Verified Document

Perception Of Kindergarten Teachers And Staff On Grade Retention Research Paper

Problem Statement A major problem in the US schooling system is the reluctance towards change and letting go of past practices that have proven to be ineffective and counter-productive. One such practice is grade retention, which can negatively influence not just student attendance but also behaviors and attitudes. Current research confirms the popularity of grade retention in K-12 in the US education system. While, accurate data on student retention rates is unavailable, grade retention perception amid school staff and teachers is contentious due to varied results (Moore, 2017; Clotfelter, Hemelt & Ladd, 2016). In line with Jimerson (2001; as cited in Barata et al, 2015) along with Shepard and Smith (1990; as cited in Barata et al, 2015) grade retention happens to be an ineffective tool and an unconstructive teaching strategy. They add that the changes at state and federal level together with several regulations to cut this practice down, have nudged neither the perceptions nor the practice. Other countries too have found similar barriers to change. For instance, researchers from the National Center for Education Statistic (2009; Barata et al., 2015) found, “In Europe, retention rates vary significantly between countries, from 2% to 22.4% in primary education and in the United States, about 10% of students are retained between kindergarten and eighth grade” (p. 149).

Moreover, research has proven that retention has negatively influenced students not just in their academic achievements but also their social life. This is especially true when one compares their data with their promoted peers (Shields-Proctor, 2017). Moreover, the problem spreads from struggling students at the kindergarten level, to teachers who also struggle to meet rigorous demands and standards of accountability. In a recent study, Repko-Erwin (2017) found, “Kindergarten teachers...

70). Add to this the financial aspect, as grade retention policies impact not just families but also communities that have higher grade retention levels (Lynch, 2014). Absent from the literature is a comprehensive understanding of teachers school staff and administrators perspectives on grade retention. This knowledge might provide significant insights in research on this gap in practice (Mawhinney, Irby, & Roberts, 2016). Closing the gap will require ways to close the readiness gap so that no children enter kindergarten significantly behind their peers (Washington State School Directors’ Association, n.d.).
Purpose

The purpose of this qualitative case-study is to understand the perceptions of teachers, school staff and administrators on kindergarten retention. Grade retention continues to be a key strategy adopted by teachers for failing students (Anastasiou, Papachristou & Diakidoy, 2017; Hughes et al., 2017). A deeper and broader understanding of school staff and teacher’s perspectives on grade retention will lead to a profound understanding of this practice. Thereafter, possible strategies can be drafted to minimize this practice. The target population for this study will be ten educators: four kindergarten teachers, two administrators, one guidance counselor, and three related staff members from (please insert the location or name of the school). After the interviews, parents of retained students will be given a consultation to inform them about the school’s grade retention policy and procedures.

Significance

The qualitative case study is significant because it will offer a…

Sources used in this document:

Repko-Erwin, M. E. (2017). Was kindergarten left behind? Examining U. S. kindergarten as the new first grade in the wake of No Child Left Behind. Global Education Review, 4(2), 1-17. Retrieved from: http://ger.mercy.edu/index.php/ger/article/view/324

Shields-Proctor, C. A. (2017). The relationship between mandatory 3rd grade retention and school performance in Florida. Retrieved from: http://search-proquest.com/openview/36c008f0662090c5d3f68569cc016/1?pqorigsite&cbi=18750&


Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Effects of Mathematics Instruction in English on ELL Second Grade...
Words: 3174 Length: 12 Document Type: Term Paper

Mathematics Instruction in English on ELL Second Grade Students J. Elizabeth Estevez Educ2205I-Content Research Seminar Mathematics is a powerful tool for interpreting the world. Research has shown that for children to learn how to use mathematics to organize, understand, compare, and interpret their experiences, mathematics must be connected to their lives. Such connections help students to make sense of mathematics and view it as relevant. There has, however, been controversy with regard

Reading Comprehension Among Middle School
Words: 1667 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

The Title I reading instructor will become familiar with the Plato Learning content library. The Title 1 reading instructor will begin supplementing classroom instruction with the mini classroom lab using software from Plato Learning. Title I reading instructor will assess classroom performance and modify lab use accordingly. The STAR Reading test results will be evaluated. Survey results on student attitudes towards reading and learning will be compared to April 2007 results. The state standard scores

Pre-School What Are the Benefits of Having
Words: 3102 Length: 9 Document Type: Research Proposal

Pre-School What Are the Benefits of Having Children Attend Pre-School Prior to Kindergarten? Books This report covers the benefit of sending children to pre-school before kindergarten. Literature review is used to explore the research existing in this field. It will help us to understand what effect pre-school has on children. Such programs are also discussed in the paper which is conducting training for preschoolers for their development. This paper not only covers

Teaching Is One of the
Words: 17626 Length: 64 Document Type: Research Proposal

3.4 Finally, I am interested in whether or not there is a trickle-down effect from leftist or rightist politics style at the provincial and federal levels. 1.3 Objectives 1.3.1 There are two major objectives for this research. The first is to compare the level of motivation among secondary school teachers under the Vancouver British Columbia School District in Canada by their socio-demographic and organizational factors. My hypothesis in advance of investigating this is

Parental Involvement and Student Academic Achievement
Words: 1450 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Proposal

Parent Involvement and Student Achievement Parental Involvement and Student Academic Achievement TA administration and staff believe schools are seeing a decrease in parental involvement as students enter high school. Research conducted by the Kentucky Department of Education (KDE) Dropout Prevention Resource Guide (2008) has demonstrated the positive effects of parental involvement in schools. Parental involvement in the eighth grade had a strong positive effect on the grade point average of 10th graders (Keith,

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now