Verified Document

Pbis Lit Positive Behavioral Intervention And Support Essay

PBIS Lit Positive Behavioral Intervention and Support (PBIS) in Elementary Schools and in Impoverished Settings

Extensive research has been carried out examining the design and implementation of Positive Behavioral Intervention and Supports (PBIS) programs in schools, districts, and on even larger state scales. The research is highly consistent in finding positive effects on behavior and learning through the successful implementation of PBIS programs, however there are significant variations found in implementation schemes and in the environmental effects on the success of PBIS programs and interventions. Less research specifically pertaining to the implementation of PBIS on Title I elementary schools is available, however the literature that has been produced in this area clearly suggests difficulties in implementation but some measure of success when programs can be successfully designed and carried out.

There are currently approximately ten-thousand or more schools that have implemented PBIS programs (based on the latest data available and ongoing growth trends in the prevalence of these programs), which exist as school-wide and universal staff behavioral programs meant to encourage and elicit desired behaviors from students (Bradshaw et al., 2008; Bradshaw et al., 2010). Organizational health, a metric that includes assessments of resource influence, staff affiliation, and other elements, has been found to be a strong mediating factor in the degree of success found in the implementation of PBIS programs in elementary schools (Bradshaw et al., 2008). This could have significant negative effects for impoverished schools.

Program fidelity has been identified as a specific issue in the successful implementation of PBIS programs in schools, with a lack of staff/instructor fidelity to the specific tasks and approaches recommended by program leading to reduced positive outcomes or effects at all (Bradshaw et al., 2010). Using a longitudinal study of disciplinary measures such as student suspensions and office discipline referrals as means of determining how effectively behavior in the student population had been modified by PBIS programs, and what the relationship between program fidelity and program effectiveness is, it has been demonstrated that high fidelity is associated with less disciplinary action required, and with staff training an essential part of achieving high fidelity (Bradshaw et al., 2010). Again, Title I schools would be at a disadvantage with fewer resources to commit to training programs for instructors and instructors that tend to be more overworked (Barnes, 2002).

Looking beyond simple program fidelity confirms the conclusion that training is of utmost importance in achieving the benefits of PBIS programs, which is encouraging in that it provides concrete means for implementing these programs but discouraging from a resource point-of-view (Bradshaw et al., 2008a). More specifically, training and behavior support in the area of developing strategies for defining goals and teaching expectations has been shown to be effective in producing positive outcomes largely independently from issues of response to violations and discipline (Bradshaw et al., 2008a). While still requiring additional resources this does provide some suggestion as to how limited resources can best be allocated.

Rolling out training on a state-wide basis has also been shown to be highly effective in terms of achieving high levels of PBIS program implementation, adherence, and benefit, and can be far more resource efficient than a school-by-school implementation and training program (Horner et al., 2009). Though PBIS programs must be implemented at the institutional level and require full-school but not necessarily system-wide adoption and implementation, system-wide PBIS initiatives show a great deal of overall and institution-specific success (Horner et al., 2009). Lower disciplinary action needs and a universal increase in PBIS practices and expected outcomes was observed in two states, Hawaii and Illinois, that implemented system-wide PBIS programs (Honer et al., 2009). Greater resource efficiency on a state-wide level and the state provision of training personnel and resources would have an enormous impact on the ability of Title I schools to effectively implement PBS programs.

Maryland has also implemented a largely successful and comprehensively researched PBIS program, though it has not been implemented on a truly state-wide basis as of yet (Bradshaw & Pas, 2011). The extensive study conducted on this program and its effects have allowed provided a great deal of insight into the specific situation in the state and broader implications for general PBIS program implementation. Distinctions between certain district- and school-level factors influencing the level of program adoption and success have been identified, with implementation quality apparently tied only to school-level issues (Bradshaw & Pas, 2011). This, again, does not bode well for specific resource-strapped institutions.

Initially, the Maryland program seemed to show greater promise, with a higher level of implementation than witnessed in subsequent years...

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

Assessments of the program's structure and efficacy during its first years were quite optimistic, suggesting that the school-level issues and factors noted in subsequent research might be the primary cause of ultimate adoption/rejection decisions and program quality when it comes to PBIS programs (Barrett et al., 2008; Bradshaw & Pas, 2011). State resources might not be as effective in schools with lower levels of resources and serving lower-income communities even if programs are well designed, then.
In an attempt to address certain of the issues and problems identified in the Maryland PBIS implementation program, researchers have looked into the basic impetus and foundation of the program, namely a partnership between the Maryland State Department of Education, Sheppard Pratt Health System, and Johns Hopkins University (Bradshaw et al., 2012). Though there were certain complications that might have adversely affected the program, on balance the partnership was seen as largely successful, and effectively promoted significant adoption of the PBIS initiative through clear evidenced-based practices and adequate training processes (Bradshaw et al., 2012). How such partnerships can better drive institution-specific success is not examined, however, providing no assistance to schools facing specific troubles.

Specific institutional needs and the requirements of at-risk student populations have been identified as problematic in other literature on the topic, as well (Debnam et al., 2012). While most schools involved in a large-scale system-wide PBIS program showed large levels of compliance and the expected effects of successful program implementation, no schools achieved Tier 1 performance targets, and schools with more intensive needs were found to show far lower levels of successful adoption or the effects of program implementation in those schools that were able to achieve some degree of operational success with the PBIS program (Debnam et al., 2012). Demographic analysis specifically showed that schools serving impoverished communities and populations are at a severe detriment when it comes to the implementation and proper success of PBIS programs (Debnam et al., 2012).

Bradshaw et al. (2009) have also identified a somewhat cyclical and an unquestionably co-influential relationship between organizational health and PBIS adoption and success, with similar implications for schools serving at-risk and low-income communities. High levels of initial organizational health have been recognized as strong indicators of successful PBIS program implementation, and low-organizational health is associated both with increased difficulty in implementation and lower success rates (Bradhshaw et al., 2009). This research also showed, however, that organizations are able to improve organizational health through the implementation of PBIS programs, and especially so for organizations that begin with lower than typical organizational health (Bradshaw et al., 2009).

While major improvements in discipline and behavioral issues have been seen in every piece of research examining successful PBIS implementations, there has not been success in all desired levels of school and environmental change with the adoption of these programs (Ryoo & Hong, 2011). Accountability for instructors and for schools was hypothesized by many to be positively influenced by PBIS implementation, however empirical examinations of schools before and after successful PBIS adoption shows no statistical difference in measurable levels of accountability for either individual staff members or institutions as a whole (Ryoo & Hong, 2011). Accountability also does not appear to have an impact on PBIS implementation success, so the additional oversight and accountability associated with many Title I schools serving impoverished communities will not serve to in any way to balance the disadvantages these schools experience in terms of pure resource control (Ryoo & Hong, 2011).

Schools at a resource disadvantage that also serve significant populations of students with emotional or behavioral disorders are faced with an especially difficult challenge when it comes to successful PBIS program implementation (Lewis et al., 2010). Though PBIS programs have been demonstrated to be effective in dealing with emotional and behavioral disorders in a proactive and preemptive fashion that reduces disciplinary interruptions and enhances the learning environment, program design and adoption is made difficult by both political and financial constraints (Lewis et al., 2010). Achieving real success in this regard involves a series of abstract and concrete obstacles, then, all of which increase for schools in poorer communities.

Examining the issue of impoverished schools and PBIS program implementation from a more positive perspective, the literature shows that disciplinary and learning improvements go hand in hand and are especially significant in…

Sources used in this document:
References

Barnes, C. (2002). Standards reform in high-poverty schools. New York: Teacher's College Press.

Barrett, S., Bradshaw, C. & Lewis-Palmer, T. (2008). Maryland Statewide PBIS Initiative: Systems, Evaluation, and Next Steps. Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions 10(2): 105-14.

Bradshaw, C., Koth, C., Bevans, K.,, Ialongo, N. & Leaf, P. (2008). The impact of school-wide positive behavioral interventions and supports (PBIS) on the organizational health of elementary schools. School Psychology Quarterly 23(4): 462-73.

Bradshaw, C., Reinke, W., Brown, L., Bevans, K. & Leaf, P. (2008a). Implementation of school-wide Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports (PBIS) in elementary schools: observations from a randomized trial. Education and Treatment of Children 31(1).
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Social Issue Alcohol Drugs Consider a Social
Words: 1118 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Social issue alcohol drugs consider a social issue interested. It human freedom, sexuality, deviance, crime, social mobility, poverty, education, aging, similar issues. Select a specific social issue investigate assignment. Social issue: Drug abuse The social problem of drug addiction is a long-standing one, yet the causes of addiction and the best way to treat addiction still remain difficult questions to answer. One contentious issue pertains to whether addiction is a 'crime' or

Social Issues Are Sometimes Affected by the
Words: 1897 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Social issues are sometimes affected by the environmental and economic issues, but they often have a life of their own. The social environment is comprised of a number of factors, including demographics, trends, mores and norms, and social factors that affect the market such as health, education and social mobility (MindTools, 2014). Those factors will affect the economic power of consumers, but also other things like knowledge that will affect

Social Problem of Homelessness Teaching Social Issues
Words: 584 Length: 2 Document Type: Research Paper

Social Problem of Homelessness Teaching Social Issues Homelessness is a social problem that is prevalent around the world and particularly in the United States of America. Homelessness has existed for much of "civilized" human history, with sharp increases in eras of history such as the Industrial Revolution. In the last two centuries, homelessness and changed and expanded, though there remains a significant amount of research to be done. Professionals who study and

Social Issues Surrounding Migrants in
Words: 3453 Length: 12 Document Type: Assessment

Other issues arise in the clustering of immigrants around the major urban areas, thus pulling to much from the grid, taxing the already marginalized system, and allowing an unprescedented demand in new housing. Experts acknolwedge that this increased level of housing needs cause even short-term visias to now be suspect in contributed to the gridlock. Additionally one of the conundrums that support a change in policy focuses on the type

Social Issues and the Myth of Luck
Words: 708 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Social Issues and the Myth of Luck in "Rocking- Horse Winner" by DH Lawrence Rocking- Horse Winner" is a short story by DH Lawrence that illustrates the importance of social status and the myth of luck in Paul's family, as well as in the society that their family live in. The short story deals with these two important themes, and each theme is dependent on each other, since it is evident,

Social Issue of Body Image
Words: 2588 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Indeed, if there is only one type of beautiful person, it contributes to increased insecurity in women who happen to be a different shape or size from the "ideal" women perpetuated in the popular culture. According to Dank, Norton, Olds and Olive (1996), there has a lengthy association between dolls and ideal proportions, a relationship going back to Greek times. For example, pre-18th century dolls were manufactured so as to

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now