Verified Document

Oversight And Regulation Of Financial Institutions Article Critique

Oversight & Regulation of Financial Institutions In the article entitled "How Financial Oversight Failed & What it May Portend for the Future of Regulation," economist Richard J. Herring identifies the government policies he believes contributed to the current financial crisis. These policies include:

Credit rating outsourcing.

Government housing.

The call for investment banks to form holding companies.

Basel I and Basel II minimum capital requirements.

After describing the policies and the financial repercussions of each in detail, Herring presents three arguments in favor of the policies, followed by three refutations of these arguments. From there, Herring goes on to address the principal/agent problems surrounding the financial crisis in both the private and public sectors, and then concludes with the description of two incentive plans -- contingent capital and resolution policy -- he believes will encourage "greater market discipline" (Herring, 2010).

Regarding credit rating outsourcing, Herring argues that outsourcing caused a "regulatory-induced increase in the demand for highly rated assets . . . [of] investment grade or higher" (Herring, 2010). The result of this demand was an imposed pressure on credit rating organizations (CROs) to rate institutions more liberally than they otherwise might have been inclined to. An institution whose credit rating would at one time have been rated average or slightly below average, was then being rated as slightly above average, which in turn skewed the perception of the institution's stability or lack thereof, resulting in a rapid decline credit rating standards. It is here that Herring puts forth his thesis statement: "What began as an attempt to improve the supervision of credit risk ultimately had the unintended consequence of exposing the financial system to a devastating credit shock" (Herring, 2010).

Regarding the government housing policy, Herring argues that imposed...

Add to this the emergence of "Fair Lending Best Practices Agreements" in 1994, and it was suddenly possible for low-income families to purchase to homes they would otherwise never have been able to afford -- and in reality, could not afford. Says Herring of the government housing policy:
A series of presumably well-intentioned government programs to meet the housing aspirations of poor Americans (albeit, by compelling other entities to subsidize the loans) led to a huge decline in the quality of mortgages issued in America. Rather than helping poor Americans to buy housing they could not afford by subsidizing down-payments, (which would have had to be reflected as an expenditure on the Federal budget) Congress and two Administrations chose to make it possible for lower income Americans to become very highly leveraged, which, of course, left them highly vulnerable to any decline in their own incomes or any fall in housing prices. The only way such lending could have been sustainable was to project a high rate of growth in housing prices into the indefinite future, an assumption that now looks hopelessly naive, but was widespread. Thus government housing policy intended to help the poor led to a personal catastrophe for many of the intended beneficiaries and a financial crisis that quickly became global. (Herring, 2010)

Meanwhile, investment banks responded to the European-imposed pressure to form holding companies by pushing for the Securities Exchange Commission (SEC) to be recognized as equivalent to the Federal Reserve as a regulatory body. Unfortunately, the SEC had neither the necessary experience or even the interest in assuming responsibility for investment bank regulations, hence the widespread failure of…

Sources used in this document:
References

Herring, R.J. (July 8, 2010). "How Financial Oversight Failed & What it May Portend for the Future of Regulation." International Atlantic Economic Society, 38, 265-282.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Regulatory Compliance for Financial Institutions
Words: 2184 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Regulatory Compliance for Financial Institutions: Implementation of a GLBA-Complaint Information Security Program The objective of this work in writing is to examine the implementation of a GLBA-complaint information security program. Objectives of the Information Security Program The Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA) makes a requirement of financial institutions to "develop, implement, and maintain a comprehensive written information security program that protects the privacy and integrity of customer records. GLBA mandates emphasize the need for each

Financial Derivatives This Study Emphasized the Importance
Words: 3145 Length: 10 Document Type: Thesis

Financial Derivatives This study emphasized the importance roles of financial derivatives, which has been known for the last decade and its effects on the Global financial crisis. It further analyzes the impact of financial derivatives and how it can be controlled to prevent corporations from incurring a lot of risks. It also explains the existence of financial derivatives since 1970, to the recent Global Financial Crisis which occurred in the 2006. Risk

Financial Statement Analysis Ambiguity and
Words: 871 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

This has been especially true in China and other Asian countries during the past several decades of economic expansion in that region of the world (Bai et al. 2008). Government stakeholders in many of these countries have benefited along with corporations in obscure and outright false financial statements and analyses as they have attracted money form foreign as well as domestic investors an enabled national growth for many Asian

Financial Derivatives on Sub-Prime Crisis
Words: 9921 Length: 30 Document Type: Dissertation

The article that was written by Conley (2011) discusses the impact that collateralized debt obligations (CDO's) would have upon the subprime loans. These were created in 1987, by the Wall Street firm Drexel Burnham. In this product, the investment bankers would take a number of different articles and combine them together as one investment. The various assets that were used included: junk bonds, mortgages and other high yielding investments from

Financial Strategies of Healthcare Organization
Words: 3659 Length: 12 Document Type: Essay

Develop a financial strategy for using global nursing strategies to increase fiscal responsibility. Include the positive and negative financial impact of bringing foreign healthcare providers into a financial organization. Examples such as physicians, nurses, and therapist should be evaluated and assessed for financial viability. Healthcare institutions may be faced with fiscal constraints at some point in their growth process therefore necessitating austerity measures and sound business practices that will help minimize

Financial Crisis and Its Impacts
Words: 3393 Length: 10 Document Type: Thesis

The second purpose of the $700 purchase of troubled assets is to create a market for the securitized versions of these assets. As a result of the crisis, the market for these assets became illiquid. The value of securitized debt obligations became near zero, which severely impacted the balance sheet of all banks that held these assets. By creating a secondary market for these products, the government hopes to increase

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now