would assert that a mean performance level merely reveals a system's complete ability. Differences on that performance level within plus or minus three standard variations are system-based and haphazard in nature. It follows that a second primary theme of total quality to attain a stable process is that first recognizing and removing the special reasons of variation can only enhance a process. Then centering the concentration on the general, system-based factors that affect performance can enhance the whole system. One of Deming's main worry is that management, through mechanisms like performance assessment, tries to react to most differences as if it were due to special reasons rather than general reasons. (Designing Performance Management Systems for Total Quality Implementation)

Performance measurements in TQM organizations recommend that it must be broadened to incorporate ideas like TQM Performance assessment, the measurement of team performance, information technology challenge, clients-suppliers contentment and association, and incentive and acknowledgment. (Performance Measures: The Link with Organizational Strategy) the functioning of 108 firms were studied by Easton and Jarrell that appear to have made an earnest and victorious attempt to put into operation TQM in the most of their businesses. They calculated performance starting at the probable time when firms in their test started sincere attempts to apply TQM. They discovered that these organizations excelled a sample of standard firms by an average of 16.05% at the end of year five with the majority of the improvements taking place in years four and five. The National Institute of Standards and Technology, which gave out the Baldrige award, evaluated the functioning of widely traded Baldrige award winners against the S&P 500. The report found that throughout December 1, 1998, the publicly trade Baldrige award winners from 1988 to 1997 excelled the S&P 500 by 2.6 to 1. (the Financial Justification of TQM) study by Wm. Schiemann and Associates done in 1996 conducted a national survey of a section of executives concluded that measurement-managed companies, particularly those that measured employee performance excelled those that downplayed measurement. 122 organizations that were making $27 million to $50 billion is sales were studied for the research. A higher percentage of measurement-managed companies were recognized as industry masters, as monetarily in the top third of their industry, and as effectively organizing their change efforts. This last part means that measurement-managed companies are likely to predict the future and are liable to continue in a leadership position in a quickly varying atmosphere. The research studied performance in six tactical performance sections considered vital for enduring victory: Financial performance, Operating efficiency, Customer satisfaction, and employee performance, Innovation/Change, Community/Environment. It was discovered from the result that employee measurement is the major measurement area sorting victorious from less victorious organization. The study says that thriving industry leaders merely do a superior work than non-leaders at calculating their labor force and this is where real change is succeeded or misplaced. (Performance Management: Impacts and Trends)

As per the study, there are four methods that donate to the achievement of measurement-managed companies: Study data point strongly to four mechanisms that contribute to the success of measurement-managed companies: Co-operation on strategy: Ninety-three percent of the measurement-managed firms accounted agreement amongst top management on tactics, against only 37% of the non-measurement-managed organizations. Clarity of communication: good quality contact demands an understandable note, and measurement offers a familiar language for communication. Concentration and alignment of efforts: Measurement-managed companies accounted more often that unit performance measures were connected to strategic company measures and that personal performance measures were connected to unit measures. Culture of the Organization: when evaluated with non-measurement-managed organizations, measurement-managed companies more often accounted well-built cultural elements, such as teamwork and collaboration among the management team, a greater level of employees self-observing their own feat, and a better eagerness to take chance. (Performance Management: Impacts and Trends)

In conclusion, performance measurement is an essential building block of TQM and a total quality organization. Performance measurement plays a vital role in the sequence of infinite improvement in: Recognizing and paving the way for development against organizational objectives; Recognizing prospects for enhancement and Contrasting performance against both internal and external standards. (Measurement: (www.dti.gov.uk/)Every type of performance measurement systems based on Total Quality Management should give obvious connections between PM, benchmarking, and quality costing. In TQM organizations,...

The dissimilarities between service and manufacturers are more obvious in non-TQM organizations. Manufacturers employ measurement at the company and procedural/technical levels and benchmarking more than services. Non-TQM services employ measurement more than manufacturers for performance management, objective alignment, continuous improvement, and prospect recognition. TQM manufacturers mainly employ measurement more extensively for measuring process and personal performance, objective alignment, continuous improvement, benchmarking and prospect recognition. (Validation of a Model of Total Quality Management Performance Measurement Systems in the UK)
Both TQM and non-TQM manufacturers employ measurement in the same way for evaluating company performance on the whole and team performance. TQM service employs measurement more extensively than non-TQM services for evaluating complete company and procedural/technical performance and benchmarking, but likewise for the further likely applications. Compared to non-TQM organizations, TQM organizations employ PM in performance appraisal, performance management, and relating people and procedures more extensively. With regard to team management, incentive and acknowledgment, both TQM and non-TQM organizations employ PM in comparable extents. Manufacturers and service employ PM for all methods in comparable extents. TQM manufacturers employ PM for all uses more extensively than non-TQM manufacturers; anticipate for incentive and acknowledgment, which is more regular at non-TQM manufacturers. TQM services employ PM more often for all uses barring team management, for which PM is employed more often by non-TQM services. (Validation of a Model of Total Quality Management Performance Measurement Systems in the UK)

The general deductions at the procedural/technical level are that TQM organizations are more probable to deal with and evaluate process performance, and employ a broader array of measures of performance than non-TQM organizations. There seems to be some measurement of suppleness, novelty and time related performance, quality, delivery and customer contentment continue to be the most extensively used performance measures. It is probable for non-TQM organizations to build up efficient PM systems. The kind of PM systems at TQM organizations is unlike that in non-TQM organizations. Also, it seems that TQM organizations are more inventive and elastic, and more probable to build up a genuinely efficient PM system than non-TQM organizations. Specifically, the necessity to combine planned goals, customer needs, process capability and personal participation is perceived as essential for successful PM systems based on Total Quality Management. (Validation of a Model of Total Quality Management Performance Measurement Systems in the UK)

References

CastaA±eda-Mendez, Kicab. (1999) Performance Measurement in Health Care. Retrieved at http://www.qualitydigest.com/may99/html/body_health.html[Accessed 11 December, 2004]

Chapman, O' Mara; Karayan, Hyland. (1998) Performance Measures: The Link with Organizational Strategy. Fall. Retrieved from www.csupomona.edu/~jis/1998/omara.pdf[Accessed 11 December, 2004]

Daniel, Meade. The Art and Science of Measurement: The Nature of Indicators on the Balanced Scorecard. Retrieved at http://www.bettermanagement.com/library/library.aspx?libraryid=10970&pagenumber=1[Accessed 11 December, 2004]

Measurement. Retrieved at http://www.dti.gov.uk/quality/pdfs/sections/Performance.pdf[Accessed 11 December, 2004]

Performance Management: Impacts and Trends. Retrieved from Retrieved at http://www.exinfm.com/pdffiles/pm.pdf[Accessed 11 December, 2004]

Performance Measurement for Government & Nonprofit Organizations.

Retrieved at http://www.evaluatorsinstitute.com/performance_measurement.htm[Accessed 11 December, 2004]

Pun, K.F; Lau, C.W. (2003) Integration of total quality management and performance measurement in government departments: an empirical study in Hong Kong. International Journal of Business Performance Management. Volume: 5; No: 4; pp: 316-335. Retrieved from https://www.inderscience.com/search/index.php?action=record&rec_id=3815&prevQuery=&ps=10&m=or[Accessed 11 December, 2004]

Quality Performance Measurements of the EPC Process: Current Practices. Retrieved at http://construction-institute.org/services/catalog/more/sd79_more.cfm[Accessed 11 December, 2004]

Sinclair, Hsin; Chang, Dave a. (2002) Validation of a Model of Total Quality Management Performance Measurement Systems in the UK. May. Retrieved from www.management.ncku.edu.tw/apmr/doc/apmr-journal/7-3-5.doc [Accessed 11 December, 2004]

Singhal, Vinod; Hendricks, Kevin. (1999) the Financial Justification of TQM.

Center for Quality of Management Journal. Volume 8, Number 1. Spring. Retrieved at http://cqmextra.cqm.org/cqmjournal.nsf/reprints/rp09600[Accessed 11 December, 2004]

Waldman, David a. Designing Performance Management Systems for Total Quality Implementation. Retrieved from www.ctu.edu.vn/centers/cfl/teaching/ebooks/5.pdf[Accessed 11 December, 2004]

Sources used in this document:
References

CastaA±eda-Mendez, Kicab. (1999) Performance Measurement in Health Care. Retrieved at http://www.qualitydigest.com/may99/html/body_health.html[Accessed 11 December, 2004]

Chapman, O' Mara; Karayan, Hyland. (1998) Performance Measures: The Link with Organizational Strategy. Fall. Retrieved from www.csupomona.edu/~jis/1998/omara.pdf[Accessed 11 December, 2004]

Daniel, Meade. The Art and Science of Measurement: The Nature of Indicators on the Balanced Scorecard. Retrieved at http://www.bettermanagement.com/library/library.aspx?libraryid=10970&pagenumber=1[Accessed 11 December, 2004]

Measurement. Retrieved at http://www.dti.gov.uk/quality/pdfs/sections/Performance.pdf[Accessed 11 December, 2004]
Performance Management: Impacts and Trends. Retrieved from Retrieved at http://www.exinfm.com/pdffiles/pm.pdf[Accessed 11 December, 2004]
Retrieved at http://www.evaluatorsinstitute.com/performance_measurement.htm[Accessed 11 December, 2004]
Pun, K.F; Lau, C.W. (2003) Integration of total quality management and performance measurement in government departments: an empirical study in Hong Kong. International Journal of Business Performance Management. Volume: 5; No: 4; pp: 316-335. Retrieved from https://www.inderscience.com/search/index.php?action=record&rec_id=3815&prevQuery=&ps=10&m=or[Accessed 11 December, 2004]
Quality Performance Measurements of the EPC Process: Current Practices. Retrieved at http://construction-institute.org/services/catalog/more/sd79_more.cfm[Accessed 11 December, 2004]
Center for Quality of Management Journal. Volume 8, Number 1. Spring. Retrieved at http://cqmextra.cqm.org/cqmjournal.nsf/reprints/rp09600[Accessed 11 December, 2004]
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

TQM Theory in Airport Passenger Handling
Words: 1443 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Total Quality Management Theory Total Quality Management Development How Total Quality Management (TQM) Theory can be applied to improve the airport passenger handling Total Quality Management (TQM) specifically deals with work process and people. Implementation of TQM calls for team work and employee involvement. All operations, suppliers, and customers have to be involved. Besides, it also calls for performance measurement. TQM is normally implemented by business organizations to satisfy its customers. It improves

Total Quality Management for Purposes
Words: 1291 Length: 4 Document Type: Thesis

If these three factors are present, there is also a high probability that there is a hospital-wide TQM initiative already in place. The research results state that many academic teaching hospitals do not have as high of a level of performance using TQM as non-teaching hospitals. This variation could be explained by the significantly different process bases in hospitals where there is instruction and treatment happening at the same

Total Quality Management and the Influence of Transformational Leaders...
Words: 1709 Length: 6 Document Type: Research Proposal

Leadership in quality management systems All over the world, the relationship between leadership and quality management systems has been studied by researchers. As quality management systems focus on refining company policies in order to meet customer needs, the role of leadership in that system is one that many have analyzed. Leaders play a tremendous role in a company’s success; therefore, it stands to reason that they should share a similar role

Total Quality Management in Toyota the Production
Words: 1917 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Total Quality Management in Toyota The production system of Toyota otherwise known as Toyota Management Systems (TMS) gives its adopters the ability to double their production in half the time, half the expense with half the problems and inventory in a fraction. TMS is no comparison to 'just' a production system. It is a three-innovation-combination model comprising of the policy of deployment (hoshin kanri), total quality management, and production just in

Total Quality Management Is an
Words: 858 Length: 3 Document Type: Research Paper

D.). This largely contributed to the development of today's total quality management concept as quality excellence has become a standard for business operations. Principles of Total Quality Management: As one of the main concepts in today's business operations, total quality management is based on several important principles including: Customer Focus: Being customer focused is the main principle behind total quality management because customers are the key determinants of the level of quality. Despite of

Total Quality Management or TQM Is Definitely
Words: 3260 Length: 11 Document Type: Essay

Total Quality Management or TQM is definitely an integrative administration structure targeted at consistently enhancing the output of products, services, items, procedures and general manufacturing to attain and exceed customer demands and anticipation. It had been an administrative approach initially produced for enhancing the structure of manufacturing. However, it's lately proven its significance in operating industries as well for enhancing the standard and services information and client satisfaction that has

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now