Verified Document

Pandemic Fears And Contemporary Quarantine: Research Proposal

To meet substantive due process, a public health intervention must be based on a public health necessity, an effective intervention, have a demonstrable means-end connection, be proportionate to the threat involved, and be the least restrictive means of accomplishing the goal. In addition, Daubert explains the parameters of the procedural due process. Due process in a quarantine situation does not always involve a judicial hearing, but it must contain the following elements: notice to the affected individual, an opportunity to contest the government's action, access to legal counsel, and a final decision that is subject to review by a court of law. She includes with a discussion of how due process came to be applied in situations of quarantine, by viewing due process as a continuum, with infected individual on one end of the spectrum and the exposed individual on another. She thinks that due process should increase as the likelihood of infection decreases. Finally, she looks at the current procedural and substantive due process framework might work in the event of a large-scale quarantine. To do so, she discusses the due process required in involuntary mental health commitments and how that might translate to a quarantine scenario. In part three, Daubert discusses the current quarantine procedural due process requirements at both the federal and state levels. In December 2003, states were encouraged to review their public health laws, and to adopt model acts to update state quarantine procedures. The two model acts suggested include the Model State Emergency Health Powers Act and the Turning Point Model State Public Health Act. These new acts were motivated by the increased threat of bioterrorism in a post 9-11 world. These acts recognize...

It also limits quarantines to a 30-day period, though a public health authority may seek a continuance o the original quarantine. Federal law provides for a 3-day provisional quarantine of individuals without an order. After three-days, the person must receive a written quarantine order and can protest the quarantine through a writ of habeas corpus.
Daubert concludes with a discussion of ways that due process guarantees can be protected if the country is faced with a large-scale quarantine. First, she recognizes that in a pandemic some people will be denied due process. Access to the courts must be increased so that impacted people can seek review. There also needs to be a remote process for review so that impacted individuals can seek judicial review without risking spread of the disease to court personnel. States are encouraged to develop Bench Books, which would detail the appropriate standards for quarantines, because many judges are unfamiliar with quarantine law. Finally, due to the fact that quarantine proceedings can involve a large number of people, jurisdictions should have plans to deal with these large numbers, including the appointment of temporary judges, if necessary.

References

CDC. (2005). Fact sheet on legal authorities for isolation/quarantine. Retrieved March 8, 2009 from Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Web site: http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/sars/factsheetlegal.htm

Daubert, M. (2007). Comment: Pandemic fears and contemporary quarantine: Protecting liberty through a continuum of due process rights. 54 Buffalo L. Rev 1299.

Sources used in this document:
References

CDC. (2005). Fact sheet on legal authorities for isolation/quarantine. Retrieved March 8, 2009 from Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Web site: http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/sars/factsheetlegal.htm

Daubert, M. (2007). Comment: Pandemic fears and contemporary quarantine: Protecting liberty through a continuum of due process rights. 54 Buffalo L. Rev 1299.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Residents in Edmonton General Continuing Care Center EGCCC In Edmonton...
Words: 3750 Length: 13 Document Type: Case Study

Nursing: The Impact of Physical Inactivity in Long-Term Care Settings during Covid- Pandemic- Case Study of Residents in Edmonton General Continuing Care Center (EGCCC), In Edmonton, Alberta CanadaIntegrative Literature ReviewEngaging in physical activity is good for both physical wellbeing but also mental health. It supports the prevention of both physical and psychological problems and brings an improvement in the overall quality of life for a person. This paper aims to

American Psycho in His Seminal Work American
Words: 2804 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

American Psycho In his seminal work American Psycho, Bret Easton Ellis uses the character of the yuppie serial killer Patrick Bateman in order to criticize American consumer culture while simultaneously challenging the reader to confront his or her own responses to that culture, responses that Ellis seems to suggest are only removed from the sociopathic actions of Bateman in a manner of degree, rather than kind. To see how Ellis uses

Communicating with Patients in Healthcare
Words: 1057 Length: 4 Document Type: Question Answers

Q1. What positive and negative impacts do chronic health conditions have on someone's view of their selves?Although almost patients at some point in their lives find themselves suffering some degree of sickness and ill health, experiencing a chronic illness, especially when someone is young, can put the patient outside of the normal growth trajectory of someone in their age group, psychologically as well as physically. Chronic illnesses can foster a

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now